Shadowing in CR-Dynamical Systems

Andrew Wood · 2025

Read Shadowing in CR-Dynamical Systems by Andrew Wood (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-23089.txt.

Introduction

Andrew Wood studies shadowing for systems where one state can lead to several in a 2025 paper. In classical dynamics, shadowing means a rough computed path is trailed by a true one nearby. When the rule is a relation rather than a function, the idea splits into flavors.

Wood defines four shadowing properties by mixing strict and loose readings of fake and true paths. The flavors collapse to the classical one for single-valued systems, and one flavor matches the known set-valued notion. He checks how textbook results for identity maps, periodic maps, and isometries carry over, and proves an equivalence with an infinite product construction, dropping a surjectivity assumption earlier work needed.

Catalog record

CREATORAndrew Wood
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE66 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-23089

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Shadowing in CR-Dynamical Systems Thanks: Affiliation: Mathematical Institute, University of Oxford, Andrew Wiles Building, Radcliffe Observatory Quarter, Woodstock Road, Oxford OX2 6GG, United Kingdom. Corresponding author: Andrew Wood, [email protected] . ORCID: 0009-0009-9948-2102 . Andrew Wood Abstract . A CR-dynamical system is a pair ( X , G ) {\left({X,G}\right)} , where X X is a compact metric space and G G is a closed relation on X X . We introduce four ( i , j ) {\left({i,j}\right)} -shadowing properties, obtained by independently varying the quantifiers in the definitions of pseudo-orbit and shadowing. These properties coincide with the classical shadowing property for single-valued systems, while ( 2 , 2 ) {\left({2,2}\right)} -shadowing agrees with the established notion of shadowing for set-valued dynamical systems. We investigate how the classical characterisations of shadowing for the identity map, periodic maps and isometries extend to closed relations. In particular, we obtain rigidity results for ( 2 , 1 ) {\left({2,1}\right)} -shadowing and positive results for ( 1 , 2 ) {\left({1,2}\right)} -shadowing on totally disconnected spaces. Finally, whenever the infinite Mahavier product is non-empty, we prove that a closed relation has the ( 2 , 2 ) {\left({2,2}\right)} -shadowing property if, and only if, its associated Mahavier dynamical system has the shadowing property. This removes the surjectivity hypothesis from a recent corresponding result for set-valued dynamical systems. 2020 Mathematics Subject Classification Primary 37B65; Secondary 54C60, 54H20 1. Introduction An important concept in classical dynamics is the shadowing property, introduced independently by Anosov [ 4 ] and Bowen [ 9 ] , with its inception coming from computers. As such, topological dynamical systems with the shadowing property are suited for computer simulations, yielding fruitful applications [ 16 , 17 , 26 , 27 ] . In classical dynamics, we wish to calculate trajectories of points within our space, but computers make computational errors. This derives the notion of pseudo-orbits which have an error term. The shadowing property then aims to ask the question: given a pseudo-orbit, can we find an actual trajectory with close distance to the pseudo-orbit? Shadowing interacts nicely with other important dynamical properties. In a topological dynamical system with the shadowing property, many dynamical properties are equivalent [ 5 , 18 , 20 ] , allowing for richer dynamics. Standard references for shadowing include Palmer [ 22 ] and Pilyugin [ 24 ] . Beyond topological dynamics, the shadowing property is widely studied in hyperbolic dynamics, with Anosov’s Shadowing Theorem [ 10 , Corollary 5.3.2 ] (also referred to as the Shadowing Lemma) being an important result. Due to the importance of such a property, it is no surprise shadowing has been generalised to set-valued dynamical systems [ 19 , 29 , 25 , 15 , 28 , 30 , 23 , 31 ] . Banič, Erceg, Rogina, and Kennedy’s paper “Minimal dynamical systems with closed relations” [ 8 ] formally introduces CR-dynamical systems {\left({X,G}\right)} , where X is a compact metric space and G is a closed relation on X . Recently, this has led to the further study of CR-dynamical systems [ 1 , 6 , 12 ] , generalising transitivity and transitive points from topological dynamical systems to CR-dynamical systems. Studying the dynamics of closed relations and set-valued functions has proved useful, including in applied areas such as economics. The Christiano-Harrison model in macroeconomics [ 11 ] is one such example. In this paper, we introduce shadowing for CR-dynamical systems. The