Higher-homotopy wild sets

Jeremy Brazas, Atish Mitra · 2025

Read Higher-homotopy wild sets by Jeremy Brazas, Atish Mitra (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23665.txt.

Introduction

Jeremy Brazas and Atish Mitra study wild sets in topology in a 2025 paper. A wild set gathers the points of a space where tiny loops, or higher sphere maps, stay essential no matter how small they shrink.

The authors show that the homotopy type of this set, for each dimension, does not change when the space is stretched in ways that preserve that type. For a class of metric spaces with a shape condition, even the homeomorphism type of the set is an invariant. That mirrors the known one dimensional case. They also prove a striking result: the wild set of a Peano continuum can match any compact metric space at all.

Catalog record

CREATORJeremy Brazas, Atish Mitra
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE74 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23665

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Higher-homotopy wild sets Jeremy Brazas, Atish Mitra Abstract . The π n \pi_{n} -wild set 𝐰 n ​ ( X ) \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) of a topological space X X is the subspace of X X consisting of the points at which there exists a shrinking sequence of essential based maps S n → X S^{n}\to X . In this paper, we show that the homotopy type of 𝐰 n ​ ( X ) \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) is a homotopy invariant of X X and, in analogy to the known one-dimensional case, we show that for certain n n -dimensional π n \pi_{n} -shape injective metric spaces, the homeomorphism type of 𝐰 n ​ ( X ) \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) is a homotopy invariant of X X . We also prove that the π n \pi_{n} -wild set of a Peano continuum can be homeomorphic to any compact metric space. 2010 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 55Q52 , 55Q35 ; Secondary 08A65 1. Introduction There are many potential definitions of “wild point” in a topological space. From the perspective of algebraic topology, if a space has wild points, e.g. if it fails to be locally contractible or semilocally simply connected, then some standard methods in homotopy theory fail to apply to the space in question. Notably, the Whitehead Theorem stating that “weakly homotopy equivalence spaces are homotopy equivalent” [ 40 ] may not be applicable. On the other hand, the existence of wild points is surprisingly helpful for distinguishing and classifying homotopy types of some families of Peano continua (compact, connected, locally connected metric spaces). It is a major achievement in the algebraic topology of locally complicated spaces that the Whitehead Theorem holds for one-dimensional Peano continua [ 18 ] and planar Peano continua [ 33 ] . The following question remains open. Problem 1.1 . Does the Whitehead Theorem hold for all finite dimensional Peano continua? That is, if f:X\to Y is a weak homotopy equivalence of finite-dimensional Peano continua, must f be a homotopy equivalence? Problem 1.1 has a negative answer for general Peano continua as infinite dimensional, non-contractible spaces with trivial homotopy groups are constructed by Karimov and Repovš in [ 31 ] and [ 32 ] . In [ 32 , Problem 5.1] , Karimov and Repovš ask if there exists a finite dimensional non-contractible Peano continuum with trivial homotopy groups. The existence of such a space would answer Problem 1.1 in the negative but no counterexample has been produced so far. A key to proving the Whitehead Theorem in the one-dimensional and planar cases is the use of the “wild” or “bad” set \mathbf{w}_{1}(X) consisting of all points in X at which X fails to be semilocally simply connected (and denoted various ways in the literature). For one-dimensional and planar X , the wild set \mathbf{w}_{1}(X) is rigid in the sense that it is fixed under all maps X\to X that are homotopic to the identity map. Moreover, this rigidity implies that the homeomorphism type of \mathbf{w}_{1}(X) is a homotopy invariant of X . In fact, for one-dimensional spaces X where all points are wild points, the isomorphism type of the fundamental group \pi_{1}(X) alone determines the entire