A Standing-Wave Model for the Low-Frequency Dynamics of a Turbulent Separation Bubble

Lukas M. Fuchs 1, B. Steinfurth 2, J.G.R. von Saldern 1, J. Weiss 2, K. Oberleithner 1 · 2025

Read A Standing-Wave Model for the Low-Frequency Dynamics of a Turbulent Separation Bubble by Lukas M. Fuchs 1, B. Steinfurth 2, J.G.R. von Saldern 1, J. Weiss 2, K. Oberleithner 1 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-24723.txt.

Introduction

Lukas Fuchs and co-authors catch a standing wave inside a turbulent bubble behind a ramp. Their 2025 paper deals with separation bubbles, whose slow breathing motion rides on large swirls. Time-resolved flow films in two planes feed a spectral split of the motion field. A dominant slow mode matches known breathing. The cross-span films, though, expose a fresh pattern: fixed nodes and antinodes across the span, like a plucked string.

A model that stacks left and right running waves between the side walls copies the measured modes well. A stability read traces the root to a centrifugal quirk, with lift-up growth downstream.

Catalog record

CREATORLukas M. Fuchs 1, B. Steinfurth 2, J.G.R. von Saldern 1, J. Weiss 2, K. Oberleithner 1
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-24723

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

A Standing-Wave Model for the Low-Frequency Dynamics of a Turbulent Separation Bubble Lukas M. Fuchs 1, B. Steinfurth 2, J.G.R. von Saldern 1, J. Weiss 2, K. Oberleithner 1 Abstract This study investigates the low-frequency dynamics of a turbulent separation bubble (TSB) forming over a backward-facing ramp, with a focus on very-large-scale coherent structures associated with the so-called ’breathing motion’. Using time-resolved particle image velocimetry (PIV) in both streamwise and spanwise planes, we examine the role of sidewall confinement, an aspect largely overlooked in previous research. Spectral proper orthogonal decomposition (SPOD) of the streamwise velocity field reveals a dominant low-rank mode at very low Strouhal numbers ( S ​ t = St= 0.01–0.05), consistent with prior observations of TSB breathing. Strikingly, the spanwise-oriented PIV data uncover a previously unreported standing wave pattern, characterized by discrete spanwise wavenumbers and nodal/antinodal structures, suggesting the presence of spanwise resonance. To explain these observations, we construct a resolvent-based model that imposes free-slip conditions at the sidewall locations by superposing left- and right-traveling three-dimensional modes. The model accurately reproduces the spanwise structure and frequency content of the measured SPOD modes, demonstrating that sidewall reflections lead to the formation of standing wave-like patterns. The analysis further indicates that the observed dynamics are caused by the lift-up mechanism driving the formation of large-scale streaks that span the domain width. Our findings highlight the critical influence of spanwise boundary conditions on the selection and structure of low-frequency modes in TSBs. This has direct implications for both experimental and numerical studies, particularly those relying on spanwise-periodic boundary conditions, and offers a low-order framework for predicting sidewall-induced modal dynamics in separated flows. † † affiliation: 1 Laboratory for Flow Instabilities and Dynamics, Institute of Fluid Dynamics and Technical Acoustics, Technical University Berlin, Germany 2 Aerodynamics Laboratory, Technical University Berlin, Germany 1 Introduction When a turbulent boundary layer separates from a surface and reattaches further downstream, the resulting recirculation region is known as a turbulent separation bubble (TSB). These flows exhibit strong unsteadiness over a broad range of frequencies, leading to detrimental effects such as structural vibrations, noise generation, mechanical fatigue, and fluctuations in thermal loads, all of which pose significant challenges in various engineering applications. TSBs can be classified into two main categories: geometry-induced and adverse pressure gradient (APG)-induced separation bubbles. Geometry-induced TSBs arise at sharp geometric discontinuities such as backward-facing steps ( Eaton & Johnston 1982 ) and rectangular leading-edge configurations ( Cherry et al. 1984 ; Kiya & Sasaki 1983 ) . APG-induced TSBs occur in configurations such as airfoils ( Delery 1985 ) , backward-facing ramps ( Kaltenbach et al. 1999 ; Weiss et al. 2022 ) , or flat plates where an adverse pressure gradient drives separation ( Patrick 1987 ; Na & Moin 1998 ; Wu et al. 2019 ; Cura et al. 2024 ; Abe 2017 ; Mohammed-Taifour & Weiss 2016 ) . One specific instance of an APG-induced TSB is the trailing-edge separation observed on