Two-color harmonic spectroscopy of ultrafast Dirac electron dynamics
Zhaopin Chen, Camilo Granados, Eyal Uzner, Ido Nisim, Daniel Kroeger, Ofer Neufeld, Marcelo F. Ciappina, Michael Krüger · 2025
Read Two-color harmonic spectroscopy of ultrafast Dirac electron dynamics by Zhaopin Chen, Camilo Granados, Eyal Uzner, Ido Nisim, Daniel Kroeger, Ofer Neufeld, Marcelo F. Ciappina, Michael Krüger (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-24290.txt.
Introduction
Zhaopin Chen and co-authors published this attosecond physics paper in 2025. High-harmonic generation is the process where an intense laser drives a material to emit light at many times the laser's frequency. In gases, the driving pulse can exhaust the ground state, and the harmonics fade at the pulse's tail. The team reports the same kind of saturation in a solid: graphite, a gapless Dirac semimetal whose electrons behave as if massless.
Graphite generates harmonics at laser intensities far below what gases need, thanks to its vanishing bandgap. By adding a second laser color, the team watched the excitation of electron-hole pairs in real time. As hot carriers piled up near the Dirac points, one family of harmonics was suppressed and emission times shifted. Simulations based on semiconductor Bloch equations matched the picture. The authors present harmonic emission as a sensitive all-optical probe of ultrafast carrier dynamics.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Zhaopin Chen, Camilo Granados, Eyal Uzner, Ido Nisim, Daniel Kroeger, Ofer Neufeld, Marcelo F. Ciappina, Michael Krüger |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 59 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-24290
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Two-color harmonic spectroscopy of ultrafast Dirac electron dynamics Zhaopin Chen, Camilo Granados, Eyal Uzner, Ido Nisim, Daniel Kroeger, Ofer Neufeld, Marcelo F. Ciappina, Michael Krüger Abstract High-harmonic generation (HHG), the hallmark effect of attosecond science, is a nonperturbative nonlinear process leading to the emission of high-harmonic light from gases and solids. In gases, extreme driving laser pulse intensities can deplete the ground state, suppressing harmonic emission during the trailing edge of the pulse. Here, we report a similar effect, pronounced ultrafast carrier saturation dynamics and harmonic emission suppression during nonperturbative harmonic generation (NPHG) in a gapless Dirac semimetal—highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG). Remarkably, HOPG supports NPHG at laser intensities as low as ∼ 10 10 \sim 10^{10} W cm -2 , facilitated by its vanishing bandgap. Ultrafast carrier saturation strongly modulates the interplay between interband and intraband currents, a key characteristic of NPHG in Dirac materials. Using two-color spectroscopy, we reveal the excitation dynamics of Dirac electron-hole pairs as it affects the emission of harmonics during the presence of the driving laser pulse. The excitation of out-of-equilibrium hot carriers and the concomitant saturation near the Dirac points leads to a marked suppression of interband harmonics and induces measurable temporal shifts. These observations are supported by simulations based on semiconductor Bloch equations. Our finding reveal that field-driven carrier saturation plays a critical role in gapless solid NPHG. We demonstrate the potential of NPHG and HHG as a sensitive, all-optical probe of ultrafast carrier dynamics, offering novel opportunities for ultrafast optoelectronics in Dirac materials. Main Parametric nonlinear optical processes, such as second-harmonic generation or four-wave mixing, transiently modify the quantum state of a medium during the laser interaction, but leave it unchanged afterward 1 . This framework extends even to high-harmonic generation (HHG), an extreme nonlinear field-driven process observed mainly in gases 2 , 3 , 4 and condensed-matter systems 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 , 9 , 10 , which cannot be described by perturbative nonlinear optics. Although HHG itself is parametric, competition with other strong-field processes can affect HHG, most prominently photoionization 4 . In gases, sufficiently intense and long laser pulses can substantially deplete the ground-state electron population, suppressing harmonic emission, causing spectral shifts and reducing harmonic cutoff energies 11 , 12 . Additionally, the resulting high densities of photoelectrons adversely affect harmonic phase matching 13 , 10 . In solids, analogous phenomena causing the suppression of the emission of harmonics might be expected at considerably lower laser intensities due to their smaller bandgaps relative to atomic ionization energies. However, experimental observation of pronounced carrier excitation dynamics during solid-state HHG and, more generally, nonperturbative harmonic generation (NPHG) remains elusive. Achieving a significant suppression of harmonic emission typically requires excitation fractions on the