Zener tunnelling in biased bilayer graphene via analytic continuation of semiclassical theory
Harley Scammell, Oleg P. Sushkov · 2025
Read Zener tunnelling in biased bilayer graphene via analytic continuation of semiclassical theory by Harley Scammell, Oleg P. Sushkov (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-24150.txt.
Introduction
Harley Scammell and Oleg Sushkov tackle a tunnelling problem in bilayer graphene in a 2025 physics paper. Bilayer graphene is two sheets of carbon, one atom thick each. When a voltage tilts the sheets and an electric field runs along them, electron and hole pairs can form by tunnelling across a gap.
Their method extends a classic semiclassical trick, which follows a path into complex values to skip points where exact answers are not known. Applied here, it shows odd traits in the far waves. Parts that fade away must be kept even where motion is freely allowed. The fully worked answer fixes the exact scale of the pair rate, and thus of the tunnelling current. That scale checks and clarifies earlier work that mixed hand math with computer steps.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Harley Scammell, Oleg P. Sushkov |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 37 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-24150
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Zener tunnelling in biased bilayer graphene via analytic continuation of semiclassical theory Harley Scammell, Oleg P. Sushkov Abstract Employing a semiclassical method based on analytic continuation, we compute the electron–hole pair production rate in biased bilayer graphene subject to an in-plane electric field. This approach, originally due to Zwaan, bypasses the need for exact solutions at turning points, which are generally unavailable beyond linear or quadratic band structures. Applying this technique to biased bilayer graphene reveals non-standard features of the asymptotic wavefunctions, in particular the necessity of retaining decaying components even in classically allowed regions. By providing a fully analytic solution, this work complements and clarifies earlier results based on hybrid analytical–numerical treatments, and importantly establishes the absolute normalisation of the pair production rate—and hence of the tunnelling current. I Introduction Bilayer graphene subject to a perpendicular electric field—i.e., biased bilayer graphene (Bblg)—develops a tunable gap in its electronic spectrum, becoming a semiconductor at charge neutrality Zhang et al. 2009 , and with dual gating the carrier density can be independently controlled Taychatanapat and Jarillo-Herrero 2010 ; Engdahl et al. 2025 . This electric field tunability has made Bblg an attractive platform for predicting and observing various many-body quantum phenomena, including momentum-polarised condensation Jung et al. 2015 ; Lin et al. 2023 ; Dong et al. 2023 , exciton condensation Scammell and Sushkov 2023 , and a cascade of isospin magnetic orders de la Barrera et al. 2022 ; Zhou et al. 2022 . At the single-particle level, strong in-plane electric fields can also drive interband Zener tunnelling across the gap—an effect that is both theoretically rich and technologically relevant. Zener tunnelling refers to the non-perturbative process in which electrons tunnel from the valence to the conduction band under the influence of a strong electric field Zener and Fowler 1934 . More broadly, tunnelling induced by strong electric and magnetic fields has long been studied in quantum electrodynamics, beginning with early work by Sauter Sauter 1931 and formalised in the Heisenberg–Euler effective action Heisenberg and Euler 1936 . In low-dimensional systems such as bilayer graphene, it is both experimentally accessible and theoretically rich, offering insight into quantum interference, nonlinear response, and field-induced transport regimes Nandkishore and Levitov 2011 ; Oka and Aoki 2005 ; Katsnelson and Volovik 2012 . In Bblg specifically, the presence of a gap makes Zener tunnelling particularly relevant to prospective device applications. Tunnel field-effect transistors (TFETs) based on interband tunnelling are among the leading candidates for steep-slope, low-power switching Ghosh and Sarkar 2013 ; Qin et al. 2024 . The specific question we address in this work is: Given an in-plane electric field, what is the pair production rate across the gap of Bblg? This problem was previously studied by Nandkishore and Levitov Nandkishore and Levitov 2011 , who employed a combination of the WKB approximation and numerical solutions to the relevant Schrödinger equation. In their approach, unknown amplitudes and scattering phases in the WKB framework were extracted by fitting to the numerical solution. In this work we present an alternative and fully analytic method, based on semiclassical theory extended by analytic