homeomorphism type of the space [ 9 , 10 ] . These invariance results are implicit to the arguments used in [ 11 , 17 ] and are explicitly stated and proved in [ 5 , Section 9] . In addition to the depth of applications in low-dimensional settings, wild sets also have utility in broader contexts since, in general, the homotopy type of \mathbf{w}_{1}(X) is a homotopy invariant of X [ 4 , Theorem 2.11] . Whether one seeks to answer Problem 1.1 in the affirmative or negative, the successful one-dimensional and planar theories suggest the relevancy of higher-dimensional wild sets. In this paper, we define and study subspaces of a given space X that consist of points where algebraic wildness occurs in higher-dimensional homotopy groups. We say that a point x\in X is a \pi_{n} -wild point if there exists a sequence of essential, i.e. non-null-homotopic, maps f_{k}:S^{n}\to X , k\in\mathbb{N} based at x that converge to the constant map at x in the compact-open topology. To simplify this concept, we note that such sequences can be adjoined to form what we call a “fully essential” based map f:(\mathbb{E}_{n},b_{0})\to(X,x) on the n -dimensional infinite earring space \mathbb{E}_{n} . The \pi_{n} -wild set of X is the subspace \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) of X consisting of all \pi_{n} -wild points of X . In Sections 2 and 3 we establish various properties and examples relevant to \pi_{n} -wild sets. In Section 4 , we prove that the homotopy type of \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) is a homotopy invariant of X , that is, if X\simeq Y , then \mathbf{w}_{n}(X)\simeq\mathbf{w}_{n}(Y) (see Theorem 4.6 ) and we use this fact to distinguish homotopy types without directly appealing to uncountable algebraic invariants. In Section 5 , we use “shrinking point-attachment spaces,” similar to those applied in [ 19 , 20 ] , to prove the following theorem. In particular, this result shows that the \pi_{n} -wild set of a Peano continuum may be an arbitrary compact metric space. Theorem 1.2 . Let n\geq 1 . If X is a Peano continuum, then \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) is a compact metric space. Moreover, if C is any compact metric space, then there exists a Peano continuum X such that (1) \mathbf{w}_{n}(X)=C , (2) X\backslash C is a countable disjoint union of open 1 -cells and open n -cells, (3) \dim(X)=\max\{\dim(C),n\} . In Section 6 , we extend the established one-dimensional theory by showing that higher \pi_{n} -wild sets are “rigid” for certain n -dimensional spaces. We say that a space X is \pi_{n} -rigid at x\in X if there exists a fully essential map f:(\mathbb{E}_{n},b_{0})\to(X,x) that cannot be freely homotoped away from the point x , i.e. if every homotopy F:\mathbb{E}_{n}\times[0,1]\to X extending f by F(a,0)=f(a) must satisfy F(b_{0},1)=x . We set \mathbf{rg}_{n}(X)=\{x\in X\mid X\text{ is }\pi_{n}\text{-rigid at }x\} and say that X is completely \pi_{n} -rigid if X is \pi_{n} -rigid at every \pi_{n} -wild point, i.e. if \mathbf{rg}_{n}(X)=\mathbf{w}_{n}(X) . The main utility of this last concept is that if X and Y are homotopy equivalent and both X and Y are completely \pi_{n} -rigid spaces, then \mathbf{w}_{n}(X) and \mathbf{w}_{n}(Y) are homeomorphic (Theorem 6.7 ). As noted above, it is known that every one-dimensional metric space is completely \pi_{1} -rigid. In the one-dimensional and planar settings, one can readily distinguish fundamental group elements using the fact that such spaces are \pi_{1} -shape injective, that is, the canonical homomorphism \pi_{1}(X)\to\check{\pi}_{1}(X) from the fundamental group to the first shape homotopy group is always injective [ 7 , 26 ] . However, for n\geq 2 , an n -dimensional Peano continuum X need not be \pi_{n} -shape injective (the canonical homomorphism \pi_{n}(X)\to\check{\pi}_{n}(X) need not be injective) [ 21 , 25 , 30 ] . Hence, to identify a higher-dimensional analogue of the result that one-dimensional spaces are completely \pi_{1} -rigid, we restrict to n -dimensional, \pi_{n} -shape injective Peano continua. We prove the following in Section 6 . Theorem 1.3 . Let n\geq 1 . If X is an n -dimensional, \pi_{n} -shape injective Peano continuum that can

Read the complete text