order of \sim 40\% , while in experiment, typical excitation levels in semiconductors are usually limited to a few percent to avoid material damage 15 . Pre-excitation of carriers with ultraviolet pulses has been explored as an alternative route to reach a carrier saturation regime and suppress the harmonic yield in semiconductors 15 , 16 , 17 . However, such approaches obscure the intrinsic saturation dynamics driven solely by the fundamental laser pulse which drives the harmonic generation process. Here, the subject of saturation and harmonic yield suppression is an intricate one because condensed matter is far more complex than the gas phase due to many-body scattering and decoherence, lower symmetry, and Bloch state delocalization. Moreover, the microscopic origins of harmonic suppression in solids remain actively debated. Such suppression could arise predominantly from state blocking, where transitions from valence to conduction bands become unavailable due to occupied states, or from excitation-induced dephasing, where increased carrier densities accelerate electron scattering and degrade interband coherence 18 . Highly oriented pyrolytic graphite (HOPG), a structurally robust carbon-based bulk material composed of stacked graphene layers 19 , 20 , provides a promising platform for investigating such intrinsic saturation dynamics under laser-field driving. HOPG retains the key electronic properties of monolayer graphene, including its gapless Dirac dispersion, high carrier mobility, and strong anisotropic optical responses 21 , 22 , 23 . It also offers additional experimental advantages, such as structural robustness and scalability, that overcome the intrinsic limitation of graphene’s low damage threshold. Furthermore, HOPG allows systematic exploration of the effects of interlayer coupling and thickness variations on nonlinear optical and electronic dynamics 24 . Despite these compelling features, HHG and NPHG of low-order harmonics in HOPG remain experimentally unexplored to date. In this combined experimental and theoretical study, we introduce an all-optical two-color spectroscopy technique to study ultrafast population dynamics in the Dirac cone, revealing behavior beyond that observed in conventional gapped solids. Specifically, we observe a time shift in harmonic emission relative to the driving field peak, a clear signature of laser-field-induced carrier saturation in a gapless Dirac semimetal. Whereas earlier studies of graphite and graphene have probed photon-induced saturation, Pauli blocking, and relaxation dynamics using transient absorption spectroscopy 25 , 26 , our work explores a fundamentally distinct regime, the nonperturbative regime, where carrier saturation evolves within tens of femtoseconds and directly influences harmonic generation. This bridges the gap between weak-field saturation effects and field-driven dynamics in Dirac materials, uncovering a new class of ultrafast phenomena governed by light-driven population reshaping. More broadly, the ability to resolve femtosecond-scale carrier saturation through HHG suppression suggests that this approach could also serve as a sensitive, all-optical probe of light-induced phase transitions in solids as demonstrated in both experimental 27 , 28 , 29 and theoretical 30 , 31 , 32 , 33 studies. Results Nonperturbative harmonic generation in HOPG We generate nonperturbative harmonics from an HOPG sample in reflection geometry 34 using an infrared femtosecond pulse (frequency \omega_{0} ) combined with a weak, synchronized second harmonic (SH) field ( 2\omega_{0} ), with a polarization parallel to the fundamental pulse (see Fig. 1 a). The fundamental laser pulse has a central wavelength of 1980 nm and a duration of 60 fs (about 9 optical cycles). The SH field is generated by focusing the fundamental field onto a \beta -barium borate (BBO) crystal. Both beams are split and then recombined in an interferometric setup, achieving both spatial and temporal overlap with accurate control of the two-color ( \omega_{0} – 2\omega_{0} ) time delay \tau (see Methods). Throughout this work, we set the SH pulse intensity at 3% of the fundamental laser intensity in both experimental measurements and theory calculations. Figure 1: Nonperturbative harmonic generation from HOPG by a two-color pulse. a , Conceptual sketch of nonperturbative harmonic generation in HOPG driven by a strong driving laser pulse with 1980 nm central wavelength and a weak second harmonic pulse. b , Three-step model of interband HHG around the Dirac cone. c , Experimentally measured harmonic spectrum with a laser peak intensity of 72 GW cm -2 and 3\% second harmonic admixture. d , Intensity scaling of the third and fifth harmonic yield when driven by the fundamental pulses only. The third harmonic exhibits a clear transition from a perturbative regime ( \propto I^{3} ) to a nonperturbative regime ( \propto I^{2.2} ), while the fifth harmonic is purely nonperturbative over the measured range, scaling as I^{2.5} at the highest intensity. e ,