Spins of Black Holes in X-ray Binaries and the Tension with the Gravitational Wave Measurements Journal: New Astronomy Review

Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Grégoire Marcel, Alexandra Veledina, Aleksandra Olejak, Debora Lančová · 2025

Read Spins of Black Holes in X-ray Binaries and the Tension with the Gravitational Wave Measurements Journal: New Astronomy Review by Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Grégoire Marcel, Alexandra Veledina, Aleksandra Olejak, Debora Lančová (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00623.txt.

Introduction

Zdziarski and four co-authors reviewed black hole spins in X-ray binaries in twenty twenty-five and their clash with gravitational wave results. Spin is how fast a black hole rotates, scaled from zero to one. Merging black holes seen by wave detectors spin slowly on average, suggesting black holes are born spinning slowly.

Most published spins for black holes feeding in X-ray binaries are instead near maximal. Binaries with massive companion stars are the sharpest puzzle, since their short lives leave no time to spin up by feeding. The authors argue the measurement methods carry large systematic errors. One relies on splitting X-ray spectra uncertainly; the other uses disk models that predict instability where stability is seen. Corrected models give lower spins, easing the tension.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrzej A. Zdziarski, Grégoire Marcel, Alexandra Veledina, Aleksandra Olejak, Debora Lančová
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE93 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00623

