The Narrow Formation Pathway of Hot Saturns: Constraints on Initial Planetary Properties gnuplot ( Williams & Kelley 2022 )

Minghao Xie, Sheng Jin, Dong-Hong Wu · 2025

Read The Narrow Formation Pathway of Hot Saturns: Constraints on Initial Planetary Properties gnuplot ( Williams & Kelley 2022 ) by Minghao Xie, Sheng Jin, Dong-Hong Wu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23148.txt.

Introduction

Minghao Xie and co-authors simulate in 2025 why Saturn mass planets are scarce on short orbits, a gap called the hot Saturn desert. That scarcity can test ideas about how gas planets form and change. The team built a large set of made up short period gas planets around sun like and small dwarf stars, varying their starting traits.

They varied mass, glow, core share, and orbit, froze migration, and let each planet cool and lose air over long time spans. Starting mass, glow, and core share proved the main drivers of how a planet's size changes. A survivor shaped like a hot Saturn needed a narrow mix: mass below half of Jupiter, a heavy core share, and a faint starting glow. The match between those limits and theory gives planet formation models a sharp check.

Catalog record

CREATORMinghao Xie, Sheng Jin, Dong-Hong Wu
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE46 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23148

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Narrow Formation Pathway of Hot Saturns: Constraints on Initial Planetary Properties gnuplot ( Williams & Kelley 2022 ) Minghao Xie, Sheng Jin, Dong-Hong Wu Abstract The observed exoplanet population exhibits a scarcity of short-period Saturn-mass planets, a phenomenon referred to as the “hot Saturn desert”. This observational scarcity can be utilized to validate the theories regarding the formation and evolution of gas planets. In this study, we conduct large-scale numerical simulations to explore how the initial conditions of gas planets orbiting solar-type and M-dwarf stars influence their evolutionary trajectories in the semi-major axis versus planetary radius ( a a - R R ) parameter space. We generate a synthetic population of 10,000 short-period gaseous planets by systematically varying their initial planetary masses ( M p M_{\rm p} ), initial planetary luminosities ( L p L_{\rm p} ), initial core mass fractions ( f core f_{\rm core} ), and semi-major axis ( a a ). Furthermore, we assume these gaseous planets have ceased orbital migration and model their long-term thermal evolution, taking into account the impacts of atmospheric evaporation. Our results show that the initial mass, L p L_{\rm p} , and f core f_{\rm core} are the dominant factors controlling radius evolution for short-period gas planets. The key to survival as a hot Saturn analogue appears to be having just the right combination of properties after gas disk dissipation: an M p M_{\rm p} below 0.5 Jupiter Mass ( M Jup M_{\rm Jup} ), a substantial f core f_{\rm core} of ≥ \geq 30%, and relatively low L p L_{\rm p} on the order of 10 − 6 10^{-6} solar luminosity ( L ⊙ L_{\odot} ) or less. The survival criteria for hot Saturn analogs align with theoretically unfavorable initial conditions of gas planets formed via core accretion scenario, naturally explaining the observed boundaries of the hot Saturn desert. I Introduction The exoplanet population exhibits a notable scarcity of short-period planets with Saturn-like masses and radii, creating a distinct “hot-Saturn desert” in the a - R parameter space ( Zhu & Dong 2021 ) . While examples exist (e.g., TOI-1194 b, a planet with a radius of 0.767^{+0.045}_{-0.041}R_{\rm Jup} and a minimum mass of 0.456^{+0.055}_{-0.051}M_{\rm Jup} ; Wang et al. 2024 ), their occurrence rate remains substantially lower than both hot Jupiters and close-in terrestrial planets. From a theoretical perspective, the absence of hot Saturns can be replicated and understood through planetary population synthesis models that are grounded in the core accretion scenario ( Ida & Lin 2004 ; Ida & Lin 2005 ; Mordasini et al. 2012a ; Mordasini et al. 2012b ) . On one hand, when a protoplanet reaches the crossover mass, defined as the point where its solid core mass equals its gaseous envelope mass, typically in the range of 10-30 M_{\oplus} , it undergoes runaway gas accretion and rapidly evolves into a gas giant ( Pollack et al. 1996 ) . On the other hand, gas giants are more likely to form in the outer regions of the protoplanetary disk, where there is a