A Hetero-functional Graph Theory Perspective of Engineering Management of Mega-Projects
Amirreza Hosseini, Amro M. Farid · 2025
Read A Hetero-functional Graph Theory Perspective of Engineering Management of Mega-Projects by Amirreza Hosseini, Amro M. Farid (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-24045.txt.
Introduction
Megaprojects, the billion-dollar builds that take years and affect millions of people, fail often, and researchers still debate why managing them is so hard. Amirreza Hosseini and Amro Farid argue that megaproject research should borrow from production system management, where factories are planned and run as reconfigurable systems.
They propose pairing model-based systems engineering with hetero-functional graph theory, a method born in mass-customized production that links the physical and information parts of a system in one model. Building on a large recent review of the field, they show how this pairing answers many of that review's closing recommendations. Beyond matching current thinking, the framework could give megaproject management a single shared theory base. The authors frame it as a step toward managing huge one-off projects with the discipline of production engineering.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Amirreza Hosseini, Amro M. Farid |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 45 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-24045
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Hetero-functional Graph Theory Perspective of Engineering Management of Mega-Projects Amirreza Hosseini, Amro M. Farid Abstract Megaprojects are large-scale, complex, and one-off engineering endeavors that require significant investments from a public or private sector. Such projects generally cost more than a billion dollars, take many years to develop and construct, involve stakeholders both in the public and private sectors, and impact millions of people. Most of the extant megaproject research is concerned with understanding why the engineering management of megaprojects fails so frequently and which dimensions make them so difficult to manage, including size, uncertainty, complexity, urgency, and institutional structure [ 1 ] . Recently, the literature on mega-projects has advocated for a convergence of the engineering management and production system management literature. To that end, this paper proposes the use of Model-Based System Engineering (MBSE) and Hetero-Functional Graph Theory (HFGT), where the latter, quite interestingly, finds its origins in the mass-customized production system literature. More specifically, HFGT was developed so that the physical and informatic parts of production system planning, operations, and decision-making are readily reconfigured to support production customization at scale. As the literature on megaprojects is rapidly evolving with a significant amount of divergence between authors, this report builds upon the recent and extensive megaproject literature review provided by Denicol et. al. [ 1 ] . The paper concludes that MBSE and HFGT provide a means for addressing many of the concluding recommendations provided by Denicol et. al. MBSE and HFGT not only align with current research on megaprojects but also push the boundaries of how the engineering management of megaprojects can gain a unified theoretical foundation. I Introduction: Motivation Megaprojects are large-scale, complex, and one-off investments in a variety of public and private sectors. They generally cost more than a billion dollars, take many years to develop and construct, involve stakeholders both in the public and private sectors, and impact millions of people. Examples of megaprojects include: the Suez Canal, the Montreal Summer Olympics, and the Sydney Opera House [ 2 ] . Based on the Oxford Handbook of Mega-Projects, they are designed ambitiously to change the structure of society in spite of the fact that some small projects in the same domain have more well-established precedents [ 3 ] . Megaprojects, however, are not just a magnified version of a smaller project in the same domain, they are often a completely different type of project in terms of the level of aspiration, stakeholder involvement, lead-time, complexity, and impact [ 3 ] . Consequently, they also demand a greater level of leadership. Flyvberjg estimates the global expenditure on megaprojects at US6-9 trillion dollars annually [ 2 ] . Consequently, the management of these complex projects has garnered attention for more intensive research, along with a growing need to understand the specific governance challenges they present [ 4 ] . Flyvbjerg, in his book [ 5 ] , refers to these multibillion-dollar megaprojects as a new ’political and physical animal’ encountered across the world. Several studies, including [ 6 ] , indicate that the number of papers featuring keywords related to the megaproject management literature has more than doubled during the 20-year period from 2004 to 2023, compared to the period from 1984 to 2003. Additionally, the growing interconnectivity among nations and the pressing need for infrastructure development in developing countries to match the standards of developed nations have led to an increasing number of megaprojects. These projects often involve international collaboration and present more complex risks than traditional megaprojects, necessitating advanced risk management strategies to overcome both foreseen and unforeseen risks such as disasters and distruptions [ 7 , 8 , 9 ] . Most of the extant megaproject research is concerned with understanding why megaprojects fail so frequently and which dimensions make megaprojects so difficult to manage including size, uncertainty, complexity, urgency, and institutional structure [ 1 ] . A review of the existing literature reveals that early research on megaprojects predominantly focused on construction and infrastructure projects, emphasizing traditional project management dimensions such as cost, time, and benefits. However, over the past two decades, the scope of megaproject research has gradually broadened to include complex R&D (research and development) projects and public-private partnerships (PPPs). Our review highlights that recent studies increasingly focus on keywords such as performance, complexity, risk, innovation, and decision-making [ 6 ] . This complexity and difficulty extend from the organizational environment of these megaprojects to risks within the supply chain and process modeling [ 10 , 11 , 12 ] . However, the degree of complexity is not uniform across all projects [ 13 ] . The Iron Law of Megaproject Management states that 99.5% of megaprojects fail to stay within budget, finish on time, and deliver anticipated benefits. Flyvbjerg recognizes that if approximately one out of ten megaprojects remains within budget, one out of ten stays on schedule, and one out of ten delivers the promised benefits, then approximately one in one thousand projects is an “on-target” success that meets all three goals [ 2 ] . Even if the success rate were to double to 2 out of 10 for each criterion, then only 8 out of 1000 would be successful. Therefore, the majority of megaprojects experience cost overruns, delayed completion, and technical issues [ 14 ] .Consequently, the Iron Law of Megaproject Management imposes a strong call to action [ 2 ] . Additionally, certain megaprojects, such as the Boston Big Dig and the Los Angeles Subway, have become notorious for their extensive cost overruns [ 15 , 16 ] . Cost overruns and benefit shortfalls are the most common phenomena in megaprojects [ 8 , 17 , 18 , 12 ] , and have been rigorously analyzed in the literature [ 19 ] . In some instances, there is evidence of intentional misrepresentation and misinformation contributing to these overruns [ 20 ] . Nevertheless, a few projects have been completed on time and within budget, only to face immediate operational failures. This paradox is aptly captured by the old adage: “The surgery was a success, but the patient died.” Thus, it is crucial to distinguish between executing a project successfully and achieving the intended outcomes [ 11 , 21 ] . Moreover, Denicol et. al find that, at present, there is no single concept or framework that can account for the multiple causes of and cures for poor megaproject performance [ 1 ] . In addition to the previously mentioned causes of megaproject failure, several studies highlight the role of organizational culture and strategies to strengthen it for more effective collaboration [ 22 , 23 , 24 ] . Some researchers argue that the diversity of organizational cultures within megaprojects presents an alternative perspective to Flyvbjerg’s view [ 5 ] , which attributes megaproject motivations primarily to vested interests [ 22 ] . Martin’s approach, which focuses on ambiguity, power dynamics, and situational factors in organizational culture, provides valuable insights for addressing the daily challenges of megaprojects [ 24 ] . The concept of megaproject culture is characterized by inherent ambiguity, with unclear boundaries and a duality between the tangible elements and the stakeholders striving to bring the project to fruition [ 25 ] . This