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Spins of Black Holes in X-ray Binaries and the Tension with the Gravitational Wave Measurements Journal: New Astronomy Review Andrzej A. Zdziarski, Grégoire Marcel, Alexandra Veledina, Aleksandra Olejak, Debora Lančová Abstract We review current challenges in understanding the values and origin of the spins of black holes in binaries. Thanks to recent advances in astrophysical instrumentation, the spins can now be measured using both gravitational waves emitted by merging black holes and electromagnetic radiation from accreting X-ray binaries containing black holes. A key finding of the gravitational-wave observatories is that premerger black holes in binaries have low spin values, with an average dimensionless spin parameter of a ∗ ∼ a_{*}\sim 0.1–0.2. Furthermore, the spins in the first-born black holes appear lower than in the second-born ones. This implies that the natal spins of black holes are generally low, and the angular momentum transport in massive stars is efficient. On the other hand, most of the published spins in X-ray binaries are very high, a ∗ ≳ 0.7 a_{*}\gtrsim 0.7 . This is the case, in particular, for binaries with high-mass donors (potential progenitors of mergers), where their published spins range from 0.8 to 1.0, while their short lifetimes prevent significant spin-up by accretion. Those with low-mass donors could be spun-up to a ∗ ≳ 0.7 a_{*}\gtrsim 0.7 by accretion, but only if the donor initial masses were more than several solar masses, which remains unproven. However, we find the existing methods of spin measurements suffer from significant systematic errors. The method relying on relativistic X-ray line broadening is based on the separation of the observed spectra into the incident and reflected ones, which is intrinsically highly uncertain. The method of spectral fitting accretion disk continua uses models that predict the disk to be highly unstable, while stability is observed. Improved stable models give the disk temperatures higher than the standard models, and consequently predict lower spins. We postulate that the published spin measurements in X-ray binaries are uncertain. We hypothesize that the spins of the binaries with high-mass donors are low, while those with low-mass donors have a broader spin distribution, ranging from low to high, including high spins as required to power relativistic jets. 1 Introduction Black holes (BHs) are the simplest objects in the universe, fully characterized by only three fundamental parameters: mass, spin, and charge. Then, astrophysical BHs would quickly discharge into their surroundings ( Komissarov 2022 ) , leaving us with mass and spin. The masses of stellar BHs in binaries can be reliably measured by studying both gravitational waves (GWs) from merging binary BHs (BBHs) and electromagnetic (EM) radiation from accreting BH X-ray binaries (XRBs) via measuring the radial velocities of their donors. The ranges of the masses of both kinds of BHs overlap, and those from GWs extended to higher values (up to \gtrsim 100{M}_{\odot} ) than those found in XRBs ( \lesssim 20{M}_{\odot} ), which appears to be well explained (see Section 2 ). The opposite situation occurs for the spins, where the measured spins of premerger BHs are very low on average, while those of BHs measured in XRBs are high on average and, in many cases, close to the maximum value. In particular, the measured spins of BHs in XRBs with high mass donors (HMXBs), which can be progenitors of BBHs, are all very high, in stark contrast to the case of BBHs. The origin of this tension remains unclear. The values of the spins are critically important for our understanding of stellar evolution, BH formation scenarios, accretion, and testing theories of relativity. For accretion, they are essential for its efficiency, the disk emission, and the launching of jets. Furthermore, high spin values are crucial for understanding the origin of gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). In particular, if a rapidly rotating star collapses into a BH, the resulting accretion disk can launch a jet thought to power long-duration GRBs ( Blandford and Znajek 1977 ) . Here, we review the observational results from both GW and EM emissions and the methods of spin measurements. We then search for possible ways to resolve the spin tension. We find that while the spins determined by the GWs appear highly reliable, the methods of measuring the spins by the EM emission are not. The method using disk reflection suffers from the uncertainty of separating the reflected emission from the incident one. The method using relativistic disk continuum emission suffers from the instabilities predicted by analytical disk models, while stability is observed. This renders them not applicable to describe the emission of BH XRBs, and calls for the development of new stable models suitable for spectral fitting. We use the standard dimensionless spin parameter, a_{*}\equiv Jc/GM^{2}, (1) where J and M are the angular momentum and mass, respectively, and G and c are the gravitational constant and the speed of light. The BH rotation period at the horizon as seen at infinity is (e.g., Lightman et al. 1975 ) P=\frac{4\pi GM(1+\sqrt{1-a_{*}^{2}})}{a_{*}c^{3}}. (2) In Sections 2 and 3 , we review the spins from BH mergers and studies of BH XRBs, respectively. Within the latter, Sections 3.1 – 3.4 and 3.5 review the methods of measuring the spins and the published values of the spins, respectively. Section 4 is devoted to possible resolutions of the tension, where 4.1 discusses possibilities of revising the EM measurements, 4.2 covers the feasibility of accretion to spin up BHs, and 4.3 discusses the possibility that BH XRBs and BBHs belong to different stellar populations. We discuss and summarize our results in Section 5 . 2 Results from BH mergers Mergers of BBHs can now be studied using GWs, which have allowed us to measure the spin of the premerger BHs. At least some BBHs (excluding those dynamically formed) are the final stages of binaries containing a BH and a high-mass donor. The latter includes currently accreting BHs, i.e., BH HMXBs. The results of those studies thus have important implications for comparing the populations of BBHs and BH XRBs and understanding their differences and similarities. Following the first detection of GWs from a merger of two BHs in 2015 ( Abbott et al. 2016 ) , more than 100 such events at redshifts \lesssim 1 have so far been publicly announced by LIGO and Virgo ( Abbott et al. 2023 lists about 70 BH mergers with reliable parameters). However, by the time of the preparation of this manuscript, about 200 candidates for additional GW detections have been found based on the ongoing Run 04. An updated catalog with the system parameters is expected to be published in the second half of 2025. Two main results about the properties of the premerger BHs have been obtained. One is that the distribution of the measured BH masses in BBHs extends to much higher values, up to \approx\!100{M}_{\odot} , than those observed in accreting BH XRBs. Until recently, the highest measured BH mass was that of Cyg X-1, 21.2\pm 2.2{M}_{\odot} ( Miller-Jones et al. 2021 ) . However, the recent investigation using detailed atmospheric (non-LTE) models of the donor by Ramachandran et al. 2025 found M\approx(12.7 – 17.8){M}_{\odot} . We also note that a 33\pm 1{M}_{\odot} BH was recently discovered in a detached binary, Gaia BH3,

Read the complete text