Maximal response to a mechanical leader at critical group size in ant collectives

Atanu Chatterjee, Tom Tzook, Nir Gov, Ofer Feinerman · 2025

Read Maximal response to a mechanical leader at critical group size in ant collectives by Atanu Chatterjee, Tom Tzook, Nir Gov, Ofer Feinerman (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-01209.txt.

Introduction

Atanu Chatterjee and co-authors test how ant groups respond to a mechanical leader in work from 2025. Living collectives are thought to sit near a critical point where response to outside signals is strongest.

The team recorded longhorn crazy ants carrying food to their nest. A robot applied tiny tactile forces like a short-lived leader, at group sizes below, near, and above the critical size. At the critical size, the group response to the force was amplified the most. Theory and simulations back the result, giving direct proof of the criticality idea in a living collective.

Catalog record

CREATORAtanu Chatterjee, Tom Tzook, Nir Gov, Ofer Feinerman
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE62 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-01209

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Maximal response to a mechanical leader at critical group size in ant collectives Atanu Chatterjee, Tom Tzook, Nir Gov, Ofer Feinerman Abstract It is widely recognized that biological collectives operate near criticality to amplify their capability of collective response. The peak in susceptibility near criticality renders these groups highly responsive to external stimuli. While this phenomenon has been recognized and supported by evidence from theory, a direct experimental demonstration has been elusive. To bridge this gap, here we record the response of a group of Paratrechina longicornis ants to external stimuli as they join efforts to carry food to their nest. Using a robotic system that mimics a transient leader, we apply tactile ant-scale forces and measure the group’s response at sub, near, and supercritical regimes. Supported by theory and simulations, we provide direct experimental evidence to demonstrate that at critical group size, the collective response of the ants to an external force is maximally amplified. Introduction Collective behavior in biological systems represents one of nature’s most fascinating and ubiquitous phenomena. From the flocking of birds and schooling of fish to the coordinated firing patterns in the brain, these ensembles are a testament to the complexity of life Vicsek et al. 1995 ; Toner and Tu 1995 ; Toner and Tu 1998 ; Vicsek 2008 ; Giardina 2008 ; Cavagna et al. 2010 ; Ariel and Ayali 2015 ; Sarfati et al. 2021 . Exploring these systems offers more than just an understanding of biological complexity; it provides a distinctive perspective on the intricate interactions that dictate the behavior of wholes that are made up of numerous interacting components. A key characteristic of biological groups is that they display emergent collective states that are often highly coordinated and display long-range order Vicsek et al. 1995 ; Toner and Tu 1995 ; Toner and Tu 1998 . It has been shown that some groups can maintain multiple distinct collective states and can switch between these states depending on group size, density, boundary conditions, or random fluctuations Tunstrøm et al. 2013 ; Gelblum et al. 2015 ; Ariel and Ayali 2015 ; Gelblum et al. 2016 ; Ron et al. 2018 ; Ayalon et al. 2021 . Moreover, emerging evidence suggests that many of these systems operate near the transition between different collective-level states Mora and Bialek 2011 ; Attanasi et al. 2014 ; Hidalgo et al. 2014 ; Chaté and Muñoz 2014 ; Bialek et al. 2014 ; Calovi et al. 2015 ; Poel et al. 2022 ; Gómez-Nava et al. 2023 . Over the past decades, statistical physics has offered tools for studying self-organization and the emergence of order in biological collectives Mora and Bialek 2011 ; Attanasi et al. 2014 ; Romanczuk and Daniels 2023 . Additionally, physical phases provide intuition regarding the coexistence of different collective states in a single biological system. Even more interesting, statistical physics offers possible reasoning for the fact that biological ensembles are poised at a transition between collective states. Indeed, it is known that, in such transition regions, physical systems display critical phenomena such as long-range correlations and increased susceptibility to external perturbation Cipra 1987 ; Landau and Lifshitz 2013 . These properties are interesting from a biological perspective since they allow the group to react quickly and cohesively to changing environmental conditions Bonabeau 1997 ; Romanczuk et al. 2009 ; Poel et al. 2022 ; Romanczuk and Daniels 2023 . Consequently, studies ranging from regulatory interactions among proteins in cells to neurons interacting in brains to collective behavior in social insects, fish schools, bird flocks, humans, and mammals have hypothesized that complex biological collectives might operate near criticality to enhance sensitivity to external stimuli and maximize collective computational capabilities Pawson and Nash 2003 ; Couzin et al. 2003 ; Sumpter 2006 ; Mora and Bialek 2011 ; Couzin 2009 ; Romanczuk et al. 2009 ; Calovi et al. 2015 ; Feinerman et al. 2018 ; Romanczuk and Daniels 2023 ; Gómez-Nava et al. 2023 . Despite these theoretical predictions, experimentally testing the hypothesis that complex biological collectives may operate near criticality has been very challenging. Bridging the gap between theoretical predictions and empirical evidence encounters a substantial hurdle due to the lack of direct measurements of how a biological group responds to changes in a specific control parameter close to the transition regime. This challenge is only compounded by the critical point being precisely defined only in the thermodynamic limit Cipra 1987 ; Landau and Lifshitz 2013 . Additionally, there is evidence that many biological collectives may override control parameters and continuously self-tune to remain near a critical-like state, making it difficult to probe the transition between the different phases Schneidman et al. 2006 ; Couzin 2009 ; Attanasi et al. 2014 ; Mora and Bialek 2011 ; Ariel and Ayali 2015 ; Poel et al. 2022 ; Klamser and Romanczuk 2021 . Finally, identifying what precisely stimulates a biological collective poses an additional layer of complexity. The potential cues can widely range from visual to chemical, tactile to auditory, or even a combination of these factors Procaccini et al. 2011 ; Rosenthal et al. 2015 ; Mathijssen et al. 2019 ; Bastien and Romanczuk 2020 . As a result, although indirect evidence suggests increased susceptibility in biological ensembles near the transition between collective states, direct empirical evidence remains very limited and sparse. Therefore, while criticality offers a compelling framework for understanding the relationship between self-organization and biological functionality, it remains a topic of ongoing investigation that requires further empirical validation across diverse biological contexts Bedard et al. 2006 ; Beggs and Timme 2012 . In this work, we provide the first direct demonstration of increased susceptibility in the transition between two collective states. We do this in the context of cooperative transport by longhorn crazy ants ( Paratrechina longicornis ), where we show that when the groups’ collective motion is at the transition between distinct collective states, it is most sensitive to single-ant scale perturbations. More specifically, during cooperative transport, these ants gather to collectively haul a load that is too heavy for any of them to move on their own Czaczkes and Ratnieks 2013 ; McCreery and Breed 2014 . It has been previously shown that the hauling group can assume one of two collective states – one in which the load moves ballistically and another where the collective motion resembles a random walk Gelblum et al. 2015 ; Feinerman et al. 2018 . Further, it has been demonstrated that, in natural conditions, the group resides near the transition between these two order-disorder collective states. The biological relevance of this is crucial, as its criticality and enhanced sensitivity allow carrying groups to be maximally responsive to information brought in by spatially informed leader ants and successfully navigate toward their nest Gelblum et al. 2015 . Finally, cooperative transport in this species can be mapped to excellent quantitative and qualitative agreement to an Ising spin model. This mapping reveals that the transition between collective motion states in the finite-sized ant system corresponds to the critical transition between magnetized and non-magnetized states in the Ising model, which represent the ordered and disordered phases of the ants, respectively, in the thermodynamic limit \left(N\rightarrow\infty\right)

Read the complete text