continuation—originally introduced by Zwaan Zwaan 1942 . Although developed in the context of atomic physics, this approach has remained largely unexplored in condensed matter settings. It bypasses the need for local exact solutions near turning points (e.g. Airy functions in the quadratic case) and instead constructs globally valid solutions via continuation through the complex plane. This is particularly valuable for systems like Bblg, where the non-quadratic dispersion precludes known closed-form solutions near turning points. The key motivation and advances of this paper are as follows. First, the method is conceptually distinct from the WKB approach of Ref. Nandkishore and Levitov 2011 and provides a route for computing both the scattering phase and tunnelling coefficient within a single, analytic framework. Second, its application to Bblg reveals subtle but important features of the wavefunction structure—notably, the necessity of retaining exponentially decaying components in classically allowed regions. Third, this method allows the definition of the absolute normalisation of the pair-production rate, and with it, the correct expression for the tunnelling current. Relatedly, we highlight subtleties related to the normalisation of the Dirac sea. This paper is structured to equip the interested reader with all necessary details. Section II outlines the key steps of the method. Section III presents the full derivation of the semiclassical wavefunctions and matching conditions. Section IV details the proper normalisation of states and its dependence on device geometry, culminating in an expression for the pair production rate in absolute units. Section V explores the physical implications of these results. Finally, Appendix A provides an analogous treatment for Zener tunnelling in the gapped two dimensional (2D) Dirac Hamiltonian. II Outline of the method Standard structure of solutions: In conventional Zener tunnelling problems with quadratic band edges, the semiclassical wavefunction exhibits the following structure: • Oscillatory (running wave) solutions in the classically allowed region x>x_{+} , which carry the tunnelling current. • Exponentially decaying solutions in the classically forbidden region x_{-}<x<x_{+} . • Standing waves (a superposition of left- and right-moving components) in the classically allowed region x<x_{-} . Analytic continuation approach: The semiclassical approximation breaks down near the turning points at x=x_{\pm} , where the classical momentum vanishes. Zwaan’s key insight is to avoid these singular points by staying a small distance away—at x-x_{\pm}=\rho , with \rho finite—and to match the solutions by analytically continuing around the turning points in the complex plane. The continuation is performed by rotating the variable as \rho\to\rho e^{i\phi} while keeping |x-x_{\pm}|=\rho fixed. This allows one to bridge the solutions on either side of the turning point (i.e., x-x_{\pm}>0 and x-x_{\pm}<0 ) without leaving the domain of semiclassical validity. Both clockwise and counterclockwise continuation paths must be considered to enforce the cancellation of unphysical, exponentially growing components. The same procedure is carried out near both x=x_{+} and x=x_{-} . Figure 1 : Semiclassical energy spectrum in Bblg, showing classically allowed and forbidden regions. The grey shaded area represents the filled valence band; the black diagonal line indicates the conduction band. The horizontal axis corresponds to the spatial coordinate x at fixed energy \varepsilon=0 . The turning points x_{\pm} mark the boundaries between regions I, II, and III. Modified structure for Bblg: For biased bilayer graphene, the semiclassical wavefunction exhibits a richer structure due to its non-quadratic dispersion. As we will show: • In region I ( x>x_{+} ), both running and decaying solutions appear. • In region II ( x_{-}<x<x_{+} ), two linearly independent decaying solutions exist. • In region III ( x<x_{-} ), both standing and decaying wavefunctions are present. By analytically continuing the semiclassical wavefunction around each turning point and carefully matching across the boundaries, we obtain a globally consistent solution across all regions. The tunnelling probability then follows from the asymptotic amplitudes of the running wave in region I. III Wavefunction Matching via Analytic Continuation III.1 Semiclassical solutions in different regions Schrödinger equation for Bblg, at a given valley, subject to in-plane electric field F , reads \displaystyle\left[\left(\begin{array}[]{cc}\Delta&\frac{p_{+}^{2}}{2m}\\ \frac{p_{-}^{2}}{2m}&-\Delta\end{array}\right)-Fx\right]\psi=\varepsilon\psi. The filling of states is shown in Fig. 1 . Writing the wave function as \displaystyle\psi(x,y)=e^{ik_{y}y}\begin{pmatrix}a(x)\\ b(x)\end{pmatrix}, (4) the x -component of the probability current is \displaystyle