Correlation Functions and Chaotic Behavior of the SYK Chain Model in Pure States

Seyyed M.H. Halataei · 2025

Read Correlation Functions and Chaotic Behavior of the SYK Chain Model in Pure States by Seyyed M.H. Halataei (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-01100.txt.

Introduction

A chain of quantum islands, each scrambling information in the SYK style, may not scramble as evenly as it first seemed. Halataei studies that puzzle in this 2025 paper, looking at single energy states rather than warm mixtures. Earlier work on entanglement in the chain hinted at slow settling for some starting states, blamed on heavy modes.

Exact computer diagonalization tells a split story here. Two-point correlations in single states match their thermal counterparts closely, and information scrambling runs efficiently inside those pure states. So the slowness seen in entanglement does not spread to every probe. The author weighs what that split means for the model's mirror description in gravity theory. Different probes, the paper warns, can tell different thermal stories.

Catalog record

CREATORSeyyed M.H. Halataei
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-01100

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Correlation Functions and Chaotic Behavior of the SYK Chain Model in Pure States Seyyed M.H. Halataei Abstract Recent investigations of Rényi entanglement entropy in the SYK chain of Majorana fermions have indicated that the model exhibits slow thermalization when initialized in certain states. The extent to which the heavy modes–believed to underlie this behavior–affect other aspects of the model remains an open question. In this work, I study thermalization and scrambling of information in individual energy eigenstates of the SYK chain using exact diagonalization. I show that two-point correlation functions in finite-energy eigenstates closely match their thermal counterparts and that information scrambling occurs efficiently within these pure states. These results suggest that the slow thermalization observed in entanglement dynamics does not extend to all probes of thermalization and scrambling, even in pure states. I discuss the implications of these findings for thermal states in a potential holographic dual theory. I Introduction Chaotic quantum many-body systems are generally expected to thermalize rapidly, even in the absence of external reservoirs. The eigenstate thermalization hypothesis (ETH) provides a framework for understanding this phenomenon Deutsch1991 ; Srednicki1994 ; Srednicki1996 . ETH posits that for generic observables, the expectation values in individual energy eigenstates are consistent with thermal averages, implying that a pure state far from equilibrium will evolve such that its observables approach and remain close to thermal values for most of the time. However, recent investigations of Rényi entanglement entropy in maximally chaotic systems have revealed exceptions to this picture. In particular, a one-dimensional generalization of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model–the SYK chain–was found to exhibit slow thermalization when initialized in specific states Gu2017b ; Gu2017 . The role of so-called heavy modes, which are believed to underlie this slow dynamics, and their influence on other observables has been identified as an open question Gu2017b . In a recent companion study Halataei2025ETH , I examined ETH in the SYK chain and in two-site SYK models, demonstrating that they satisfy ETH at finite size and thus thermalize rapidly. The present work extends that investigation by analyzing additional probes of thermalization and information scrambling in the SYK chain. Specifically, I study two-point and four-point correlation functions in energy eigenstates, as well as the spectral form factor. The SYK chain is a one-dimensional lattice model with quenched disorder, in which each site hosts N Majorana fermions subject to random four-fermion interactions Gu2017 . Neighboring sites are coupled via random bilinear interactions. This model inherits several important features from the original, zero-dimensional SYK model Kitaev2015 ; Maldacena2016 , including local criticality, an extensive zero-temperature entropy, and maximal chaos. It also displays additional features such as diffusive energy transport and a butterfly velocity that characterizes the spatial spread of chaos Gu2017 . From a condensed matter perspective, the SYK chain is a rare example of a solvable, strongly interacting, chaotic lattice model–offering a tractable platform for studying thermalization, entanglement propagation, many-body localization, and quantum transport. From the viewpoint of holography, the SYK chain has been conjectured to be dual to an incoherent black hole Gu2017 . Since the SYK chain is a closed, unitary system, understanding its thermalization dynamics may yield insights into black hole formation and evaporation, and thereby inform broader discussions surrounding the black hole information paradox Hawking1976 . 