closed-relation and set-valued viewpoints are closely related. Indeed, by [ 13 , Theorem 1.2 ] , a set-valued function F\colon X\to 2^{X} is upper semi-continuous if, and only if, its graph is closed in X\times X . Consequently, when {\operatorname{dom}{\left({G}\right)}}=X , the relation G is precisely the graph of a compact-valued upper semi-continuous function, and hence gives a set-valued dynamical system. Allowing {\operatorname{dom}{\left({G}\right)}}\neq X amounts to permitting partial dynamics, in which points may have no successor at all. We use closed relations not to distinguish full-domain CR-dynamical systems from set-valued dynamical systems, but to accommodate partial dynamics, inverse relations and relation composition naturally. We introduce four {\left({i,j}\right)} -shadowing properties by independently varying the quantifiers in the definitions of pseudo-orbit and shadowing. The {\left({2,2}\right)} -shadowing property is precisely the shadowing property already studied for set-valued dynamical systems. All four notions coincide with the classical shadowing property when G is the graph of a single-valued function. It is known that the identity map on a compact metric space has the shadowing property if, and only if, the space is totally disconnected [ 20 , Theorem 3] . The same characterisation holds for periodic maps [ 20 , Theorem 5] and, more generally, for equicontinuous surjections [ 21 , Theorem 4] ; in particular, it holds for isometries. The main purpose of this paper is to understand how the classical characterisations of shadowing for the identity map, periodic maps, and isometries change when a self-map is replaced by a closed relation. The quantifier choices are useful for different reasons: the {\left({2,1}\right)} -shadowing property is rigid enough to detect branching, the {\left({1,2}\right)} -shadowing property gives natural positive generalisations, and the {\left({2,2}\right)} -shadowing property is the established notion from set-valued dynamics. Our first main theorem generalises the identity-map characterisation. Theorem A . Let {\left({X,G}\right)} be a CR-dynamical system with \Delta_{X}\subseteq G . (1) If {\left({X,G}\right)} has the {\left({2,1}\right)} -shadowing property, then G=\Delta_{X} and X is totally disconnected. (2) If X is totally disconnected, then {\left({X,G}\right)} has the {\left({1,2}\right)} -shadowing property. Both statements are sharp with respect to the positions of the quantifiers. The periodic-map characterisation suggests replacing the hypothesis \Delta_{X}\subseteq G with the existence of a positive integer n such that \Delta_{X}\subseteq G^{n} . The rigidity of the {\left({2,1}\right)} -shadowing property as in {\left({1}\right)} of Theorem A survives. For the other direction in the classical periodic-map characterisation, uniform continuity is employed in the proof. With G^{0}=\Delta_{X} , we define set-valued functions F_{k}\colon X\to 2^{X} for each k\in{\left\{{0,\ldots,n}\right\}} by F_{k}{\left({x}\right)}={\left\{{{y\in X}\,\left|\vphantom{{y\in X}{y\in G^{k}{\left({x}\right)}\text{ and }x\in G^{n-k}{\left({y}\right)}}}\right.{y\in G^{k}{\left({x}\right)}\text{ and }x\in G^{n-k}{\left({y}\right)}}}\right\}} for each x\in X . It is straightforward to check that F_{k} is upper semi-continuous for each k . We call F_{k} uniformly upper semi-continuous (see [ 2 ] ) if, for every \epsilon>0 , there exists a \delta>0 such that for all x,y\in X , d{\left({x,y}\right)}\leq\delta implies F_{k}{\left({x}\right)}\subseteq\bigcup_{z\in F_{k}{\left({y}\right)}}B{\left({z,\epsilon}\right)}. We now give our second main theorem generalising the periodic-map characterisation. Theorem B . Let {\left({X,G}\right)} be a CR-dynamical system, such that there exists positive integer n with \Delta_{X}\subseteq G^{n} , and let F_{k} be as above. (1) If {\left({X,G}\right)} has the {\left({2,1}\right)} -shadowing property, then G={\Gamma{\left({f}\right)}} for a periodic homeomorphism f\colon X\to X with f^{n}=\emph{id}_{X} , and X is totally disconnected. (2) If X is totally disconnected and F_{k} is uniformly upper semi-continuous for each 0\leq k\leq n , then {\left({X,G}\right)} has the {\left({1,2}\right)} -shadowing property. For the graph {\Gamma{\left({f}\right)}} of a periodic map f , we have F_{k}{\left({x}\right)}={\left\{{f^{k}{\left({x}\right)}}\right\}} . Thus, uniform upper semi-continuity of each F_{k} follows from uniform continuity of the iterates of f . Theorem B recovers both directions of the classical periodic-map theorem. We also give an example in which {\left({1,2}\right)} -shadowing holds although one of the set-valued functions F_{k} is not uniformly upper semi-continuous. We now give our

Read the complete text