Si(100)-SiO 2 Trap Density Dependence on Sample Processing

Adam J. Czarnecki, Nikola L. Kolev, Patrick See, Nick Sullivan, Wyatt A. Behn, Neil J. Curson, Taylor J.Z. Stock, Peter Grütter · 2025

Read Si(100)-SiO 2 Trap Density Dependence on Sample Processing by Adam J. Czarnecki, Nikola L. Kolev, Patrick See, Nick Sullivan, Wyatt A. Behn, Neil J. Curson, Taylor J.Z. Stock, Peter Grütter (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23574.txt.

Introduction

Adam Czarnecki and co-authors map tiny charge traps at the boundary between silicon and its oxide in a 2025 paper. As silicon devices shrink, these traps drag down performance: they slow carriers in chips and add noise that shortens the life of quantum states. Knowing exactly where traps sit helps engineers judge their harm.

Using a sensitive force microscope method, the team detected single traps and charted them across samples. They compared standard silicon with samples prepared for hydrogen-based atomic-scale patterning. Hydrogen treatment lowered the density of donor-like traps, confirming its calming effect. The patterned samples showed a marked drop in a flickering two-level kind of trap as well. The authors suggest such prepared silicon may suit high-performance nanoscale and atomic-scale devices.

Catalog record

CREATORAdam J. Czarnecki, Nikola L. Kolev, Patrick See, Nick Sullivan, Wyatt A. Behn, Neil J. Curson, Taylor J.Z. Stock, Peter Grütter
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE28 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23574