1 1 1 For recent developments in resolving the information paradox, see Penington2020 ; Almheiri2019a ; Almheiri2020a ; Almheiri2019b ; Almheiri2020b ; Almheiri2020c ; Alishahiha2021 ; Bousso2020 ; Saad2021 . In this work, I examine the spectral form factor, and two- and four-point correlation functions in energy eigenstates of the SYK chain. I perform ensemble averaging over disorder realizations for three different coupling regimes. Using exact diagonalization, I find that these observables in pure states closely resemble their thermal counterparts and that the spectral form factor shows qualitative agreement with predictions from random matrix theory (RMT). These results indicate that the slow thermalization observed in entanglement dynamics Gu2017b does not necessarily extend to all probes of thermalization and scrambling, even in pure states. A discussion of the apparent tension with conclusions drawn from Rényi entropy is presented in the final section. Previous studies have established thermal behavior in two-point functions and scrambling indicators in the complex SYK model, which features all-to-all interactions and no spatial structure Sonner2017 . The extent to which spatial locality and the absence of all-to-all couplings modify thermalization dynamics remains a key question Hunter2018 . The present results suggest that, in the analytically tractable regime considered, spatial locality does not obstruct thermalization or scrambling of information in the SYK chain. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section II reviews the SYK chain model. Section III outlines the numerical implementation, including the construction of the Hamiltonian, the choice of parameter regimes, and the few-body operators used in this study, along with their thermal expectation values. Section IV presents the results for two- and four-point functions in energy eigenstates and for the spectral form factor. Finally, Section V summarizes the findings, discusses their implications, and compares them with the entanglement-based study. II Background The SYK chain model Gu2017 is a higher-dimensional generalization of the original Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model Kitaev2015 ; Maldacena2016 . In this section, I first provide a brief overview of the original SYK model before describing the structure and properties of the SYK chain model. The original SYK model is an ensemble-averaged theory defined by N Majorana fermions with random all-to-all quartic interactions. The Hamiltonian for a single realization of the ensemble is given by H=\sum_{1\leqslant i<j<k<l\leqslant N}J_{ijkl}\ \chi_{i}\chi_{j}\chi_{k}\chi_{l} (1) where the Majorana fermion operators satisfy the Clifford algebra \{\chi_{i},\chi_{j}\}=\delta_{ij} (2) and the couplings {J_{ijkl}} are independent real Gaussian random variables with mean and variance \overline{J_{ijkl}}=0,\qquad\qquad\overline{J_{ijkl}^{2}}=\frac{3!J^{2}}{N^{3}}. (3) Here, J sets the overall energy scale of the interactions. The model becomes solvable in the large- N limit and exhibits a number of remarkable features at strong coupling ( N\gg\beta J\gg 1 ), including extensive zero-temperature entropy, local quantum criticality characterized by power-law temporal correlations, and maximal chaos. In this regime, the disorder-averaged theory displays emergent conformal symmetry and a duality to nearly- \mathrm{AdS}_{2} gravity. However, being a (0+1) -dimensional model, it lacks spatial structure and therefore cannot realize phenomena such as diffusion or spatially propagating chaos (the butterfly effect). To introduce spatial locality, Gu et al. Gu2017 proposed a (1+1) -dimensional generalization, known as the SYK chain model. This model consists of a one-dimensional lattice of M SYK sites (also referred to as “links”), with each site containing N Majorana fermions and interacting with its nearest neighbors via quartic interactions. The structure is illustrated in Fig. 1 . Figure 1: SYK chain model. The model consists of M sites with periodic boundary conditions. Each site contains N Majorana fermions with on-site SYK interactions. Neighboring sites interact via quartic terms involving two fermions from each site. (Graphic adapted from Gu2017 ) In this paper, I focus on the SYK chain model. Like its (0+1) -dimensional counterpart, the SYK chain is defined as an ensemble-averaged theory. The Hamiltonian for a single realization takes the form \displaystyle H \displaystyle= \displaystyle\sum_{x=1}^{M}\ \sum_{1\leqslant i<j<k<l\leqslant N}J_{ijkl,x}\ \chi_{i,x}\chi_{j,x}\chi_{k,x}\chi_{l,x} (4) \displaystyle+ \displaystyle\sum_{x=1}^{M}\ \sum_{\begin{subarray}{c}1\leqslant i<j\leqslant N\\ 1\leqslant k<l\leqslant N\end{subarray}}J^{\prime}_{ijkl,x}\ \chi_{i,x}\chi_{j,x}\chi_{k,x+1}\chi_{l,x+1} where J_{ijkl,x} and J^{\prime}_{ijkl,x} are independent zero-mean Gaussian random couplings with

Read the complete text