On the class-breadth conjecture This research was supported by the Russian Science Foundation under grant no. 22-11-00075.
Alexander Skutin · 2025
Read On the class-breadth conjecture This research was supported by the Russian Science Foundation under grant no. 22-11-00075. by Alexander Skutin (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00952.txt.
Introduction
Alexander Skutin, in a 2025 math paper, takes up the class-breadth conjecture for groups built from a prime power. The conjecture caps a group's nilpotency class by its breadth plus one. Counterexamples are known when the prime is two, but the case of odd primes stays open. Skutin's article is devoted to that general odd-prime case, which makes it a focused attack on one of group theory's standing questions.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Alexander Skutin |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 18 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00952
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the class-breadth conjecture This research was supported by the Russian Science Foundation under grant no. 22-11-00075. Alexander Skutin Abstract The class-breadth conjecture of Leedham-Green, Neumann and Wiegold states that for each p p -group, c l ( G ) ≤ b ( G ) + 1 cl(G)\leq b(G)+1 , where c l ( G ) cl(G) , b ( G ) b(G) denote the nilpotency class and the breadth of G G . While several counter-examples to this conjecture have been found for p = 2 p=2 , it is still open in general for p > 2 p>2 . This article is dedicated to one simplified version of the conjecture for p > 2 p>2 . 1 Introduction Let G be a finite p -group. The breadth b(x) of an element x of a group G is defined as b(x):=\log_{p}|G:Z_{G}(x)| , where Z_{G}(x) denotes the centralizer of x in G . The breadth b(G) of G is defined as \displaystyle b(G):=\max_{g\in G}b(g) . C. Leedham-Green, P. Neumann and J. Wiegold in [ 7 ] stated the following conjecture: cl(G)\leq b(G)+1 , for all p -groups G ( cl(G) denotes the nilpotency class of G ). W. Felsch, J. Neubüser and W. Plesken in [ 3 ] provide the series of counter-examples to the conjecture for p=2 . Further counter-examples were found by B. Eick, M. Newman and E. O’Brien in [ 2 ] , in [ 2 ] they also proved that the analogue of the conjecture for finite dimensional nilpotent Lie algebras is false for all finite fields, i.e., that for every finite field \mathbb{F} there exists a finite dimensional nilpotent Lie algebra \mathfrak{g} over \mathbb{F} such that cl(\mathfrak{g})>b(\mathfrak{g})+1 , where \displaystyle b(\mathfrak{g}):=\max_{a\in\mathfrak{g}}(\dim\mathfrak{g}-\dim Z_{\mathfrak{g}}(a)) , Z_{\mathfrak{g}}(a):=\{x\in\mathfrak{g}\>|\>[a,x]=0\} . The conjecture has been proved in some special cases, see, for example: if b(G)\leq 4 in [ 6 , 8 ] , if b(G)\leq p+1 in [ 4 ] , if G is a p -group of maximal class in [ 1 ] , if G is metabelian in [ 7 ] , if G is not covered by its two-step centralizers in [ 7 ] . See also [ 2 ] for more classes of p -groups satisfying the conjecture. A more detailed description of the results related to the class-breadth conjecture can be found in the introduction of [ 3 ] . This note is dedicated to the general case p>2 of the conjecture. The author thanks A. M. Maksaev for the introduction to the topic by suggesting the problem [ 9 , Problem 4.69] and Y. V. Novikova for discussions that led to this article. The author thanks the Theoretical Physics and Mathematics Advancement Foundation “BASIS”. 2 Main theorem Consider a p -group G . The commutator [x,y],x,y\in G is x^{-1}y^{-1}xy . For each subgroups G_{1},G_{2} of G , denote by [G_{1},G_{2}] the subgroup of G which is generated with the set of elements \{[g_{1},g_{2}]\>|\>g_{1}\in G_{1},g_{2}\in G_{2}\} . For each element g\in G and each subgroup H of G , denote b_{H}(g):=\log_{p}|H:H\cap Z_{G}(g)| , [g,H]:=\{[g,h]\>|\>h\in H\} , \displaystyle Z_{G}(H):=\bigcap_{h\in H}Z_{G}(h) , \gamma_{1}(H):=H , \gamma_{i+1}(H):=[\gamma_{i}(H),H] , i\geq 1 – denotes the lower central series of H . So b_{H}(g)=\log_{p}|[g,H]| . For each subset X of G , denote by \langle X\rangle the subgroup of G which is generated with the set X . The main result of this article is the following Theorem 1: Theorem 1 . Let p>2 be a prime