A Terminology and Quantitative Framework for Assessing the Habitability of Solar System and Extraterrestrial Worlds
Dániel Apai, Rory Barnes, Matthew M. Murphy, Tim Lichtenberg, Noah Tuchow, Régis Ferrière, Kevin Wagner, Antonin Affholder, Renu Malhotra, Baptiste Journaux, Allona Vazan, Ramses Ramirez, Abel Méndez, Stephen R. Kane, Veronica H. Klawender, NExSS Quantitative Habitability Science Working Group · 2025
Read A Terminology and Quantitative Framework for Assessing the Habitability of Solar System and Extraterrestrial Worlds by Dániel Apai, Rory Barnes, Matthew M. Murphy, Tim Lichtenberg, Noah Tuchow, Régis Ferrière, Kevin Wagner, Antonin Affholder, Renu Malhotra, Baptiste Journaux, Allona Vazan, Ramses Ramirez, Abel Méndez, Stephen R. Kane, Veronica H. Klawender, NExSS Quantitative Habitability Science Working Group (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22808.txt.
Introduction
Daniel Apai and a large working group propose a shared language and math framework for judging whether a world could support life, in a 2025 paper. The search for life needs clear habitat assessments, but no accepted quantitative method existed. A three-year group effort reviewed past work and found a universal definition of habitability blocked by the lack of a universal definition of life.
Their framework compares two probability models: one for the conditions a place offers, one for whether a given metabolism could run under them. Open software implements the scheme. Test cases cover exoplanet ranking, oxygen detection, Mars underground habitats, and the ocean of Europa.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Dániel Apai, Rory Barnes, Matthew M. Murphy, Tim Lichtenberg, Noah Tuchow, Régis Ferrière, Kevin Wagner, Antonin Affholder, Renu Malhotra, Baptiste Journaux, Allona Vazan, Ramses Ramirez, Abel Méndez, Stephen R. Kane, Veronica H. Klawender, NExSS Quantitative Habitability Science Working Group |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 120 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22808
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A Terminology and Quantitative Framework for Assessing the Habitability of Solar System and Extraterrestrial Worlds Dániel Apai, Rory Barnes, Matthew M. Murphy, Tim Lichtenberg, Noah Tuchow, Régis Ferrière, Kevin Wagner, Antonin Affholder, Renu Malhotra, Baptiste Journaux, Allona Vazan, Ramses Ramirez, Abel Méndez, Stephen R. Kane, Veronica H. Klawender, NExSS Quantitative Habitability Science Working Group Abstract The search for extraterrestrial life in the Solar System and beyond is a key science driver in astrobiology, planetary science, and astrophysics. A critical step is the identification and characterization of potential habitats, both to guide the search and to interpret its results. However, a well-accepted, self-consistent, flexible, and quantitative terminology and method of assessment of habitability are lacking. Our paper fills this gap based on a three year-long study by the NExSS Quantitative Habitability Science Working Group. We reviewed past studies of habitability, but find that the lack of a universally valid definition of life prohibits a universally applicable definition of habitability. A more nuanced approach is needed. We introduce a quantitative habitability assessment framework (QHF) that enables self-consistent, probabilistic assessment of the compatibility of two models: First, a habitat model, which describes the probability distributions of key conditions in the habitat. Second, a viability model, which describes the probability that a metabolism is viable given a set of environmental conditions. We provide an open-source implementation of this framework and four examples as a proof of concept: (a) Comparison of two exoplanets for observational target prioritization; (b) Interpretation of atmospheric O 2 detection in two exoplanets; (c) Subsurface habitability of Mars; and (d) Ocean habitability in Europa. These examples demonstrate that our framework can self-consistently inform astrobiology research over a broad range of questions. The proposed framework is modular so that future work can expand the range and complexity of models available, both for habitats and for metabolisms. I Introduction With increasing capabilities in in-situ robotic probes and remote-sensing observatories, humanity may soon be within reach of identifying life beyond Earth. The search for life has emerged as one of the most important science drivers in astronomy (e.g., 2020 Astronomy Decadal Survey by National Academies of Sciences Engineering and Medicine 1 ), planetary sciences, and astrobiology (e.g., 2020 Planetary Science and Astrobiology Decadal Survey by National Academies of Sciences Engineering and Medicine 2 ). Integral to that search is the study and identification of potential habitats suitable for life: From the Martian sub-surface to the clouds of Venus, from the oceans of dwarf planets and icy moons to extrasolar worlds. The term “habitable” (and its derivative ”habitability”) are widely used in our