Social Construction of Urban Space: Understanding Neighborhood Boundaries Using Rental Listings
Adam Visokay, Ruth Bagley, Ian Kennedy, Chris Hess, Kyle Crowder, Rob Voigt, Denis Peskoff, University of Washington, Department of Sociology, Northwestern University, Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois Chicago, Department of Sociology, Kennesaw State University, Department of Sociolo · 2025
Read Social Construction of Urban Space: Understanding Neighborhood Boundaries Using Rental Listings by Adam Visokay, Ruth Bagley, Ian Kennedy, Chris Hess, Kyle Crowder, Rob Voigt, Denis Peskoff, University of Washington, Department of Sociology, Northwestern University, Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois Chicago, Department of Sociology, Kennesaw State University, Department of Sociolo (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00634.txt.
Introduction
Adam Visokay and co-authors read neighborhood borders in rental ads in a 2025 paper. Neighborhood lines on official maps often differ from the ones people claim. Chicago Craigslist listings from 2018 to 2024 carry those claims in everyday language. The team classified each listing's stated neighborhood by hand and with language models.
Geospatial checks sorted mismatches into three patterns. Some listings sit where competing definitions overlap. Border homes can honestly claim either neighbor area. Others engage in reputation laundering, borrowing a distant prized name. Topic modeling showed listings far from a center stress different amenities. Ads thus reveal how urban space is socially built. Conventional boundary methods miss this contested layer entirely.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Adam Visokay, Ruth Bagley, Ian Kennedy, Chris Hess, Kyle Crowder, Rob Voigt, Denis Peskoff, University of Washington, Department of Sociology, Northwestern University, Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois Chicago, Department of Sociology, Kennesaw State University, Department of Sociolo |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 46 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00634
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Social Construction of Urban Space: Understanding Neighborhood Boundaries Using Rental Listings Adam Visokay, Ruth Bagley, Ian Kennedy, Chris Hess, Kyle Crowder, Rob Voigt, Denis Peskoff, University of Washington, Department of Sociology, Northwestern University, Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois Chicago, Department of Sociology, Kennesaw State University, Department of Sociology, Criminal Justice Abstract Rental listings offer a unique window into how urban space is socially constructed through language. We analyze Chicago Craigslist rental advertisements from 2018 to 2024 to examine how listing agents characterize neighborhoods, identifying mismatches between institutional boundaries and neighborhood claims. Through manual and large language model annotation, we classify unstructured listings from Craigslist according to their neighborhood. Geospatial analysis reveals three distinct patterns: properties with conflicting neighborhood designations due to competing spatial definitions, border properties with valid claims to adjacent neighborhoods, and “reputation laundering" where listings claim association with distant, desirable neighborhoods. Through topic modeling, we identify patterns that correlate with spatial positioning: listings further from neighborhood centers emphasize different amenities than centrally-located units. Our findings demonstrate that natural language processing techniques can reveal how definitions of urban spaces are contested in ways that traditional methods overlook. 1 Contested Neighborhood Boundaries A substantial body of research suggests that neighborhood location matters for a wide range of individual and collective outcomes Sampson et al., 2002 ; Sharkey and Faber, 2014 ; Minh et al., 2017 ; Chyn and Katz, 2021 . While much of this research has focused on the social and demographic characteristics of neighborhoods, even more subjective features attached to specific neighborhoods – their reputation, status, or stigma – have important repercussions, shaping residents’ satisfaction, place attachment, trust in their neighbors, physical health, and overall well being Tran et al., 2020 ; Kullberg et al., 2010 ; Permentier et al., 2011 ; Otero et al., 2024 . Neighborhood reputation also shapes the economic value attached to property in the area, patterns of investment and disinvestment Kirk, 2024 ; Korver-Glenn and Mayorga, 2024 , and residential mobility patterns that shape broader dynamics of neighborhood stratification Krysan and Crowder, 2017 ; Evans and Lee, 2020 . Figure 1: Contested boundaries of Humboldt Park neighborhood according to the official City of Chicago limits (blue), Zillow’s definition (red), and claims in Craigslist rental listings (orange points for listings claiming to be in Humboldt Park, purple if claiming to be elsewhere); the center of the Craigslist-defined neighborhood is represented by a green star. This map shows how the rigid, non-overlapping boundaries for neighborhoods found in traditional maps might not adequately represent the fluidity of neighborhood identity in reality. Such effects are seen