On Linking Planet Formation Models, Protoplanetary Disk Properties, and Mature Gas Giant Exoplanet Atmospheres

Adina D. Feinstein, Richard A. Booth, Jennifer B. Bergner, Joshua D. Lothringer, Elisabeth C. Matthews, Luis Welbanks, Yamila Miguel, Bertram Bitsch, Linn E. J. Eriksson, James Kirk, Stefan Pelletier, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Anjali A. A. Piette, Caroline Piaulet-Ghorayeb, Kamber R. Schwarz, Diego Turrini · 2025

Read On Linking Planet Formation Models, Protoplanetary Disk Properties, and Mature Gas Giant Exoplanet Atmospheres by Adina D. Feinstein, Richard A. Booth, Jennifer B. Bergner, Joshua D. Lothringer, Elisabeth C. Matthews, Luis Welbanks, Yamila Miguel, Bertram Bitsch, Linn E. J. Eriksson, James Kirk, Stefan Pelletier, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Anjali A. A. Piette, Caroline Piaulet-Ghorayeb, Kamber R. Schwarz, Diego Turrini (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00669.txt.

Introduction

Feinstein and co-authors wrote a paper from 2025 summing up a week-long workshop on one of astronomy's connective problems. Three mature fields meet there: how planets form, how the disks around young stars behave, and what the air of grown gas giants shows. Each field is strong alone, yet the chain that links a disk's chemistry to a planet's adult atmosphere is loose. A single ratio, such as carbon to oxygen, cannot carry the story.

The workshop, hosted in Heidelberg, traded state-of-the-art results across the three fields and aligned their languages. Talks covered formation models, disk observations, and the atmosphere readings of giant planets. The conclusion was frank: no one yet knows the ideal observable for the link. Candidates range from several element ratios to the budgets of rock-forming material. The paper lists what each field most needs to sharpen next.

Catalog record

CREATORAdina D. Feinstein, Richard A. Booth, Jennifer B. Bergner, Joshua D. Lothringer, Elisabeth C. Matthews, Luis Welbanks, Yamila Miguel, Bertram Bitsch, Linn E. J. Eriksson, James Kirk, Stefan Pelletier, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Anjali A. A. Piette, Caroline Piaulet-Ghorayeb, Kamber R. Schwarz, Diego Turrini
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE109 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00669

