When water phase matters: its effect on the stopping cross section for proton therapy and astrophysics

F. Matias 1, N. E. Koval 2, P. de Vera 3, R. Garcia-Molina 3, I. Abril 4, J. M. B. Shorto 1, H. Yoriyaz 1, J. J. N. Pereira 1, T. F. Silva 5, M. H. Tabacniks 5, M. Vos 6, P. L. Grande 7 · 2025

Read When water phase matters: its effect on the stopping cross section for proton therapy and astrophysics by F. Matias 1, N. E. Koval 2, P. de Vera 3, R. Garcia-Molina 3, I. Abril 4, J. M. B. Shorto 1, H. Yoriyaz 1, J. J. N. Pereira 1, T. F. Silva 5, M. H. Tabacniks 5, M. Vos 6, P. L. Grande 7 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23396.txt.

Introduction

Matias and co-authors work out how the phase of water changes the way protons lose energy in it. The work dates to 2025. Exact loss rates in liquid water matter for proton therapy of cancer. They also matter for how protons slow in space ice.

Hard tests on liquid water are scarce, so the team used a live quantum model joined with a known loss method. The model matched test data for ice and vapor well across a wide energy range. It showed clear phase gaps near the peak of the loss curve. A key find is that liquid water and soft ice give the same loss for protons.

Catalog record

CREATORF. Matias 1, N. E. Koval 2, P. de Vera 3, R. Garcia-Molina 3, I. Abril 4, J. M. B. Shorto 1, H. Yoriyaz 1, J. J. N. Pereira 1, T. F. Silva 5, M. H. Tabacniks 5, M. Vos 6, P. L. Grande 7
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE20 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23396