number. Consider arbitrary integers n\geq 0 , m\geq 1 , an arbitrary p -group G , and any normal subgroups H,C_{1},C_{2},\ldots,C_{p-1} of G that satisfies: 1. C_{i}\subsetneq H , \forall 1\leq i\leq p-1 (i.e. C_{1},C_{2},\ldots,C_{p-1} are proper subgroups of H ), 2. \displaystyle\max_{g\in H\setminus\left(\bigcup_{i=1}^{p-1}C_{i}\right)}b_{\gamma_{m}(H)}(g)\leq n . Then there exists a normal subgroup N of G such that: 1. N\subseteq H , 2. \log_{p}|H:N|\leq n , 3. cl(N)\leq n+m , 4. \displaystyle N\nsubseteq\bigcup_{i=1}^{p-1}C_{i} . As a consequence, for each p -group G\not=\{e\} with p>2 , after the application of Theorem 1 to n=b(G) , m=1 , G , H=G , C_{1}=C_{2}=\ldots=C_{p-1}=\{e\} , the following simplified version of the class-breadth conjecture can be proved: Theorem 2 . Let p>2 be a prime number. Consider a p -group G\not=\{e\} . Then there exists a normal subgroup N of G such that \log_{p}|G:N|\leq b(G) and cl(N)\leq b(G)+1 . Lemma 1 . Let G be a p -group. Consider any normal subgroups C_{1} , C_{2} of G such that C_{1}\subseteq C_{2} . Let P:=\{g\in G\>|\>[g,C_{2}]\subseteq[C_{1},G]\} . Then 1. \{g\in G\>|\>b_{C_{1}}(g)\geq b_{C_{2}}(g)\}\subseteq P , 2. P is a normal subgroup of G . Moreover if C_{1} , C_{2} are characteristic subgroups of G , then P is also characteristic in G , 3. if P=G , then [C_{1},G]=[C_{2},G] . Proof. To prove 1, notice that b_{C_{1}}(g)\leq b_{C_{2}}(g) , \forall g\in G , therefore, if g\in\{g\in G\>|\>b_{C_{1}}(g)\geq b_{C_{2}}(g)\} , then b_{C_{1}}(g)=b_{C_{2}}(g) and [g,C_{2}]=[g,C_{1}]\subseteq[C_{1},G] , so g\in P . To prove 2 notice that P=\pi^{-1}(Z_{\pi(G)}(\pi(C_{2}))) , where \pi:G\to G/[C_{1},G] denotes the homomorphism of factorization. To prove 3, notice that if P=G , then [C_{1},G]\subseteq[C_{2},G]=[G,C_{2}]\subseteq[C_{1},G] . ∎ Lemma 2 . Let G be a p -group. Consider any normal subgroups C_{1} , C_{2} of G such that C_{1}\subsetneq C_{2} . Then there exists a normal subgroup C_{3} of G such that C_{1}\subseteq C_{3}\subseteq C_{2} and |C_{2}:C_{3}|=p . Proof. Consider the subgroup C_{1}[C_{2},G]:=\langle\{xy\>|\>x\in C_{1},y\in[C_{2},G]\}\rangle of G . Easy to check that C_{1}[C_{2},G] is a normal subgroup of G and C_{1}[C_{2},G]\subseteq C_{2} . From C_{1}\subsetneq C_{2} , it follows that \{e\}\subsetneq C_{2}/C_{1}\subseteq G/C_{1} , therefore, since G/C_{1} is nilpotent, C_{1}[C_{2},G]=[C_{2}/C_{1},G/C_{1}]C_{1}\subsetneq C_{2} . Consider any maximal under the inclusion proper subgroup C_{3} of C_{2} such that C_{1}[C_{2},G]\subseteq C_{3} . Then (from maximality of C_{3} in C_{2} ) |C_{2}:C_{3}|=p . From [C_{3},G]\subseteq[C_{2},G]\subseteq C_{1}[C_{2},G]\subseteq C_{3} and C_{1}\subseteq C_{1}[C_{2},G]\subseteq C_{3} , it follows that C_{3} is a normal subgroup of G that satisfies C_{1}\subseteq C_{3}\subseteq C_{2} and |C_{2}:C_{3}|=p . ∎ Lemma 3 . Let G be a p -group. Consider any normal subgroups H , C_{1} , C_{2} of G such that C_{1}\not=C_{2} , C_{1},C_{2}\subseteq H , and |H:C_{1}|=|H:C_{2}|=p . Then each subgroup C of H that satisfies C_{1}\cap C_{2}\subseteq C is normal in G . Proof. For each 1\leq i\leq 2 , consider the homomorphism of factorization \pi_{i}:G\to G/C_{i} . From |H:C_{1}|=|H:C_{2}|=p , it follows that \pi_{i}(H) is a normal subgroup of \pi_{i}(G) of order p , therefore \pi_{i}(H)\subseteq Z(\pi_{i}(G)) and [H,G]\subseteq C_{i} , \forall 1\leq i\leq 2 . So [C,G]\subseteq[H,G]\subseteq C_{1}\cap C_{2}\subseteq C and C is normal in G . ∎ Lemma 4 . Let G be a p -group. Consider any proper subgroups C_{1},C_{2},\ldots,C_{p} of G such that C_{1}\not=C_{2} and |G:C_{1}|=|G:C_{2}|=p . Then there exists a normal subgroup C of G such that |G:C|=p , C\cap C_{1}=C\cap C_{2}=C_{1}\cap C_{2} , and C\nsubseteq C_{i} , \forall 1\leq i\leq p . Proof. From |G:C_{1}|=|G:C_{2}|=p , C_{1}\not=C_{2} , it follows that C_{1},C_{2} are normal subgroups of G and G/(C_{1}\cap C_{2})\cong\mathbb{Z}_{p}\oplus\mathbb{Z}_{p} . Consider the homomorphism of factorization \pi:G\to G/(C_{1}\cap C_{2}) . Assume for convenience that for an integer k\geq 2 , C_{1}\cap C_{2}\nsubseteq C_{i} , \forall 2<i\leq k and C_{1}\cap C_{2}\subseteq C_{i} , \forall i>k ( \{C_{i}\}_{2<i\leq k}=\varnothing if k=2 ). Group \mathbb{Z}_{p}\oplus\mathbb{Z}_{p} contains p+1 pairwise