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

On Linking Planet Formation Models, Protoplanetary Disk Properties, and Mature Gas Giant Exoplanet Atmospheres Adina D. Feinstein, Richard A. Booth, Jennifer B. Bergner, Joshua D. Lothringer, Elisabeth C. Matthews, Luis Welbanks, Yamila Miguel, Bertram Bitsch, Linn E. J. Eriksson, James Kirk, Stefan Pelletier, Anna B.T. Penzlin, Anjali A. A. Piette, Caroline Piaulet-Ghorayeb, Kamber R. Schwarz, Diego Turrini, Lorena Acuña-Aguirre, Eva-Maria Ahrer, Madyson G. Barber, Jonathan Brande, Aritra Chakrabarty, Ian J. M. Crossfield, Gabriel-Dominique Marleau, Helong Huang, Anders Johansen, Laura Kreidberg, John H. Livingston, Rafael Luque, Maria Oreshenko, Elenia Pacetti, Giulia Perotti, Jesse Polman, Bibiana Prinoth, Dmitry A. Semenov, Jacob B. Simon, Johanna Teske, Niall Whiteford Abstract Measuring a single elemental ratio (e.g., carbon-to-oxygen) provides insufficient information for understanding the formation mechanisms and evolution that affect our observations of gas giant planet atmospheres. Although the fields of planet formation, protoplanetary disks, and exoplanets are well established and interconnected, our understanding of how to self-consistently and accurately link the theoretical and observational aspects of these fields together is lacking. To foster interdisciplinary conversations, the Max-Planck Institut für Astronomie (MPIA) hosted a week-long workshop called, “Challenge Accepted: Linking Planet Formation with Present-Day Atmospheres.” Here, we summarize the latest theories and results in planet formation modeling, protoplanetary disk observations, and atmospheric observations of gas giant atmospheres to address one of the challenges of hosting interdisciplinary conferences: ensuring everyone is aware of the state-of-the-art results and technical language from each discipline represented. Additionally, we highlight key discussions held at the workshop. Our main conclusion is that it is unclear what the ideal observable is to make this link between formation scenarios and exoplanet atmospheres, whether it be multiple elemental abundance ratios, measuring refractory budgets, or something else. Based on discussions held throughout the workshop, we provide several key takeaways of what the workshop attendees feel need the most improvement and exploration within each discipline. I Motivation Modern exoplanet science aims to not only characterize planets around other stars, but to explain why and how the observed diversity of planets arises. Early attempts to link giant planet atmospheric compositions to a formation mechanism began in our own solar system, following the Galileo probe measurements of Jupiter’s atmosphere ( Owen et al. 1999 , e.g.) . For example, Lodders 2004 found that when the elemental abundances in Jupiter’s atmosphere are normalized by sulfur, there may be a factor of 2 depleted in oxygen. Given these abundances, Lodders 2004 proposed a new formation explanation that suggests Jupiter may have formed near the carbonaceous condensation/evaporation line, rather than the water ice line. As it subsequently became possible to characterize the atmospheres of planets beyond our solar system, the idea emerged that measurements of elemental ratios in a planet’s atmosphere could provide a powerful constraint on its formation origins ( Madhusudhan et al. 2011 ) . Around this time, Öberg et al. 2011 introduced the idea that volatile snowlines can dramatically influence the C/O ratio of gas vs. solids at different radial positions within a protoplanetary disk. This simple and elegant picture suggests that a giant planet’s atmospheric C/O ratio can be directly mapped to its formation location within the parent disk ( Mollière et al. 2022 ) . This idea found particular resonance with the community, and has been a major driver of exoplanet science over the past decade. Figure 1: A summary schematic of assumptions that are made in planet formation modeling, protoplanetary disk modeling, and exoplanet atmospheric modeling. We note that several of the presented variables can be directly measured (e.g., planet mass, radius, and semi-major axis), but not necessarily in all systems. The processes involved in planet formation and evolution are, however, complex, interdependent, and dynamic (Figure 1 ). It is widely acknowledged that a single elemental ratio is insufficient for linking giant planet atmospheres to their formation origins. Understanding how planets form remains an important goal for the field, but achieving it will require collaborative efforts across the communities of protoplanetary disk physics and chemistry, planet formation, atmospheric evolution, and exoplanet characterization. In the coming years, maintaining open communication between these fields will be especially important as operational facilities (e.g., the Atacama Large Millimeter/sub-millimeter Array and JWST) continue to deliver and near-future space- and ground-based facilities (e.g., the Extremely Large Telescope, Square Kilometre Array, and ESA’s PLATO and ARIEL missions) will deliver an unprecedented volume and quality of constraints on exoplanet atmospheres and the physics and chemistry of protoplanetary disks. The aim of this work, building off of the ‘‘Challenge Accepted: Linking Planet Formation with Present-Day Atmospheres’’ 1 1 1 https://the-great-link.github.io/ workshop hosted by the Max-Planck-Institut für Astronomie, is to provide an accessible overview of the current progress and limitations in making the connection between gas giant planet ( R_{p}\geq 4R_{\oplus} ) atmosphere observations and their formation. This article is intended to reflect the discussions and perspectives of workshop participants, and not to provide a comprehensive review of the fields covered. This work is organized as follows. In Section II we outline leading theoretical frameworks of planet formation. In Section III we describe the current understanding of protoplanetary disk physics and chemistry which may influence planetary atmosphere compositions. In Section IV , we discuss existing constraints on elemental abundances in giant planet atmospheres. Lastly, in Section V , we comment on potential promising avenues for making the link from planet formation to mature atmospheres. II State of Planet Formation Models There are two main theories of giant planet formation. One is the ‘bottom-up’ core accretion theory, where the planet’s rocky core forms first (by accreting small (mm- to cm-sized) pebbles, larger ( \sim km-sized) planetesimals, or a combination of the two) before accreting a gaseous envelope from the protoplanetary disk. The second theory is ‘top-down’, where the planet forms directly via the fragmentation of a gravitationally unstable disk. We briefly review the essentials of these ideas. II.1 “Bottom-up”: Core Accretion Planet formation via core accretion is thought to proceed as follows ( Pollack et al. 1996 , e.g.) . First, the planet’s core grows by the accretion of solids. The high temperature during core growth initially prevents significant amounts of gas accretion. However, as core growth slows, the planets can start to accrete gas. Initially, gas accretion is slow and limited by the ability of the planet to cool ( Lee & Chiang 2015 ) , but the planet enters the rapid runaway gas accretion phase once the gas mass becomes comparable to the mass of solids accreted ( Mizuno 1980 ; Stevenson 1982 ; Bodenheimer et al. 2000 ; Rafikov 2006 ) . At this stage, the planet quickly grows to become a gas giant. Largely, the picture is the same whether the solids are primarily accreted in the form of dust/pebbles ( \lesssim cm particles) or planetesimals ( \gtrsim km-size solid bodies), although details such as the efficiency, speed of growth, and preferred range of locations where gas giants form differ between the two scenarios. Both scenarios can reproduce some key features of the exoplanet demographics ( Emsenhuber et al. 2021 ; Drążkowska et al. 2023 , e.g.) , but no model yet explains the full population ( Burn & Mordasini 2025 , see also discussion in) . Here, we discuss the key

Read the complete text