Look mom, no experimental data! Learning to score protein-ligand interactions from simulations

Michael BrocidiaconoJames WellnitzKonstantin I. PopovAlexander TropshaEshelman School of PharmacyUniversity of North Carolina at Chapel Hill · 2025

Read Look mom, no experimental data! Learning to score protein-ligand interactions from simulations by Michael BrocidiaconoJames WellnitzKonstantin I. PopovAlexander TropshaEshelman School of PharmacyUniversity of North Carolina at Chapel Hill (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2506-00593.txt.

Introduction

Michael Brocidiacono, James Wellnitz, Konstantin Popov, and Alexander Tropsha teach neural networks to score drug binding using only simulations in a 2025 paper. Its playful title boasts of using no experimental data. Predicting binding strength is the bottleneck of virtual screening, and deep models falter on new targets. Physics based free energy calculations are accurate but far too slow for large libraries.

Their hybrid trains a separate network for each target on molecular dynamics runs of the protein with random small molecules. Force matching lets the network learn the binding energy landscape implicitly. Across six proteins, screening performance rivaled established methods. With true poses for active compounds, early enrichment hit state of the art levels. Code is shared openly.

Catalog record

CREATORMichael BrocidiaconoJames WellnitzKonstantin I. PopovAlexander TropshaEshelman School of PharmacyUniversity of North Carolina at Chapel Hill
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2506-00593