greater abundance of material. These giant planets can arrive short-period orbits only if they are sufficiently large to trigger Type II migration, as outlined in the gas disk migration scenario ( Lin et al. 1996 ) . Taking these two factors into account, it is challenging for Saturn-like planets to reside in short-period orbits. Even if such planets initially reach close-in orbits via disk migration, dynamical instabilities in the post-disc phase may further sculpt the final architecture of planetary systems, potentially removing planets that formed near the desert boundary ( Wu & He 2023 ; He et al. 2024 ) . Furthermore, high-eccentricity migration and atmospheric evaporation processes also play a significant role in sculpting the boundaries of the hot Saturn desert ( Matsakos & Königl 2016 ; Owen & Lai 2018 ) . The synergy of these mechanisms leads to the observed scarcity of hot Saturn exoplanets. Although theoretical models based on the core accretion scenario provide a conceptual explanation for the desert of hot Saturn exoplanets, they do not quantitatively specify which types of planets are unfavorable to form. Because formation theories typically produce all theoretically viable outcomes, rather than predicting which specific outcomes are prohibited. From an observational point of view, the hot Saturn desert manifests as a distinct forbidden region in a - R space, where planets ending up in this region are considered unfavorable. This desert is a statistical feature that emerges from the exoplanet demographics, independent of specific planet formation models. By examining the shape of the hot-Saturn desert, we can backtrack to the early stages of planet formation and quantitatively identify which types of planets are unlikely to form, namely those that would ultimately reside in the desert region. Assuming that there is a virtual population of short-period planets that, after undergoing long-term thermal evolution, could eventually occupy the region now known as the hot Saturn desert, then the initial physical parameters of these hypothetical planets would offer crucial constraints on planet formation theories. Given that the evolved counterparts—hot Saturn analogues—of this hypothetical population are rarely observed in reality, understanding why planets with such initial parameters fail to form in short-period orbits can provide valuable insights into the early stages of planet formation when a gas disk is still present. In this study, we aim to find out the initial physical parameters of the hypothetical population of short-period gaseous planets that are unlikely to exist, as inferred from the shape of the hot Saturn desert. The observed hot Saturn desert represents a distribution feature at a very late stage, after planets have formed, migrated, and undergone long periods of thermal evolution. Hence, we trace back to the early stage when the gas disks had just dissipated and the disk-based migration had just ceased, in order to identify the unfavorable initial planetary parameters. We bypass the constraints of theoretical planet formation models to generate a large number of short-period gaseous planets with a wide range of initial physical parameters. We then track the evolutionary trajectories of these synthetic gaseous planets and determine their final positions in the a - R space. Our results show that the evolution of short-period gaseous exoplanets is strongly linked to atmospheric evaporation, with three primary initial parameters playing a crucial role: M_{\rm p} , L_{\rm p} , and f_{\rm core} . We also find that a group of hot Saturn analogues have ultimately ended up in the hot Saturn desert region. Notably, the initial physical parameters of these hot Saturn analogues, which are essentially the forbidden parameters given the existence of the observed hot Saturn desert, align with the unfavorable initial parameters predicted by the core accretion scenario. This paper is organized as follows. Section II describes our planet grids and our planetary structure and evolution model. In section III , we present the simulation outcomes around solar-type stars, analyze the influence of varying initial planetary parameters, and examine the specific case of planets orbiting M-dwarf stars. Section IV provides a brief summary and discussion. II MODEL II.1 Grid of synthetic gas planets Gaseous planets primarily complete their formation while their host star still retains a protoplanetary disk. During

Read the complete text