disciplines and even appear in the highest levels of mission goals (e.g., NASA’s “Habitable Worlds Observatory”, ESA’s to-be-selected L5 mission), yet their exact meaning and quantitative interpretation differs widely between investigations. In fact, a review of the literature reveals significant tension in the use of these words: Compelling arguments are made for more specific vs. more universal, and simpler vs. more comprehensive definitions of habitability and related terms (see Figure 1 for a visual summary). Unsurprisingly, the popular media (and occasionally research investigations) also often confuse “habitability” with the “habitable zone”, in spite of important differences between them. We argue that – in order to increase robustness and falsifiability of future research associated with these large-scale science questions – it is very important for the fields of astrobiology, planetary sciences, and astronomy that a clear, quantitative, expandable, flexible, and widely applicable terminology is introduced, and that it is widely adopted by the community . This paper presents a framework developed to address these needs. Our study is the result of a three-year study conducted by the NExSS Quantitative Habitability Science Working Group (chairs: D. Apai and R. Barnes). The SWG held regular meetings between 2020 and 2023, solicited input from members of the NExSS network and from the broader community, held a workshop (with over 100 participants), and developed the present paper through an iterative process with the community. This paper is organized as follows: In Section II , we provide the necessary philosophical and scientific background for the definition of a new scientific terminology for habitability assessment. In Section III , we review the strategic community reports on exoplanet habitability and astrobiology with special focus on their vision and handling of habitability. In Section IV , we survey the research literature for relevant terminology and illustrative quantitative frameworks. In Section V , we introduce a new terminology and, building on that, the NExSS Quantitative Habitability Framework . In Section VI , we provide examples for viability functions, followed by four example applications in Section VII . In Section VIII , we discuss the key properties, applications, and limitations of the new terminology and framework. In Appendix A , we provide an overview of the open source python implementation of the NExSS Quantitative Habitability Framework introduced in our study, complete with four examples. Finally, in Section IX , we summarize the key findings of our study. II Considerations for Scientific Terminology II.1 The Problem at the Foundations of Habitability Arguably, it is important to identify at the onset of our study the fundamental problem that makes a perfect and ultimate definition of habitability challenging, if not impossible: Ultimately, the root of the problem that hampers the community’s efforts to converge on a definition for habitability is that habitability depends on the requirements for life, and we do not have a widely agreed-upon definition for life. Much has been written and argued about universally required and sufficient properties of life, yet a definition, even after centuries of debate, remains elusive. Some scholars argue that a search for a definition of life, at least with our present knowledge is doomed to fail but it may not even be necessary for continued progress [ 18 , e.g.,] . One particularly insightful analogy may be the centuries of failed effort to define “water” that preceded the discovery of chemical elements and the existence of molecules. In this view, we may just lack a deeper level of understanding of living organisms that would enable us to capture their true essence – how they differ from non-living objects. Others argue that the definition of life may be a fool’s errand regardless of a potential future, deeper understanding of life. For example, Machery [40] argues that life is practically undefinable: For many, life is a “folk” concept, i.e., an intuitive concept that feels well-defined but, when examined more rigorously, lacks a consistent basis. Thus, those attempting to define life often resort to coming up with criteria to support their intuition, rather then drawing from scientific observations. Machery [40] also argues that a scientific definition of life is likely impossible to reach, as life crosses multiple disciplines (e.g., evolutionary biology, astrobiology, biochemistry), and scholars of different disciplines experience (and therefore define) life differently, from fundamentally incompatible perspectives. Therefore, the author argues, life cannot be defined and attempts to do it should be abandoned. Smith & Mathis [62] , in their commentary entitled “The futility of exoplanet biosignatures”, takes this argument further: They argue that the lack of definition of life means that currently envisioned missions to search for extraterrestrial life are not testing well-defined hypotheses but rather are searches in