What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level?
Manosh T. Manoharan · 2025
Read What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? by Manosh T. Manoharan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-24743.txt.
Introduction
Manosh Manoharan asks what really lets simple dark energy models ease the Hubble tension, in a paper from 2025. Two no-extra-parameter models seem to favor a faster current expansion, which would calm the clash between early and late universe measures. Suspect priors and dataset choices might be doing the work.
Minimally extended versions of both models actually favor low expansion rates, and the high values trace to prior choices. Dropping certain high-redshift absorption data restores strong tension with local measures. New survey data also sit uneasily with older distance estimates. Reframed as interacting dark sectors, easing the tension demands an odd sign-switching coupling.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Manosh T. Manoharan |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 91 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-24743
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
What solves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at background level? Manosh T. Manoharan Abstract Few phenomenological models tend to favour higher values of the Hubble parameter, often at the expense of invoking phantom transitions. These models achieve this without introducing additional parameters, akin to the simplicity of the concordance Λ \Lambda CDM model. In this work, we investigate two such models – Phenomenologically Emergent Dark Energy (PEDE) and Granda-Oliveros Holographic Dark Energy (GOHDE) – to assess how correlations between H 0 H_{0} and Ω m \Omega_{m} , as well as the choice of datasets, influence conclusions regarding their potential to address the Hubble tension at the background level. We find that minimally extended versions of these models favour notably low values for the Hubble parameter, with the perceived preference for higher values driven by the associated prior. Excluding BAO Ly α \alpha - H ( z ) H(z) data points at a redshift of ∼ 2.3 \sim 2.3 results in a Hubble parameter that remains in significant tension with SH0ES measurements. In contrast, including these data points favours a higher H 0 H_{0} , as they suggest a relatively lower matter density within the framework of the assumed fiducial cosmology. Additionally, recent DESI DR1 and DR2 data exhibit mild tension with BAO- H ( z ) H(z) estimates from SDSS. We demonstrate that the inclusion of stringent constraints, such as the CMB shift-parameter along with Pantheon + , on the effective pressure less matter density significantly impacts the estimation of the Hubble parameter. Finally, reinterpreting these models in terms of interacting dark sectors with Q = 3 H γ Λ ρ ~ m Q=3H\gamma_{\Lambda}\tilde{\rho}_{m} reveals that addressing the Hubble tension necessitates a varying γ Λ \gamma_{\Lambda} characterised by a singular sign-switch behaviour. This phantom behaviour, or equivalently, the onset of violation of the null energy condition in the future, is crucial for minimal models to solve the Hubble tension. I Introduction The most intricate puzzle in cosmology could arguably be the Hubble tension [ 1 ] , which refers to the discrepancy between the current value of the Hubble parameter reported by local observations, such as [ 2 ] ( H_{0}=73.04\pm 1.04 km / s / Mpc), and that inferred from CMB observations ( H_{0}=67.4\pm 0.5 km / s / Mpc) [ 3 ] . While local observations depend on calibrators such as Cepheid variables, the relatively high value of H_{0} reported might stem from calibration issues, as discussed by [ 4 ] . Conversely, CMB observations are grounded in the \Lambda cold dark matter ( \Lambda CDM) cosmological model, raising questions about the validity of \Lambda as well as CDM. In either case, until more statistically robust data becomes available, the claims in [ 4 ] may remain speculative, as detailed by [ 5 ] . Furthermore, as compelling evidence against \Lambda continues to emerge, as suggested by [ 6 ] , the reliability of CMB-based observations could also be challenged. Resolving the Hubble tension, therefore, is far from straightforward. While the observational community focuses on scrutinising calibration methods, any potential flaws in [ 2 ] could necessitate a downward revision of the Hubble parameter. On the other hand, the theoretical community remains invested in exploring alternatives to the \Lambda CDM model and investigating the possibility of ‘new physics’ to account for a higher Hubble parameter. Within this domain, dark energy models play a pivotal role in addressing the Hubble tension, albeit often at the cost of introducing exotic features such as phantom crossings. Recent DESI results, indicating an evolving dark energy component with a phantom crossing [ 6 , 7 ] , lend further credibility to such models. Among the extensive array of dark energy models, only a select few are inherently capable of predicting a higher value of the Hubble parameter at the background level, such as the phenomenological emergent dark energy (PEDE) model proposed by [ 8 ] . As might be intuitively anticipated, the PEDE model resolves the Hubble tension at the background level through a dynamic dark energy equation of state parameter that exhibits phantom behaviour. However, the reliance on phantom behaviour to address the Hubble tension represents arguably the most significant (and perhaps the sole) challenge in employing dark energy as a solution at the background level. Here, we will not attempt to resolve this issue; instead, we will focus on identifying the specific features that explicitly enable these models to address the Hubble tension. If a model can resolve the Hubble tension at the background level—solely by considering the expansion history—it must predict a higher value of the Hubble parameter using datasets that provide the Hubble flow H(z) at various redshifts ( z ). This is precisely what the PEDE model proposed by [ 8 ] offers. However, upon closer inspection, it becomes evident that the results heavily depend on the specific datasets employed. For instance, a quick parameter estimation using only the BAO Galaxy clustering H(z) data for redshifts below 2 yields H_{0}=66.94^{+2.87}{-2.93} and \Omega_{m}=0.38^{+0.07}{-0.06} for the PEDE model. These results appear to show tension in both H_{0} and \Omega_{m} estimations.This raises the pertinent question: What resolves the Hubble tension in phenomenological dark energy models at the background level? To address this in a broader context, we examine both the PEDE model and a comparable framework, the Granda-Oliveros Holographic Dark Energy (GOHDE) model [ 9 ] , which can address the Hubble tension without introducing an additional free parameter, as required by PEDE. Our analysis delves into the finer aspects of these models with minimal extensions to determine what fundamentally resolves the Hubble tension. To this end, we employ various datasets that are commonly used to study the expansion history of the Universe at the background level. Interestingly, despite their different theoretical origins, the impact of the data on the analysis for both models appears remarkably similar, if not identical. The structure of this manuscript is as follows. First, we introduce the dark energy models of interest – the PEDE and GOHDE models – as minimal extensions of the \Lambda CDM framework. Subsequently, we explore various re-parameterizations of these models, as proposed by [ 10 ] . Next, we analyse the influence of different datasets on the models’ performance in addressing the Hubble tension, highlighting the critical role played by the correlation between free parameters and the assumed fiducial cosmology in the extraction of certain data points, shaping the derived conclusions at the background level. We then examine the specific features of these minimal extensions. Our findings reveal that these extensions do not favour a significantly large value of H_{0} in the full picture. By exploring the models within the interacting dark sector framework, we demonstrate that a future violation of the null energy condition is sufficient to resolve the Hubble tension. This conclusion remains consistent across various extensions and manifests as a pole in the evolving interaction strength. II Minimal extensions to \Lambda CDM Even before the discovery of accelerated expansion, the concordance cosmological constant ( \Lambda ) faced numerous theoretical challenges [ 11 ] . Following the confirmation of the Universe’s recent accelerated expansion, a plethora of dynamic dark energy models