Improved Risk Ratio Approximation by Complementary Log-Log Models: A Comparison with Logistic Models
Yuji Tsubota, Kenji Beppu · 2025
Read Improved Risk Ratio Approximation by Complementary Log-Log Models: A Comparison with Logistic Models by Yuji Tsubota, Kenji Beppu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00889.txt.
Introduction
Yuji Tsubota and Kenji Beppu present a 2025 statistics paper on reporting treatment effects more honestly. Logistic models give odds ratios, which drift far from the risk ratios readers actually want when outcomes are common. That drift can mislead doctors and policy makers about how big an effect is.
The pair studies a less-used model family whose effect measure, which they name the complementary log ratio, hugs the true risk ratio more closely. Inside a one-parameter family that contains both link types, they prove the new measure always carries smaller bias than the odds ratio. Simulations back the math. Since the model runs in standard software, they urge analysts to use it more often.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yuji Tsubota, Kenji Beppu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 19 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00889
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Improved Risk Ratio Approximation by Complementary Log-Log Models: A Comparison with Logistic Models Thanks: Yuji Tsubota is the corresponding author of this article. Email: [email protected] Yuji Tsubota, Kenji Beppu Abstract Abstract Odds ratios obtained from logistic models fail to approximate risk ratios with common outcomes, leading to potential misinterpretations about exposure effects by practitioners. This article investigates the complementary log-log models as a practical alternative to produce risk ratio approximation. We demonstrate that the corresponding effect measure of complementary log-log models, called the complementary log ratio in this article, consistently provides a closer approximation to risk ratios than odds ratios. To compare the approximation accuracy, we adopt the one-parameter Aranda-Ordaz family of link functions, which includes both the logit and complementary log-log link functions as special cases. Within this unified framework, we implement a theoretical comparison of approximation accuracy between the complementary log ratio and the odds ratio, showing that the former always produces smaller approximation bias. Simulation studies further reinforce our theoretical findings. Given that the complementary log-log model is easily implemented in standard statistical software such as R and SAS, we encourage more frequent use of this model as a simple and effective alternative to logistic models when the goal is to approximate risk ratios more accurately. keywords : Odds Ratios, Complementary log-log model, Risk Ratio Approximation, Aranda-Ordaz family of link functions 1 Introduction When the outcome of interest is dichotomous, odds ratios are frequently reported as a measure of exposure effects in cohort studies and randomized controlled trials ( Zhang and Kai 1998 ; Knol et al. 2011 ; VanderWeele 2020 ) . This widespread use of odds ratios comes mainly from the popularity of logistic regression analyses ( Robbins et al. 2002 ; Penman and Johnson 2009 ) . However, the interpretation of odds ratios as a measure of exposure effect is not straightforward and is often misleading ( Zhang and Kai 1998 ; Robbins et al. 2002 ; Penman and Johnson 2009 ) . With rare outcomes, odds ratios closely approximate risk ratios, enabling a straightforward interpretation of exposure effects as risk ratios. On the other hand, such an interpretation is no longer valid when the outcome is common ( VanderWeele 2020 ) . A substantial body of research has pointed out the problem of misinterpreting odds ratios as risk ratios in practice with common outcomes ( Zhang and Kai 1998 ; Altman et al. 1998 ; Robbins et al. 2002 ; Knol et al. 2011 ; Knol et al. 2012 ; VanderWeele 2020 , e.g.,) . Zhang and Kai 1998 visually illustrated that, when true risk ratios are greater (or less) than 1 , the corresponding odds ratios always overestimate (or underestimate) the values of risk ratios. Resulting deviations of odds ratios from risk ratios become significant when the outcome prevalence is greater than 10\% ( Zhang and Kai 1998 ; Knol et al. 2012 ; Hosmer Jr et al. 2013 ) . Therefore, existing literature tends to use 10\% as a cutoff outcome prevalence where odds ratios can be safely interpreted as risk ratios ( Robbins et al. 2002 ; Hosmer Jr et al. 2013 ) . Several studies have suggested alternative approaches for estimating covariate-adjusted exposure