Many Will Enter, Few Will Win: Cost and Sensitivity of Exploratory Dynamics

Elena F. Koslover, Milo M. Lin, Rob Phillips · 2025

Read Many Will Enter, Few Will Win: Cost and Sensitivity of Exploratory Dynamics by Elena F. Koslover, Milo M. Lin, Rob Phillips (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00775.txt.

Introduction

Elena Koslover, Milo Lin, and Rob Phillips weigh the costs of search inside cells in this 2025 paper. Many cell systems find targets by blind trial, looping back to the start after each miss. That looping burns energy, yet it buys sharp responses to tiny changes.

Two case studies carry the argument. In protein building, a driven step helps the ribosome tell right parts from near-right fakes. In cell skeleton growth, reset loops let a trace catalyst steer length. Path counting and circuit maps price the futile loops in each case. Mild driving, they show, already flips a system into a keen response mode at modest cost.

Catalog record

CREATORElena F. Koslover, Milo M. Lin, Rob Phillips
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE91 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00775

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Many Will Enter, Few Will Win: Cost and Sensitivity of Exploratory Dynamics Elena F. Koslover, Milo M. Lin, Rob Phillips Abstract A variety of biomolecular systems rely on exploratory dynamics to reach target locations or states within a cell. Without a mechanism to remotely sense and direct motion towards a target, the system must sample over many paths, often including resetting transitions back to the origin. We explore how exploratory dynamics can confer an important functional benefit: the ability to respond to small changes in parameters with large shifts in the steady-state behavior. However, such enhanced sensitivity comes at a cost: resetting cycles require energy dissipation in order to push the system out of its equilibrium steady state. We focus on two concrete examples: translational proofreading in the ribosome and microtubule length control via dynamic instability to illustrate the trade-offs between energetic cost and sensitivity. In the former, a thermodynamically driven activation step enhances the ability to distinguish between substrates and decoys with small binding energy differences. In the latter, resetting cycles enable catalytic control, with the steady-state length distribution modulated by sub-stoichiometric concentrations of a reusable catalyst. Synthesizing past models of these well-studied systems, we show how path-counting and circuit mapping approaches can be used to address fundamental questions such as the number of futile cycles inherent in translation and the steady-state length distribution of a dynamically unstable polymer. In both cases, a limited amount of thermodynamic driving is sufficient to yield a qualitative transition to a system with enhanced sensitivity, enabling accurate discrimination and catalytic control at a modest energetic cost. It is our great pleasure to contribute to this special issue dedicated to the life and work of Prof. Erich Sackmann. Sackmann was a pioneer in the broad field dedicated to using the tools of physics to understand the fascinating phenomena of life. One of the most intriguing aspects of living organisms that makes them so different from their inanimate counterparts is the expenditure of energy to maintain nonequilibrium steady states. Many of the phenomena that exploit such energy consumption share features of exploratory dynamics: sampling many paths with occasional resetting en route to a target state. Common examples include biological polymerization in processes such as replication, translation, and cytoskeletal filament dynamics. In this paper, we examine two case studies (protein translation and microtubule growth) linking the energetic cost and functional benefits of exploratory dynamics. Introduction One of the fundamental challenges faced by living cells is the need to carry out their functions while ‘blind’ – lacking a centralized omniscient organizer that can direct cellular components where to go and which interactions to perform in what order. Above the cellular scale, biological dynamics can be at least somewhat directed: individual cells follow gradients of chemotactic signals to find food or escape danger Berg 2004 , morphogen patterns regulate tissue rearrangements and cellular differentiation Wolpert 1969 , organisms make use of sensory organs to find distant targets. Within a cell, however, exploratory dynamics reigns supreme J. and M. 1997 . Whether searching through physical space or through chemical state-space, cells rely on dynamics that follow a characteristic pattern: blindly sampling through the available states, fixing and amplifying the targets when a trajectory stumbles across them, and resetting unsuccessful trajectories to try again. Such exploratory dynamics was first noted in the context of dynamically unstable microtubules that engage in search-and-capture cycles of random growth and rapid depolymerization to find chromosomes when constructing the mitotic spindle Kirschner and Mitchison 1986 ; Heald and Khodjakov 2015 . The same principle applies to other spatial search problems in the cell. For example, the ability of neurons to localize mitochondria in regions of high energy demand Misgeld and Schwarz 2017 relies on ‘sushi-belt’ dynamics Williams et al. 2016 , where a motile population of organelles constantly cycles via motor-driven transport through neuronal projections, with regions of enhanced stopping encoded through local increases in calcium MacAskill et al. 2009 or glucose concentrations Pekkurnaz et al. 2014 . In the endocytic pathway, endosomes bearing activated receptors must wander through the cellular periphery until they encounter other organelles that trigger phosphoinositide conversion and deactivate the signal York et al. 2023 ; Villaseñor et al. 2016 . Analogous exploratory processes occur on the molecular scale, particularly in the context of sensing and proofreading. First introduced to explain the accuracy of polymerization-based information transfer Hopfield 1974 ; Ninio 1975 , kinetic proofreading relies on chaining together intermediate states that the system must pass through before reaching a target. By providing multiple opportunities to reset back to the origin from each intermediate state, such proofreading can amplify the likelihood of following a pathway involving ‘right’ versus ‘wrong’ interactions. Thus, a ribosome searches for the next amino acid to add to a growing polypeptide chain by exploring through intermediate states that might involve the right or wrong tRNA. The higher rate of resetting (release of the tRNA) for the wrong amino acid allows a greater probability that the final step of peptide elongation is reached only with the correct amino acid. Similar exploration through intermediate states shows up in sensory systems, such as T-cell activation Cui and Mehta 2018 or chemotactic signaling Hathcock et al. 2024 . In both cases, incorrect ligands that bind weakly to receptors are more likely to be released, resulting in resetting during each intermediate step. Proofreading through resetting is also thought to contribute to the self-assembly of large multimeric structures, including sequence-specific RecA filament formation on DNA Bar-Ziv et al. 2002 and viral RNA packaging Mizrahi et al. 2022 . Protein quality control systems provide additional examples of exploratory dynamics that leverage resetting to accurately sort components into distinct pathways. The ubiquitinating enzyme APC is able to distinguish its substrates among myriads of decoy proteins by sequentially marking multiple lysine groups on the target protein, eventually triggering the degradation of the substrate Lu et al. 2015 . The resulting difference in APC binding affinity on ubiquitinated substrates versus non-ubiquitinated decoys makes it more likely that only the correct proteins are targeted for degradation. In the secretory pathway, newly translated proteins are tagged by the addition of glycan chains that facilitate binding to chaperones which help fold the proteins Adams et al. 2019 . Multiple cycles of glycosylation in the ER allow chaperones to make several attempts at folding a nascent protein before it proceeds towards the terminal pathways of export or degradation Brown and Koslover 2021 . Given the prevalence of resetting dynamics in intracellular systems, a natural question is why this approach is so common and what advantages it might offer to the cell. The effects of resetting on speed in subcellular exploration are considered in previous work Evans and Majumdar 2011 ; Evans et al. 2020 and addressed in a cohesive framework in another article within this issue Kondev et al. 2025 . Instead of considering the temporal advantages, here we illustrate how exploratory dynamics enhances sensitivity: the ability of the cell to respond to small differences in system parameters. We contend that seemingly distinct functional objectives, including concerted activation of specific signaling molecules, accurate discrimination of targets from decoys, and regulation of molecular assembly size, are all manifestations of the same phenomenon:

Read the complete text