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

When water phase matters: its effect on the stopping cross section for proton therapy and astrophysics Preprint: APS/123-QED F. Matias 1, N. E. Koval 2, P. de Vera 3, R. Garcia-Molina 3, I. Abril 4, J. M. B. Shorto 1, H. Yoriyaz 1, J. J. N. Pereira 1, T. F. Silva 5, M. H. Tabacniks 5, M. Vos 6, P. L. Grande 7 Abstract Accurately quantifying the energy loss rate of proton beams in liquid water is crucial for the precise application and improvement of proton therapy, whereas the slowing down of proton in water ices also plays an important role in astrophysics. However, precisely determining the electronic stopping power, particularly for the liquid phase, has been elusive so far. Experimental techniques are difficult to apply to volatile liquids, and the availability of sufficient reliable measurements has been limited to the solid and vapor phases. The accuracy of current models is typically limited to proton energies just above the energy-loss maximum, making it difficult to predict radiation effects at an energy range of special relevance. We elucidate the phase differences in proton energy loss in water in a wide energy range ( 0.001 − 10 0.001-10 MeV) by means of real-time time-dependent density functional theory combined with the Penn method. This non-perturbative model, more computationally-efficient than current approaches, describes the phase effects in water in excellent agreement with available experimental data, revealing clear deviations around the maximum of the stopping power curve and below. As an important outcome, our calculations reveal that proton stopping quantities of liquid water and amorphous ice are identical, in agreement with recent similar observations for low-energy electrons, pointing out to this equivalence for all charged particles. This could help to overcome the limitation in obtaining reliable experimental information for the biologically-relevant liquid water target. Proton therapy is one of the most advanced tools for cancer treatment Durante and Paganetti 2016 ; Schardt et al. 2010 , as it offers more precision in energy delivery to tumor zones and less damage to healthy tissues than traditional radiotherapy, owing to its characteristic depth-dose profile. Known as the Bragg peak, this profile maximizes the energy delivery by the end of the protons trajectories while sparing the surrounding areas. Understanding how energetic protons lose their energy in biological matter is crucial for the precise control of the radiation dose, importantly affecting the sub-milimetric positioning of the Bragg peak within the patient Andreo 2009 ; Paul 2013 needed for treatment planning. Liquid water is typically used as a target when studying radiation effects due to its biological relevance Nikjoo et al. 2012 ; Nikjoo et al. 2016 , making it an ideal material for effectively investigating the fundamentals of biodamage. The rate at which protons lose energy in liquid water sets the initial conditions for the molecular mechanisms responsible for radiation damage, related to DNA clustered lesions directly produced by secondary electron impact, or indirectly by free radical production Nikjoo et al. 2016 . Uncertainties around the energy-loss maximum (low proton energies, \leq 0.2 MeV) limit the predictive power of biophysical models for proton effects in tissue. In addition to its relevance for proton therapy and the fundamental understanding of proton-matter interaction, studying the different phases of water is also important in astrophysics, where the interaction of cosmic energetic protons with ices plays a significant role Baragiola 2003 ; Farenzena et al. 2005 . Water ice is abundant on comets, interstellar dust and planetary moon’s surfaces Cleeves et al. 2014 ; Dartois et al. 2024 ; Protopapa et al. 2024 ; Sunshine et al. 2006 which are constantly bombarded by solar wind primarily consisting of protons and electrons. Proton irradiation of ice can lead to radiolysis and formation of reactive species including radicals Teolis et al. 2017 as well as to amorphization of crystalline ice Baragiola et al. 2005 . The radiolysis products are crucial for understanding chemical processes in extraterrestrial environments. In astrochemistry, they help explain the chemical evolution of icy bodies in space Jenniskens and Blake 1994 ; Mejía, C. et al. 2024 contributing to the synthesis of organic macromolecules Ligterink et al. 2024 , and may play a role in the chemical enrichment of protoplanetary disks. Understanding protons energy loss in various water phases is therefore essential, as it determines the depth and efficiency of energy deposition that drives such processes. Despite its importance as radiation target both in biomedical applications and astrophysics, the precise values of the electronic stopping power (ESP, average energy loss per unit path length of the proton) of water around its maximum (proton energies \leq 0.2 MeV) are uncertain, particularly for the liquid phase. Volatile liquids such as water are difficult to manipulate in energy loss experiments and, thus, the empirical information on its ESP is scarce Shimizu et al. 2009 ; Shimizu et al. 2010 ; Siiskonen et al. 2011 . The interpretation of experimental measurements closer to the stopping maximum is based on Monte Carlo simulations Shimizu et al. 2009 ; Shimizu et al. 2010 , but the accuracy of the extracted values has been under debate Garcia-Molina et al. 2013 ; de Vera et al. 2019 . Measurements are more straightforward with solid and gas water targets, for which experimental information is more abundant Bauer et al. 1994 ; Phillips 1953 ; Reynolds et al. 1953 ; Mitterschiffthaler and Bauer 1990 ; Baek et al. 2006 . Even though there have been recent claims that liquid water slows down charged particles (specifically low-energy electron beams) similarly to amorphous ice Signorell 2020 , this discussion is not yet settled, still less for proton beams. The issue is also problematic from the theoretical point of view. State-of-the-art calculations for the proton beam ESP in condensed matter are based mainly on the dielectric formalism Penn 1987 ; Nikjoo et al. 2012 ; Garcia-Molina et al. 2012 ; Vos and Grande 2019 ; de Vera et al. 2023 or on first-principles methods such as time-dependent density functional theory (TDDFT) Reeves et al. 2016 ; Yao et al. 2019 ; Gu et al. 2020 ; Taioli et al. 2021 ; Koval et al. 2022 ; Gu et al. 2022 ; Shepard and Kanai 2023 ; Koval et al. 2023 ; Shepard et al. 2023 . The former methodology, even though it can accurately account for the target phase state (by means of the material’s electronic excitation spectrum via its energy loss function, ELF), presents lower accuracy at energies at and below the stopping maximum, due to its perturbative nature. This is precisely the energy range at which the phase effects are expected to be more important. The latter approaches, when applied to atomistic structures, are notably accurate but can be computationally demanding, mainly because of the number of trajectories required to calculate the average ESP for random orientations of the target. There is thus the need for reliable, yet computationally-efficient, non-perturbative theoretical approaches that can provide accurate ESP results even below the stopping maximum, and which can clarify the influence of phase state in the proton energy loss in water. To overcome these limitations, in this work, we use a more efficient computational procedure, which combines real-time TDDFT Borisov et al. 2004 ; Quijada

Read the complete text