Visualizing Three-Qubit Entanglement

Alfred Benedito, Germán Sierra · 2025

Read Visualizing Three-Qubit Entanglement by Alfred Benedito, Germán Sierra (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23638.txt.

Introduction

Alfred Benedito and Germán Sierra offer a 2025 picture based way to see entanglement in states of three qubits. Entanglement links particles so that one cannot be fully described apart from the others, and three qubit cases split into classes with unlike structure. Their framework draws each class in geometric form.

The authors study the shape tied to each class and type, and link that view to a measure called the tangle. They derive bounds that depend on the class, and propose a purely geometric formula for the tangle and a related quantity in non generic cases. As a use case, they look at energy states of physical systems and give conditions for true three way entanglement to survive small symmetry breaking changes.

Catalog record

CREATORAlfred Benedito, Germán Sierra
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE63 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23638

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Visualizing Three-Qubit Entanglement Alfred Benedito, Germán Sierra Abstract We present a graphical framework to represent entanglement in three-qubit states. The geometry associated with each entanglement class and type is analyzed, revealing distinct structural features. We explore the connection between this geometric perspective and the tangle, deriving bounds that depend on the entanglement class. Based on these insights, we conjecture a purely geometric expression for both the tangle and Cayley’s hyperdeterminant for non-generic states. As an application, we analyze the energy eigenstates of physical Hamiltonians, identifying the sufficient conditions for genuine tripartite entanglement to be robust under symmetry-breaking perturbations and level repulsion effects. I Introduction Entanglement is a consequence of the superposition principle, where quantum states cannot be written in product form on any local basis entangled_states__horodecki . Although their existence was first pointed out by Einstein, Podolski and Rosen in 1935 EPR__paper , it was not until the late 1990s and early 2000s that the study and classification of entanglement in systems of more than 2 qubits picked the interest of physicists due to the realization that they could be used as a resource in information processing and communication. This is because entanglement differs from classical correlations even if one uses local hidden variables Bell_theorem__paper . The \left|{\text{GHZ}}\right\rangle state GHZ_state__paper sparked interest in the aforementioned classification 1 1 1 It also turned out to be the unique state that is maximally entangled in 3-qubit systems acin_decomp_paper__cit_5 , which means that all its information is encoded purely on its entanglement. This can be concluded by observing that all its 1-qubit reduced density matrices are just the maximally mixed state. , with early attempts revolving around the study of the orbits of U(2)^{\otimes n} acin_decomp_paper__cit_4 , but later moving to the modern paradigm of entanglement measures earliest_entang_measure__paper such as Benett’s entanglement of formation 00__bennet . This measure was later extended to any 2-qubit mixed state 01__1__wooters ; 01__2__Wooters through a quantity known as the concurrence \mathcal{C} . With it, it wash shown that, if one has a system of 3 qubits A , B and C , then there is a trade-off between A ’s entanglement with B and with C tangle_introduction . In other words, the sharing of entanglement is restricted. This is a core difference between classical and quantum correlations, measured by the tangle \tau 2 2 2 Moreover, Wooters, Coffman and Kundu conjectured that such a relation should also exist for systems of more qubits (known as the CKW conjecture, later proven true by Osborne and Verstraete verstraete_nTangle ). . This showed that there were two inequivalent ways of entangling all 3 qubits in a pure 3-qubit state, allowing the classification of pure 3-qubit states Cirac_3qbit_classes based on defining entanglement classes as sets of states that map onto themselves under invertible SLOCC 3 3 3 The methods can be used to classify 4 qubit states as well verstraete_4qubits_classes . . They identified 6 different entanglement classes (see Fig. 1 ), which can be fully characterized by 4 parameters (see Table 1 ). Figure 1: Entanglement classes (from Cirac_3qbit_classes ) Class S_{A} S_{B} S_{C} \tau A-B-C 0 0 0 0 A-BC 0 >0 >0 0 B-AC >0 0 >0 0 C-AB >0 >0 0 0 W >0 >0 >0 0 GHZ >0 >0 >0 >0 Table 1: Values of the local entropies and the tangle for the different classes (from Cirac_3qbit_classes ). From the group orbit analysis acin_decomp_paper__cit_4 it was known that the number of entanglement invariant parameters had to be 5 for 3-qubit states but so far only 4 had been used. This pointed towards the existence of further structure yet to be found within these classes. This structure was understood by means of a Generalized Schmidt / Canonical Decomposition (CD) for 3-qubit states acin_decomp_paper . The CD showed there is a canonical form unique for all states related by Local Unitaries (LUs) that uses only 5 of the 8 basis elements. Depending on which basis elements had null coefficients, one could identify different sub-classes (or Types ). This classification is quite difficult to visualize, because it depends on the 5 entanglement invariants \{J_{l}\}_{l=1}^{5} (which are hard to relate to physical observables). For 1 qubit states, a typical graphical representation is the Bloch sphere S^{2} representing the expectation values of spin observables. For 2 qubits, Mosseri and Dandoloff first_hopfQubit_paper reinterpreted this Bloch sphere map as fibrating S^{3} with S^{1} : a Hopf Fibration. This way, the generalization of the Bloch sphere follows immediately. For 3-qubits one can do a similar construction second_hopfQubit_paper , but the fundamental difference (for our interests) is that the construction is then sensitive to the entanglement between A and BC but it says nothing about entanglement between B and C . Mosseri proposed for this case to instead use the three Bloch-norms (r_{A},r_{B},r_{C}) which are also entanglement invariants (they belong to a set first found by Sudbery Sudbery_2001_simpler_invariants ; acin_decomp_paper ). It’s these three invariants along with the tangle that will be the main focus of our work. The main aim of this paper is investigating how 3-qubit entanglement can be visualized with physical observables in a geometrical picture. We study how Mosseri’s proposal results in a more physical and geometrical characterization of different entanglement classes and types in what we call Bloch-norm representation . This naturally leads to a series of bounds between the tangle and the norm of a vector. An important consequence of those results is that we can conjecture a formula for calculating Cayley’s hyperdeterminant cayley_paper ; adrian_latorre_paper ; latorre_cited_book ; tangle_introduction which relies purely on geometrical characteristics. This is fairly striking, since contrary to the regular determinant (which can be understood geometrically as a measure of volume) the hyperdeterminant does not have a simple geometric interpretation. The second goal is the application of these geometrical tools to the study of the entanglement present in the energy eigenstates of physical Hamiltonians , where we identify the sufficient conditions for genuine tripartite entanglement to be robust under perturbations. The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. II we briefly review the graphical aspect of Mosseri’s proposal. The original work of this paper begins in Sec. III which is devoted to the study of the relation between the Bloch-norm representation and the tangle. We derive bounds for \tau depending on the Bloch-norms and geometrically characterize it for states belonging to the GHZ class. Finally, in Sec. IV we consider physical systems of three qubits characterized by different Hamiltonians. We study the Bloch-norm properties of their energy eigenstates and characterize the source of their tangle. To do so, we developed a Python library to automate the analytic computations as much as possible. Finally, Appendix B contains the details of the fibration procedure needed to obtain the bounds of Sec. III , and in Appendix C we provide the exact calculations for the chains in further detail. II Graphical representation of entanglement Let us first present a summary of the classification of 3-qubit states and their tangle. Starting by the concurrence, this is a quantity which measures the entanglement between two bipartitions of a state. In the simplest case, a 2-qubit state of components \{v_{ij}\}_{i,j\in\{0,1\}} , it reduces to \propto|v_{00}v_{11}-v_{01}v_{10}| that is 0 if the

Read the complete text