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Look mom, no experimental data! Learning to score protein-ligand interactions from simulations Michael BrocidiaconoJames WellnitzKonstantin I. PopovAlexander TropshaEshelman School of PharmacyUniversity of North Carolina at Chapel Hill Abstract Despite recent advances in protein-ligand structure prediction, deep learning methods remain limited in their ability to accurately predict binding affinities, particularly for novel protein targets dissimilar from the training set. In contrast, physics-based binding free energy calculations offer high accuracy across chemical space but are computationally prohibitive for large-scale screening. We propose a hybrid approach that approximates the accuracy of physics-based methods by training target-specific neural networks on molecular dynamics simulations of the protein in complex with random small molecules. Our method uses force matching to learn an implicit free energy landscape of ligand binding for each target. Evaluated on six proteins, our approach achieves competitive virtual screening performance using 100-500 µs of MD simulations per target. Notably, this approach achieves state-of-the-art early enrichment when using the true pose for active compounds. These results highlight the potential of physics-informed learning for virtual screening on novel targets. We publicly release the code for this paper at https://github.com/molecularmodelinglab/lfm under the MIT license. 1 Introduction Finding small molecule ligands that bind to a protein target is a critical step in early-stage drug discovery. However, this objective can be extremely challenging and expensive – the typical approach is to run a high-throughput screen (HTS), which can take months to set up and cost millions of dollars [ 16 ] . Identifying true binders faster and more cheaply is a major goal of computational drug discovery. Traditionally, the challenge of predicting protein-ligand binding affinities is separated into two tasks: docking and scoring. Docking algorithms propose 3D binding poses of a ligand within a protein’s binding site, while scoring functions estimate the binding affinity of a given pose. While much recent progress has been made in the area of docking [ 13 , 4 , 49 ] , scoring has lagged behind [ 51 , 46 , 10 ] . This is the primary reason for the unreliability of structure-based virtual screening (SBVS), wherein ligands from a large library are ranked according to their predicted binding affinity, and the top-scoring hits are chosen for experimental characterization. More recently, generative modeling has emerged as a potential alternative to SBVS; however, generative models are still typically evaluated and/or fine-tuned according to noisy scoring functions such as AutoDock Vina [ 44 , 35 , 34 ] . The difficulty of scoring arises from both data limitations and fundamental trade-offs in existing approaches. ML-based scoring functions often suffer from overfitting due to the scarcity of high-quality binding affinity data [ 51 , 46 ] . On the other hand, physics-based methods exhibit a speed-accuracy trade-off: rigorous absolute binding free energy (ABFE) simulations provide accurate affinity estimates but require extensive computational resources, often taking many hours per molecule even on GPUs [ 7 , 23 , 5 ] . In contrast, traditional fast scoring functions, such as those used by Vina and Glide [ 22 ] , offer rapid predictions but are often unreliable, failing to achieve robust enrichment in virtual screening tasks [ 10 , 28 , 38 ] . Developing scoring methods that generalize beyond the available training data is especially important for the next generation of drugs. Recent advances in drug discovery have expanded interest beyond the traditional druggable proteome, targeting intrinsically disordered proteins [ 37 ] , protein-protein interactions [ 33 ] , and RNA tertiary structures [ 12 ] as promising avenues for next-generation therapeutics. The ability to efficiently identify small-molecule binders for these novel targets could greatly accelerate the development of new treatments. These novel target classes represent a formidable yet rewarding challenge for screening methods, as no current methodology can reliably find binders for such targets. In this work, we propose combining the advantages of physics-based and machine learning models for protein-ligand scoring. Instead of trying to train a general binding affinity predictor to work on all protein targets, we seek to train a new model for each protein target of interest. We create a custom training set for each protein by running molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of random small molecules inside the binding site. We then use force matching to train a neural network on the free energy landscape of ligand binding. We emphasize that this approach requires no experimental data for the target in question except for its 3D structure (which can be estimated using structure-prediction methods such as AlphaFold). We name this workflow ligand force matching (LFM). Figure 1: Method overview. a) For a particular protein target, we start by placing random small molecules in the binding site. For each ligand, we run an MD simulation of the protein-ligand complex, keeping the ligand atoms frozen relative to the binding site. We record the positions and intermolecular forces of the ligand atoms. b) Using the dataset thus generated, we train a neural network to approximate this binding PMF of the protein-ligand complex using force matching. c) In a virtual screen, we use this neural network to approximate the free energy of protein-ligand binding by subtracting the PMF of the ligand outside the binding site from the minimized PMF of the docked ligand. 2 Method 2.1 Overview Invoking the Born-Oppenheimer approximation [ 9 ] , a receptor-ligand system can be specified by the positions of the receptor atoms: x_{R} , the ligand atoms x_{L} , and the solvent atoms x_{S} . Throughout this paper, we use a coordinate system defined by the rigid-body alignment of the binding site \alpha carbons to a reference structure. At equilibrium, these positions follow the Boltzmann distribution: p(x_{R},x_{L},x_{S})=\frac{1}{Z}e^{-\beta U(x_{R},x_{L},x_{S})} (1) Here U is the potential energy of the system and \beta=\frac{1}{k_{B}T} is the Boltzmann factor. In practice, we can approximate U with a fast and easily-evaluated sum of nonbonded and bonded energy terms. When scoring protein-ligand complexes, we desire to predict the binding free energy \Delta G_{\text{binding}}=G_{\text{bound}}-G_{\text{unbound}} . The free energy G for a particular state is defined: G_{\Omega}=-\frac{1}{\beta}\log\int_{\Omega}e^{-\beta U(x_{L},x_{R},x_{S})}dx_{L}dx_{R}dx_{S} (2) Here \Omega is the set of either all bound or all unbound poses, depending on the free energy in question. The integral in this equation is computationally intractable, as protein-ligand systems can easily exceed 10K atoms. In practice, we can approximate \Delta G_{\text{binding}} by sampling from many intermediate systems wherein the energy terms corresponding to the protein-ligand interactions are slowly attenuated; the final free energy is the work done during this transformation. This is the approach taken by ABFE protocols such as double decoupling [ 25 ] and the alchemical transfer method [ 50 ] . As mentioned above, such algorithms are accurate but slow. As an alternative approach, we can condition G on the ligand coordinates x_{L} . This results in the binding position of mean force (PMF). G_{\text{PMF}}(x_{L})=-\frac{1}{\beta}\log\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}e^{-\beta U(x_{L},x_{R},x_{S})}dx_{R}dx_{S} (3) As its name implies, the force this potential generates on the ligand atoms is equal to the ensemble average of the ligand forces from the full potential U . -\nabla_{x_{L}}G_{\text{PMF}}(x_{L})=-\Bigl\langle\nabla_{x_{L}}U(x_{L},x_{R},x_{S})\Bigr\rangle_{x_{R},x_{S}} (4) Estimating the full \Delta G_{\text{binding}} is much easier if we have access to G_{\text{PMF}} , as it already integrates over the majority of the degrees of freedom. We can additionally quickly approximate the full free energy

Read the complete text