effects on binary outcomes ( Zhang and Kai 1998 ; Zou 2004 ; Penman and Johnson 2009 ; Richardson et al. 2017 ) . However, each alternative approach has its own limitations and drawbacks, such as convergence issues, inability to accommodate interactions, or theoretical complexity. Moreover, among such studies, there has been limited investigation of other standard binary generalized linear models ( Nelder and Wedderburn 1972 , GLMs;) except for log-binomial models that directly estimate risk ratios ( Penman and Johnson 2009 ) . In this article, we investigate the potential utility of a less-utilized binary GLM, complementary log-log models ( Fisher 1922 ) , in approximating risk ratios. We compare odds ratios with the corresponding estimand of complementary log-log models, and show that the latter estimand is always a better approximation of risk ratios than odds ratios. In our mathematical proof, we introduce the one-parameter family of link functions proposed by Aranda-Ordaz 1981 that contains logit and complementary log-log link functions as special cases. Following the framework by Aranda-Ordaz 1981 , we can express odds ratios and the corresponding estimand of complementary log-log models in a unified way, thereby enhancing the clarity and brevity of our mathematical derivation. The present article does not argue against the direct estimation of risk ratios. In fact, it is generally preferable when such estimation is stable and permits valid inference. However, it can involve complex modeling or computational challenges ( Williamson et al. 2013 ) . To address these difficulties, our goal is to suggest a more accessible and practical alternative based on standard GLMs. The remainder of this paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces the Aranda-Ordaz transformation family, preparing essential theoretical groundwork for the mathematical analyses in later sections. In Section 3 , we provide a theoretical comparison of approximation accuracy between odds ratios and the corresponding effect measures of complementary log-log models within this framework. Section 4 presents concluding remarks. All technical proofs are provided in the Supplementary Materials. 2 Setup 2.1 Binary Effect Measures in GLM literature Let A be a binary exposure and Y be a binary outcome of interest. Define p_{1}=P(Y=1|A=1) and p_{0}=P(Y=1|A=0) denoting the probability of having the outcome when exposed and unexposed, respectively. Given specific values of p_{1} and p_{0} , the risk ratio \mathrm{RR} is defined by \mathrm{RR}=p_{1}/p_{0} . Additionally, we define the odds ratio \mathrm{OR} and complementary log ratio \mathrm{CLR} for p_{1} and p_{0} respectively as \displaystyle\mathrm{OR}=\frac{p_{1}/(1-p_{1})}{p_{0}/(1-p_{0})},\quad\mathrm{CLR}=\frac{\log(1-p_{1})}{\log(1-p_{0})}. (1) Analogous to the odds ratio, we term the corresponding effect measure from complementary log-log models the “complementary log ratio”. The definition of complementary log ratios in ( 1 ) expresses the effect of exposure as a power function ( Agresti 2010 ; Agresti 2012 ) . Additionally, the same expression as complementary log ratios has appeared as an alternative expression of hazard ratios in some literature ( Agresti 2010 ; VanderWeele 2020 ) . When the outcome is rare, for example, both p_{1} and p_{0} are less than or equal to 0.1 , it is not difficult to see \mathrm{OR}\approx\mathrm{RR} ( Hosmer Jr et al. 2013 ) . On the other hand, for \mathrm{CLR} , Maclaurin expansions of the numerator and the denominator give the approximation relationship \mathrm{CLR}\approx\mathrm{RR} with relatively rare outcomes ( VanderWeele 2020 ) . The above approximations hold for small outcome prevalence, but the values of \mathrm{OR} and \mathrm{CLR} significantly diverge from that of \mathrm{RR} when the outcome is common ( VanderWeele 2020 ) . 2.2 The family of Aranda-Ordaz transformations Because both the logistic and complementary log-log models belong to the Aranda-Ordaz family of transformations ( Aranda-Ordaz 1981 ) , we introduce this parametric family as a unifying framework. This unified framework enables systematic comparisons between logistic and complementary log-log models, facilitating theoretical analyses of how closely each model can approximate risk ratios through varying a transformation parameter. Aranda-Ordaz 1981 considers the following family of transformations, which includes both logistic and complementary log-log models: \displaystyle W_{\lambda}(\theta):=\begin{cases}\{(1-\theta)^{-\lambda}-1\}/{\lambda},&\text{when }0<\lambda\leq 1,\\ -\log(1-\theta),&\text{when }\lambda=0.\end{cases} where 0<\theta<1 denotes the probability of