Soft theorems of tree-level Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) , YM and NLSM amplitudes from 2 2 -splits

Kang Zhou · 2025

Read Soft theorems of tree-level Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) , YM and NLSM amplitudes from 2 2 -splits by Kang Zhou (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00747.txt.

Introduction

When one particle in a scattering event goes soft, carrying almost no energy, the whole amplitude simplifies in predictable ways, called soft theorems. Kang Zhou derives those rules for three classic theories using a new tool: the 2-split, a special way amplitudes factorize on chosen slices of the kinematic space. The method leans only on how amplitudes break apart, both at ordinary poles and at these new split points.

Zhou recovers the known leading and next-to-leading soft rules for a scalar theory and for Yang-Mills theory, plus double-soft rules for the nonlinear sigma model. Higher-order rules take a universal form in reduced kinematic spaces. Two bonuses appear: the Yang-Mills and sigma model rules swap into each other by a simple replacement of variables, and the split currents obey their own tidy soft theorems. All results respect momentum conservation in physical content.

Catalog record

CREATORKang Zhou
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE130 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00747

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Soft theorems of tree-level Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) , YM and NLSM amplitudes from 2 2 -splits Kang Zhou Abstract In this paper, we extend the method proposed in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd for deriving soft theorems of amplitudes, which relies exclusively on factorization properties including conventional factorizations on physical poles, as well as newly discovered 2 2 -splits on special loci in kinematic space. Using the extended approach, we fully reproduce the leading and sub-leading single-soft theorems for tree-level Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) and Yang-Mills (YM) amplitudes, along with the leading and sub-leading double-soft theorems for tree-level amplitudes of non-linear sigma model (NLSM). Furthermore, we establish universal representations of higher-order single-soft theorems for tree-level Tr ⁡ ( ϕ 3 ) {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) and YM amplitudes in reduced lower-dimensional kinematic spaces. All obtained soft factors maintain consistency with momentum conservation; that is, while each explicit expression of the resulting soft behavior may changes under re-parameterization via momentum conservation, the physical content remains equivalent. Additionally, we find two interesting by-products: First, the single-soft theorems of YM amplitudes and the double-soft theorems of NLSM, at leading and sub-leading orders, are related by a simple kinematic replacement. This replacement also transmutes gauge invariance to Adler zero. Second, we obtain universal sub-leading soft theorems for the resulting pure YM and NLSM currents in the corresponding 2 2 -splits. 1 Introduction In recent years, three novel types of factorizations of tree-level amplitudes, termed smooth splitting, factorization near hidden zero, and 2 -split, have been discovered successively Cachazo:2021wsz ; Arkani-Hamed:2023swr ; Cao:2024gln ; Cao:2024qpp ; Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd . Unlike the conventional tree-level factorization, which states the behavior of residue on any physical pole, these new factorizations occur on special loci in kinematic space without requiring residue evaluation. It has been shown that among the three types, the 2 -split is the most fundamental one, as both smooth splitting and factorization near zero arise from further specializations of consecutive 2 -splits Cao:2024qpp . As demonstrated in Cao:2024gln ; Cao:2024qpp , the 2 -split is a universal phenomenon, with a wide range of particle and string amplitudes exhibiting this behavior. Whereas the conventional factorization produces two on-shell lower-point amplitudes, the 2 -split yields two amputated currents, each with an off-shell leg. These novel factorizations and associated hidden zeros have attracted extensive attention, see in Zhang:2024iun ; Zhang:2024efe ; Rodina:2024yfc ; Bartsch:2024amu ; Li:2024qfp ; Zhou:2024ddy ; Huang:2025blb ; Feng:2025ofq . As is well known, the usual factorization on poles enables effective computational techniques, as well as novel formalisms and insights, such as the famous Britto-Cachazo-Feng-Witten (BCFW) on-shell recursion relation and the amplituhedron Britto:2004ap ; Britto:2005fq ; Arkani-Hamed:2013jha ; Arkani-Hamed:2017mur . It is natural to expect that the new class of factorizations will also lead to significant physical implications and applications. For instance, hidden zeros and their associated factorizations provided the crucial clue for discovering the simple ” \delta -shift” of kinematic variables, which preserves zeros and factorizations. This marvelous shift unifies the {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) , non-supersymmetric Yang-Mills (YM), and non-linear sigma model (NLSM) amplitudes into a single stringy curve integral Arkani-Hamed:2023jry ; Arkani-Hamed:2024nhp , in the story of ”surfaceology” which represents a major advance in recent studies of scattering amplitudes Arkani-Hamed:2023lbd ; Arkani-Hamed:2023mvg ; Arkani-Hamed:2023jry ; Arkani-Hamed:2024nhp ; Arkani-Hamed:2024tzl ; Arkani-Hamed:2024vna ; Arkani-Hamed:2024yvu ; Arkani-Hamed:2024nzc ; Arkani-Hamed:2024pzc . Furthermore, as demonstrated in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd , the novel 2 -split also provides a new approach for deriving universal soft theorems of amplitudes. This paper focuses on deriving soft theorems for tree-level amplitudes by utilizing 2 -splits. Soft theorems describe a universal factorization behavior when one or more external massless particles become soft, that is, their momenta are scaled as k_{i}=\tau\hat{k}_{i} , with \tau\to 0 . In such soft limit, a wide range of amplitudes at specific orders of \tau factorize into a universal soft factor and a lower-point amplitude excluding the soft particles. For instance, when an external gluon s is taken soft, the color-ordered tree-level YM amplitude factorizes as \displaystyle{\cal A}_{\rm YM}(1,\cdots,n,s)=\Big({1\over\tau}\,S^{(0)}_{g}+S^{(1)}_{g}\Big)\,{\cal A}_{\rm YM}(1,\cdots,n)+\cal O(\tau)\,,~~ (1) where S^{(0)}_{g} and S^{(1)}_{g} are universal leading and sub-leading soft factors, respectively. Here, ”universal” means their forms are independent of the number of external particles. As demonstrated in a series of works, the soft behaviors can be exploited to construct tree amplitudes without relying on traditional Lagrangians or Feynman rules Nguyen:2009jk ; Boucher-Veronneau:2011rwd ; Rodina:2018pcb ; Ma:2022qja ; Cheung:2014dqa ; Cheung:2015ota ; Luo:2015tat ; Elvang:2018dco . For example, it allows us to access the universal expansions of tree amplitudes for a large variety of theories, via an on-shell recursive scheme that invert soft limits Zhou:2022orv ; Wei:2023yfy ; Hu:2023lso ; Du:2024dwm ; Zhou:2024qjh ; Zhou:2024qwm . These expansions hold for arbitrary numbers of external states, simplifying amplitude computations to evaluating coefficients (with prescribed rules) and basis. However, such constructions discussed above presuppose known soft theorems. In general, deriving soft theorems for multiple distinct theories, via a universal methodology without prior knowledge of amplitudes, is highly non-trivial. The method in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd , leveraging 2 -splits and conventional factorizations, offers a new approach to tackle this challenge. Unfortunately, while it fully determines leading-order soft theorems via 2 -splits alone, higher-order results derived via the method in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd are restricted to lower-dimensional kinematic subspaces, i.e., they are incomplete. Nevertheless, most inverse-soft methods in the literature require complete sub-leading soft factors (e.g., S^{(1)}_{g} in ( 1 )) to fully construct amplitudes. Yet, the method in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd cannot supply the complete set of needed soft factors. To address this gap, we extend the method of Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd to derive complete sub-leading soft theorems. Unlike Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd which uses one 2 -split, our method employs two. Furthermore, while the treatment for YM and NLSM in Arkani-Hamed:2024fyd depends on the ” \delta -shift” formalism of surfaceology, our method is independent of this framework. By combining (i) conventional factorizations on poles, and (ii) two distinct 2 -splits on different kinematic loci, we obtain full sub-leading single-soft factors for {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) /YM amplitudes and double-soft factors for NLSM at tree-level. Here, ”single-soft” denotes one soft particle, while ”double-soft” involves two. Although we focus on these three theories, our method is generalizable to any amplitude exhibiting 2-splits, as it avoids theory-specific properties (e.g., gauge invariance or Adler zero). To systematize our approach, we also discuss the derivation of leading soft theorems, via two distinct methods: one based on conventional factorizations and the other utilizing novel 2 -splits. Remarkably, while the conventional factorization approach is limited to {\rm Tr}(\phi^{3}) and YM amplitudes, the 2 -split method demonstrates broader applicability, successfully extending to NLSM amplitudes as well. An interesting observation is, the single-soft theorems for Yang-Mills (YM) amplitudes (at leading/sub-leading orders) and the double-soft theorems for NLSM amplitudes (at the same orders) are interrelated through a simple kinematic replacement: \epsilon_{s}\to k_{s_{1}}-k_{s_{2}} , k_{s}\to k_{s_{1}}+k_{s_{2}} , where \epsilon_{s} and k_{s} denote the polarization vector and momentum of the soft gluon, while k_{s_{1}} and k_{s_{2}} are momenta of two soft pions. This replacement maps gauge invariance in YM to Adler zero in NLSM. The construction which builds gluon polarizations from scalar momenta, plays a pivotal role in the ”surfaceological” description of gluon amplitudes, known as scalar-scaffolded gluons Arkani-Hamed:2023jry . While the sub-leading soft theorems derived

Read the complete text