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Si(100)-SiO 2 Trap Density Dependence on Sample Processing Preprint: AIP/123-QED Adam J. Czarnecki, Nikola L. Kolev, Patrick See, Nick Sullivan, Wyatt A. Behn, Neil J. Curson, Taylor J.Z. Stock, Peter Grütter Abstract As silicon-based devices continue to shrink to the nanoscale, traps at the Si-SiO 2 interface pose increasing challenges to device performance. These traps reduce channel carrier mobility and shift threshold voltages in integrated circuits, and introduce charge noise in quantum systems, reducing their coherence times. Knowledge of the precise location of such traps aids in understanding their influence on device performance. In this work, we demonstrate that frequency-modulated atomic force microscopy (fm-AFM) allows the detection of individual traps. We use this to study how sample preparation, specifically the introduction of a buried hydrogen termination layer, and post-processing annealing in forming gas (N 2 +H 2 ), affects the density of donor-like traps in Si(100)-SiO 2 systems. We spatially map and quantify traps in both conventionally prepared (“pristine”) silicon samples and those processed under ultra-high vacuum for hydrogen resist lithography (HRL). We confirm previous studies demonstrating hydrogen passivation of traps and find that hydrogen termination further reduces the donor-like trap density. We also observe a significant reduction in two-level donor-like traps in the hydrogen-terminated samples compared to pristine silicon samples. These findings suggest that HRL-prepared silicon may offer advantages for high-performance nanoscale and atomic-scale devices due to reduced trap densities. Silicon remains the foundational material for modern electronics, from everyday computing to emerging quantum technologies. As devices shrink to the nanoscale, their performance becomes increasingly sensitive to material imperfections, particularly at the Si-SiO 2 interface. These defects include interfacial traps, arising from the mismatch between the silicon and oxide crystals, as well as oxide traps within the oxide layer itself. Such traps can disrupt electronic properties by introducing charge noise, lowering carrier mobility, shifting threshold voltages, and increasing leakage currents Kato, Yamasaki, and Uda 2006 ; Campbell et al. 2007 ; Kirton and Uren 1989 ; Cowie et al. 2024a . These issues are particularly concerning for field-effect devices such as metal–oxide–semiconductor field-effect transistors (MOSFETs) Chen et al. 2019 , as well as emerging silicon-based quantum technologies Wang and Clerk 2021 ; Ambal et al. 2016 . Reducing trap density is therefore a key challenge in the fabrication of high-performance devices. Hydrogen and deuterium passivation of interfacial traps in Si-SiO 2 systems via thermal annealing has been well studied Stesmans 1996 ; Stesmans 2000 ; Brower 1990 ; Cartier, Stathis, and Buchanan 1993 ; Pantelides et al. 2000 ; Lyding, Hess, and Kizilyalli 1996 . The experimental methods typically used to characterize trap densities in these studies include electron spin resonance and nuclear magnetic resonance. These techniques quantify average trap densities over large sample areas. As device dimensions continue to shrink, the spacing between individual traps can become comparable to, or even larger than, the device’s critical dimension. Consequently, it is necessary to know the precise location of traps to understand their influence on device performance, as global trap density is less relevant than the exact position with respect to a device. In this work, we demonstrate that frequency-modulated atomic force microscopy (fm-AFM) allows the detection of individual traps. We use this to study how sample preparation—specifically hydrogen termination and post-processing annealing in forming gas (N 2 +H 2 )—affects the density of donor-like traps in Si(100)-SiO 2 systems. We spatially map and quantify traps in two types of silicon surfaces: conventionally prepared (“pristine”) silicon and hydrogen-terminated Si(100) prepared under ultra-high vacuum conditions, each with a native oxide layer. The latter is commonly used as a substrate in hydrogen resist lithography (HRL), a scanning tunneling microscopy-based technique for atomic-scale patterning Lyding et al. 1994 . HRL has shown promise for building single-atom transistors, quantum dots, and other atomically precise devices Fuechsle et al. 2012 ; Wyrick et al. 2019 ; Huff et al. 2018 ; Achal et al. 2018 ; Weber et al. 2014 ; Wang et al. 2022 . However, the impact of hydrogen termination on trap densities has not been widely studied. This work examines how hydrogen termination and post-processing annealing influence trap densities at the Si(100)-SiO 2 interface. Our results highlight how fabrication and processing choices affect interface quality, offering insights for improving both conventional and quantum device architectures. We also demonstrate the utility of fm-AFM as a non-destructive tool for characterizing interfacial defects at the nanoscale. All experiments were performed on silicon samples taken from the same initial wafer, which was boron-doped \left(9.15\times 10^{14}/\text{cm}^{3}\right) and 500 µm thick. The preparation of clean Si(100) surfaces, and subsequent hydrogen termination, took place in an ultra-high vacuum (UHV) chamber, with a base pressure of around 4\times 10^{-10} mbar. A clean Si(100) surface was prepared by direct current heating to 600 ∘ C for 8 hours, followed by multiple flash anneals at 1200 ∘ C, and then slow cooling over 30 minutes to allow the surface to relax into a Si(100)- 2\times 1 surface reconstruction with minimal defects. H-termination was performed by exposing the surface to an atomic hydrogen beam while using direct current heating to maintain a sample temperature of 320 ∘ C. The beam was generated by thermally cracking H 2 , at a H 2 partial pressure of 5\times 10^{-7} mbar. Molecular beam epitaxy was then used to cap the sample in 3 nm of epitaxial silicon. The first 10 monolayers (the locking layer) was grown at room temperature, followed by a rapid thermal anneal at 470 ∘ C for 15 s. The rest of the silicon was then grown while the sample temperature was kept at 250 ∘ C. This is a common method for encapsulating devices fabricated using HRL, as it minimizes the diffusion of atomically precise positioned dopant atoms. The sample was subsequently removed from UHV to allow for a native oxide, of around 1 nm, to form at the surface, and diced into three parts. To examine how annealing in a forming gas affects the density of Si(100)-SiO 2 traps, three types of post-fabrication anneals were studied: no anneal (control), N 2 gas, and N 2 +H 2 forming gas. This was repeated for two types of Si(100) samples: unprocessed Si(100) - which was not cleaned in UHV or subsequently hydrogen terminated - and is referred to as “pristine silicon”, and Si(100) which was processed as one would for HRL Lyding et al. 1994 ; Stock et al. 2020 , referred to as “H-terminated silicon”. The post-fabrication anneals were all performed 250 ∘ C for 5 minutes at atmospheric pressure, repeated four times for each sample. The ratio of the N 2 +H 2 forming gas was 95%/5%. The spatial density of traps in the samples was characterized with fm-AFM using a metal-coated tip. Traps can be located by mapping the fm-AFM dissipation F_{d} Cowie et al. 2024b . Areas of larger F_{d} due to traps will manifest themselves as rings in a dissipation scan, with the rings centered at the trap locations. The rings are a result of the AFM response due to the ionization of a single trap Cowie et al. 2024b . An example of such a dissipation scan is shown in Fig. 1 , which was obtained from

Read the complete text