airfoils, where the flow detaches in the rear part of the airfoil and reattaches near the trailing edge. Low-frequency oscillations of these trailing-edge TSBs were first noted by Zaman et al. 1989 and have since remained a topic of ongoing research ( Wang & Ghaemi 2022 ; Sarras et al. 2024 ) . Another flow configuration related to TSBs involves stall cells, three-dimensional flow structures that appear during separation on two-dimensional airfoils. These structures have been described as mushroom-shaped ( Winkelmann & Barlow 1980 ) , consisting of two counter-rotating vortices. Additionally, TSBs are prevalent in shock–boundary layer interactions (SBLI), where shock waves interact with turbulent boundary layers, leading to separation and reattachment phenomena that remain a subject of ongoing research ( Delery 1985 ; Dussauge et al. 2006 ; Poggie et al. 2015 ; Hao 2023 ) . Turbulent separation bubbles have been studied extensively over the past five decades across a wide range of geometries and flow configurations. Throughout these studies, different frequency domains have been identified and associated with distinct phenomena, often described using terms such as breathing, flapping, and shedding. The presence of a dominant frequency in TSBs, when scaled appropriately, was first recognized by Mabey 1972 , who found that the separation bubble length L_{b} and free-stream velocity u_{\infty} provide a meaningful Strouhal number scaling, St=fL_{b}/u_{\infty} . Many TSBs exhibit a characteristic shedding frequency range between St=0.5 and St=0.8 , attributed to vortex roll-up in the shear layer ( Eaton & Johnston 1982 ; Kiya & Sasaki 1983 ; Cherry et al. 1984 ) , often linked to the Kelvin–Helmholtz instability ( Tenaud et al. 2016 ) . Weiss et al. 2015 observed a shedding mode at St\approx 0.35 , associated with vortex roll-up in the shear layer above the recirculation region. Beyond shedding, lower-frequency dynamics have also been observed. Eaton & Johnston 1982 noted already in Eaton & Johnston 1982 that over 30% of turbulence intensity occurred at frequencies below St\approx 0.02 , though their measurement setup lacked the resolution to analyze this further. Kiya & Sasaki 1983 distinguished between high-frequency shedding and lower-frequency oscillations, describing the latter as an accumulation of vorticity that enlarges the bubble before being advected downstream. In recent decades, two primary descriptions have become established for describing low-frequency motions: flapping and breathing. Flapping refers to oscillations of the shear layer, which typically occur in forward-facing step configurations between St\approx 0.08 and St\approx 0.18 ( Fang & Wang 2024 ; Pearson et al. 2013 ; Largeau & Moriniere 2007 ) , but are also observed in backward-facing step flows. Breathing, on the other hand, describes an overall expansion and contraction of the separation bubble, modulating both the separation and reattachment points. Pearson et al. 2013 characterized flapping as a streamwise and wall-normal expansion/contraction of the TSB, which Wang & Ghaemi 2022 argued aligns with the definition of breathing. While terminology varies, it is widely agreed that flapping occurs at intermediate frequencies, while breathing corresponds to the lowest frequencies, around St\approx 0.01 ( Weiss et al. 2015 ; Mohammed-Taifour & Weiss 2016 ; Borgmann et al. 2024 ) . The mechanism driving the breathing dynamics is still an open question. Wu et al. 2019 used a direct numerical simulation (DNS) to study a flat-plate TSB with two setups: one using suction-only separation and another using a suction-and-blowing profile to force reattachment. Dynamic mode decomposition (DMD) revealed streamwise-elongated structures potentially linked to Görtler instability, but their observed breathing frequencies ( St\approx 0.45 ) were significantly higher than those reported in other studies. More recently, Cura et al. 2024 performed global stability (GSA) and resolvent analyses (RA) on a DNS dataset from Coleman et al. 2018 . Their global stability analysis found no unstable eigenmodes, but the least damped mode occurred at zero frequency with small, nonzero spanwise wavenumbers. Resolvent analysis showed strong agreement with experimental databases, suggesting that forced dynamics are influenced by a weakly damped global mode. Sarras et al. 2024 analyse stall cells using global linear stability analysis on a RANS mean flow and compare their findings with wind tunnel experiments. Their findings reveal stationary three-dimensional global modes becoming unstable only within certain ranges of angles of attack and particular spanwise wavenumbers. Bugeat et al. 2022 investigated the

Read the complete text