Birational equivalence of Severi–Brauer varieties

János Kollár · 2025

Read Birational equivalence of Severi–Brauer varieties by János Kollár (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-24720.txt.

Introduction

Severi-Brauer varieties are geometric objects tied to algebras, and a long-standing question asks when two of them that are linked in an algebraic sense can be reshaped into each other. János Kollár takes up Amitsur's conjecture on this question in this 2025 paper. Amitsur showed one direction long ago and guessed the converse, given equal dimensions.

Kollár proves the conjecture for varieties whose index is not a prime power. His route runs through a clean description of the product of two such varieties: under a coprime condition, the product matches a simple reshaping of the pair. That description yields the main theorem, covering cases where the dimension plus one has at least two distinct prime factors. The proof settles ground that earlier inductive methods had left open.

Catalog record

CREATORJános Kollár
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE18 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-24720

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Birational equivalence of Severi–Brauer varieties János Kollár Abstract . We prove Amitsur’s conjecture for Severi–Brauer varieties whose index is not a prime power. Let P be a Severi–Brauer variety over a field k . Amitsur [ Ami55 ] proved that if P is birational to another Severi–Brauer variety Q , then they generate the same subgroup of \operatorname{Br}(k) , and conjectured that the converse also holds, provided P,Q have the same dimension. The conjecture was popularized by Serre in [ Ser62 , Ser79 , Sec.X.6] . Roquette [ Roq64 ] developed an inductive method, and settled the conjecture when P splits over a solvable Galois extension of degree \dim P+1 . Krashen [ Kra03 , Kra08 ] used the method to show, among others, that if the conjecture holds for both P_{1},P_{2} , and \dim P_{1}+1,\dim P_{2}+1 are relatively prime, then it also holds for their (tensor or Brauer) product P_{1}\otimes P_{2} ; see Definition 7 . Combined with [ Tre91 ] , this implies that the conjecture holds if 2 is a primitive root modulo every prime factor of \dim P+1 . We show that the conjecture holds for P_{1}\otimes P_{2} , even if we do not know what happens for P_{1} and P_{2} individually. This leads to the following. Theorem 1 . Let P,Q be Severi–Brauer varieties of the same dimension over a field k . Assume that \dim P+1 has at least 2 distinct prime factors. Then P,Q generate the same subgroup of \operatorname{Br}(k) iff P is birationally equivalent to Q . This turns out to be a straightforward consequence of the following birational description of the tensor product of Severi–Brauer varieties. Theorem 2 . Let P_{1},P_{2} be Severi–Brauer varieties over a field k , and assume that (\dim P_{1}+1,\dim P_{2}+1)=1 . Then there is a birational equivalence [formula] P_{1}\otimes P_{2}\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}P_{1}\times P_{2}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r},\quad\mbox{where}\quad r=\dim P_{1}\cdot\dim P_{2}. Remarks 3 . ( 3 .1) The method of [ Ami55 ] produces birational equivalences of the form (P_{1}\otimes P_{2})\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r_{1}}\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}P_{1}\times P_{2}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r_{2}} for some r_{1},r_{2}>0 , see ( 4 .4). The key assertion of Theorem 2 is that we can achieve r_{1}=0 . ( 3 .2) The birational equivalence ( 2 .1) usually fails without the realtively prime assumption. For example, if P_{1}=P_{2}=P and \dim P+1 is even, then P\otimes P and P\times P are not even stably birational to each other. ( 3 .3) There is no general birational product formula for P_{1}\otimes P_{2} that involves only the P_{i} and their dimensions. For example, although P is birationally equivalent to its dual P^{\vee} , the tensor product P\otimes P^{\vee} is birationally trivial, but P\otimes P is usually not. See, however, Lemma 19 . Note that in Theorem 2 , the subgroup of \operatorname{Br}(k) generated by P_{1}\otimes P_{2} is the same as the subgroup generated by P_{1} and P_{2} . This suggests the following generalization. Conjecture 4 . Let X=\prod_{i\in I}P_{i} and Y=\prod_{j\in J}Q_{j} be (ordinary) products of Severi–Brauer varieties. The following are equivalent. (4.1) The subgroups \langle P_{i}:i\in I\rangle\subset\operatorname{Br}(k) and \langle Q_{j}:j\in J\rangle\subset\operatorname{Br}(k) agree. (4.2) X\times{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim Y}\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}Y\times{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim X} . If \dim X=\dim Y , then these are also equivalent to (4.3) X\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}Y . Known cases. Using Corollary 10 we see that the pull-back of each Q_{j} to X is trivial. Similarly, the pull-back of each P_{i} to Y is trivial. This gives birational equivalences [formula] X\times{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim Y}\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}X\times Y\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}Y\times{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim X}. Thus ( 4 .1) and ( 4 .2) are equivalent. ( 4 .3) \Rightarrow ( 4 .2) is clear, and repeated application of Theorem 2 gives many cases of the converse. Some cases where P_{i},Q_{j} have dimension \leq 2 are treated in [ Kol05 , Hog09 ] . Background on Severi–Brauer varieties We collect basic results about Severi–Brauer varieties that we need. The algebraic versions are discussed in several books [ Alb39 , Her68 , GS06 ] . A geometric treatment is given in [ Kol25 ] . Definition 5 . Let k be a field with algebraic closure \bar{k} . A Severi–Brauer variety is a k -variety P such that P_{\bar{k}}\cong{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim X}_{\bar{k}} . Q\subset P is a twisted linear subvariety if Q_{\bar{k}}\subset P_{\bar{k}}\cong{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim X}_{\bar{k}} is a linear subvariety. The index of P is the gcd of the degrees of 0-cycles on P . It is also the minimum degree of a (nonzero) effective 0-cycle on P . The index divides \dim P+1 ; it is denoted by \operatorname{ind}(P_{k}) . Lemma 6 . Let P be a Severi–Brauer variety. All minimal twisted linear subvarieties are isomorphic to each other; denote these by P^{\rm min} . Then \dim P^{\rm min}=\operatorname{ind}(P) , and P is birationally equivalent to P^{\rm min}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r} where r=\dim P-\dim P^{\rm min} . ∎ Definition 7 (Tensor or Brauer product) . Let P,Q be Severi–Brauer varieties over a field k . There is a unique Severi–Brauer variety—denoted by P\otimes Q —and an embedding P\times Q\lhook\joinrel\to P\otimes Q , that is isomorphic to the Segre embedding over \bar{k} . Definition 8 (Brauer group) . Two Severi–Brauer varieties P,Q are Brauer equivalent iff P^{\rm min}\cong Q^{\rm min} . The tensor product defines a group structure on the set of Brauer equivalence classes over k . It is called the Brauer group of k , and denoted by \operatorname{Br}(k) . \operatorname{Br}(k) is a torsion group, and the order of P in \operatorname{Br}(k) is called the period of P . Lemma 9 . Let \langle P\rangle\subset\operatorname{Br}(k) denote the subgroup generated by P . Then Q\in\langle P\rangle iff there is a rational map P\dasharrow Q . If these hold then \operatorname{ind}(Q) divides \operatorname{ind}(P) . ∎ Corollary 10 . Let P be a Severi–Brauer variety. Then the kernel of the base change map \operatorname{Br}(k)\to\operatorname{Br}\bigl(k(P)\bigr) is the subgroup generated by P . ∎ The stable birational equivalence version of Theorem 1 is proved in [ Ami55 ] . Lemma 11 . Let P,Q be Severi–Brauer varieties over a field k . Then \langle P\rangle=\langle Q\rangle iff P\times{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim Q} is birational to Q\times{\mathbb{P}}^{\dim P} . ∎ Lemma 12 (Primary decomposition) . Let P,Q be minimal Severi–Brauer varieties over a field k . Assume that (\dim P+1,\dim Q+1)=1 . Then P\otimes Q is the minimal Severi–Brauer variety in the Brauer equivalence class of [P]\cdot[Q] .∎ Proof of Theorem 2 \Rightarrow Theorem 1 13 . By Lemma 11 , if P is birational to Q then they generate the same subgroup of \operatorname{Br}(k) . The new result is the converse. Assume first that P is not minimal. By Lemma 6 P\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}P^{\rm min}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r},\quad\mbox{and}\quad Q\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}Q^{\rm min}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r}, where r=\dim P-\dim P^{\rm min}\geq\dim P^{\rm min}+1 . Thus P^{\rm min}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r}\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}Q^{\rm min}\times{\mathbb{P}}^{r} by Lemma 11 , and we are done. (Here we did not need the assumption about 2 distinct prime factors.) We are left with the case when P,Q are minimal. By assumption we can write \dim P+1=(m+1)(n+1) where (m+1,n+1)=1 , and m,n are both \geq 1 . Choose a,c>0 such that a(m+1)+c(n+1)\equiv 1\mod\dim P+1. Let P_{1} (resp. P_{2} ) be the minimal Severi–Brauer variety that is Brauer equivalent to P^{a(m+1)} (resp. P^{c(n+1)} ), and similarly for Q_{1},Q_{2} . Note that P\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}P_{1}\times P_{2} and Q\operatorname{\stackrel{{\scriptstyle bir}}{{\sim}}}Q_{1}\times Q_{2} by Lemma 12 . Then P_{1},Q_{1} have index n+1 , dimension n , and generate the same subgroup of \operatorname{Br}(k)

Read the complete text