On the Physical Untenability of the Standard Notion of Quantum State
Christian de Ronde · 2025
Read On the Physical Untenability of the Standard Notion of Quantum State by Christian de Ronde (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23989.txt.
Introduction
Christian de Ronde, writing alone, offers a 2025 paper that challenges a core notion in quantum mechanics: the quantum state. The standard account of the theory, set in the 1930s, rests on that notion. De Ronde argues that the account gives several definitions of it that do not agree with each other.
Those clashing definitions, he says, are still blurred together in mainstream physics and philosophy writing. The blur leads to self-contradictory claims and wrong conclusions. The paper lays out the inconsistencies one by one. It closes by arguing the notion, as standardly used, cannot support a rational reading of the theory.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christian de Ronde |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 43 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23989
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
On the Physical Untenability of the Standard Notion of Quantum State Christian de Ronde Abstract The notion of quantum state plays a fundamental role within the Standard account of Quantum Mechanics (SQM) as established by Dirac and von Neumann during 1930s and up to the present. In this work we expose the deep inconsistencies that exist within the multiple definitions of the notion of quantum state that are provided within this axiomatic formulation. As we will argue, these different inconsistent definitions continue to be —even today— uncritically confused within the mainstream physical and philosophical literature leading to self-contradictory statements and wrong conclusions. We end with a discussion regarding the untenability of this concept for any rational understanding of theoretical physics. Philosophy Institute Dr. A. Korn, University of Buenos Aires - CONICET Center Leo Apostel for Interdisciplinary Studies Foundations of the Exact Sciences - Vrije Universiteit Brussel Institute of Engineering - National University Arturo Jauretche Keywords: quantum state, purity, standard quantum mechanics. “The classical concept of state becomes lost [in QM], in that at most a well-chosen half of a complete set of variables can be assigned definite numerical values.” Erwin Schödinger Introduction Today, it is commonly accepted within the physics community —since Richard Feynman [ 16 ] made it explicit to a packed audience of young undergraduate students in 1964— that “nobody understands quantum mechanics.” This might seem very strange given that another common statement made by contemporary physicists, which contradicts the former, is that “the theory describes a microscopic realm composed of elementary particles”. Of course, if the first statement is true the second one cannot be the case. This problematic situation regarding understanding is many times escaped by physicists who suddenly shift the attention to the fact the theory of quanta has been —anyhow— incredibly successful from a technological perspective. In this respect, it was the Manhattan project —on which Feynman himself took part— which exposed most clearly that understanding and technological development did not necessarily go hand in hand. Karl Popper would describe the radical shift that contributed to this new pragmatic account of physics during the late 1950s: “Today the view of physical science founded by Osiander, Cardinal Bellarmino, and Bishop Berkeley, has won the battle without another shot being fired. Without any further debate over the philosophical issue, without producing any new argument, the instrumentalist view (as I shall call it) has become an accepted dogma. It may well now be called the ‘official view’ of physical theory since it is accepted by most of our leading theorists of physics (although neither by Einstein nor by Schrödinger). And it has become part of the current teaching of physics.” [ 26 , pp. 99-100] According to Popper, this new understanding of physics would become wildly accepted for two main reasons. Firstly, due to the influence of Bohr’s complementarity approach in QM —which he himself famously criticized [ 29 ] —, and secondly, due to the effectiveness of the Manhattan Project , exposed to the world with a “big bang” in August 6, 1945 [ 26 , pp. 101] . And still, regardless of its powerful technological applications, there are many dead ends that rise when attempting to explain or understand the Standard formulation of Quantum Mechanics (SQM) —first presented by Dirac and von Neumann in the 1930s. But maybe the most powerful consequence of the instrumentalist account of physics, established after the IIWW [ 17 ] , is that the lack of understanding would not be regarded anymore as a problem. Physics would be understood as a discipline for predicting observations and “solving problems”. Period. As a consequence, when faced to the many questions raised by critical students in physics classrooms, Professors would feel confident enough to shout to them: “Shut up and calculate!” There are many records of this common procedure that continues taking place even today (see for a detailed review [ 8 ] ). A good example is given by Lee Smolin who recalls: “When I learned physics in the 1970s, it was almost as if we were being taught to look down on people who thought about foundational problems. When we asked about the foundational issues in quantum theory, we were told that no one fully understood them but that concern with them was no longer part of science. The job was to take quantum mechanics as given and apply it to new problems. The spirit was pragmatic; ‘Shut up and calculate’ was the mantra. People who couldn’t let go of their misgivings over the meaning of quantum theory were regarded as losers who couldn’t do the work.” [ 28 , p. 312] In this same respect, Sean Carroll [ 7 ] has recently described what happens —even today— to students that do not follow these basic instructions: “Many people are bothered when they are students and they first hear [about SQM]. And when they ask questions they are told to shut up. And if they keep asking they are asked to leave the field of physics.” But what are these difficulties with which students are faced when learning the standard Dirac-von Neumann axiomatic formulation of the theory of quanta? As we shall discuss in this work, the difficulties begin already with the first postulate of the theory which can be found in any textbook presentation of SQM. This first postulate, which focuses on the notion of quantum state , runs more or less as follows: Postulate 0.1 . The possible states of a quantum system are represented by normalised vectors in some complex Hilbert space. However, this is not the only definition that can be found within mainstream textbooks. There are —at least— four different definitions that are —implicitly— considered to be equivalent, consistent and meaningful. As we shall discuss in this work none of this is true. The paper is organized as follows. In section 1 we discuss four different definitions that can be found in any mainstream SQM textbook. Section 2 discusses the irrepresentable rule that bridges the gap between quantum superpositions and observable measurement outcomes. In section 3 we discuss a widespread confusion present in the literature surrounding the notions of pure state and quantum superposition and, in section 4, we discuss what is considered to be the same through the notion of physical state . Finally, in section 5, we will argue that the physical untenability of the notion of quantum state implies a very deep problem for any rational theoretical representation of QM that attempts to scientifically discuss about an evolving state of affairs. 1 The Orthodox Notion(s) of Quantum State Let us begin by considering the different mathematical definitions of the notion of quantum state that are presented within the mainstream physical literature. First of all, as presented in the first postulate, there is a widespread account of quantum states given in highly abstract mathematical terms, as referring to vectors in Hilbert space. This gives rise to the first definition: Definition 1.1 (Abstract Vector State) . An abstract unit vector (i.e., with no reference to any basis), \Psi , in Hilbert space is a pure state. In terms of density operators \rho is a pure state if it is a projector, namely, if Tr (\rho^{2})=1