in the reluctance of real estate actors to avoid associating their properties with stigmatized areas Schachter et al., 2024 . But there is also growing recognition that neighborhoods are socially constructed in the sense that their boundaries and reputations are defined through social interaction Zelner, 2015 ; Hohle, 2023 and influenced by broader social and political dynamics Stuart et al., 2024 . As social constructs, both the boundaries and meaning of neighborhoods are subject to contestation, defined by social processes reflected in the language we use to describe specific locations. Given the repercussions of neighborhoods for residents’ lives, understanding the processes through which neighborhood boundaries are defined, challenged, and redefined is of paramount importance. We offer a rare glimpse into these processes of neighborhood definition and redefinition by focusing on the ways in which real estate actors characterize the locations of their units. Using language models and the text from Chicago Craigslist rental advertisements from 2018-2023 we identify mismatches between units that are listed in one neighborhood but claim another. This can occur for several reasons. We focus in particular on cases where the listing agent is appealing to a desirable community in a form of "reputation laundering" Stuart et al., 2024 . Our language model framework leverages contextual understanding to identify neighborhood claims in rental listings, significantly advancing beyond the string-matching techniques typically employed in urban social science research and demonstrating NLP’s potential for quantifying socially constructed spatial phenomena. Section 2 describes the Chicago Craigslist rental data we use for our analysis and outlines the pre-processing steps employed to create a clean, spatially-anchored corpus. Section 3 demonstrates how large language models can accurately identify neighborhood claims in rental listings, outperforming traditional string-matching approaches. Section 4 develops a methodological framework for quantifying spatial relationships between listings and neighborhood identities, constructing standardized distance metrics from each unit to its claimed neighborhood centroid. Section 5 employs topic modeling to uncover the latent semantic structure of rental advertisements, revealing distinct patterns in how properties are marketed. Section 6 estimates statistical associations between unit characteristics and spatial positioning relative to neighborhood centers, illuminating patterns in spatial boundary making. Section 7 synthesizes our empirical findings about the social construction of Chicago’s neighborhoods through rental listings and contextualizes these results within the broader field of natural language processing. 2 Craigslist Housing Advertisements We use a data collected from Chicago Craigslist rental advertisements from 2018 to 2024 to identify listings with mismatches between the neighborhood containing the unit and the neighborhood claimed by the listing agent. 1 1 1 We have been actively collecting data in Chicago since 2018, providing a rich window into the discursive construction of urban space. It includes all available advertisements each day from December 2018 until June 2024 using the webscraper Helena Chasins et al., 2018 ; Hess and Chasins, 2022 . Occasional changes to the architecture of the Craiglist website result in limited periods of data loss, the longest of which was from August 2019 to early October 2019. This mismatch can occur for several reasons such as a listing agent appealing to a more desirable community in a form of "reputation laundering" or "neighborhood stigma’ Schachter et al., 2024 . Preceding computational analysis of Cragislist rental listings has focused on the rent distribution Boeing and Waddell, 2017 the way listings describe neighborhoods Kennedy et al., 2020 ; Besbris et al., 2021 , units Boeing et al., 2021 , include exclusionary language Stewart et al., 2023 , indicate affordability Hess et al., 2023 and home security Somashekhar et al., 2024 . Taken together, this work has shown that rental listings on Craigslist align with and appear to reproduce social inequality. Recent work has begun to focus on the importance of neighborhood names and the places those names describe Schachter et al., 2024 , with specific focus on contested naming: when advertisements use neighborhood names that seem to diverge from the name most local residents would use for that space. We focus on Chicago because it stands as a quintessential “city of neighborhoods," where locally recognized community areas hold exceptional cultural, economic, and social significance Hwang and Sampson, 2014 . Chicago’s urban identity has historically been defined through its distinctive neighborhood mosaic, with 77 officially recognized community areas and numerous smaller neighborhoods within them that residents strongly identify with and that carry powerful reputational associations. This neighborhood orientation is so deeply embedded in Chicago’s social fabric that it shapes how residents understand their place in the city, influences social networks, and structures daily mobility patterns. The pronounced salience of neighborhoods in Chicago makes it an ideal site for examining how spatial boundaries