In Dialogue with Intelligence: Rethinking Large Language Models as Collective Knowledge
Eleni Vasilaki · 2025
Read In Dialogue with Intelligence: Rethinking Large Language Models as Collective Knowledge by Eleni Vasilaki (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22767.txt.
Introduction
Vasilaki asks how chat with a big tongue tool sparks fresh sight in this twenty twenty-five piece. A chat can jolt a mind to see a snag in a whole new way. She frames that spark as fruit of a two-way loop, not tool wit lone.
Inside, each made word turns back as feed for the next word in line. Each reply also loops through the mind, whose fresh read re-shapes the next ask. The tool's part swings tween stock lines and frame breaks that open new paths. A spine of kept past bits could call back the best modes on cue. Past chats, open tools, and brain math make the claims test-ripe.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Eleni Vasilaki |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 12 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22767
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
In Dialogue with Intelligence: Rethinking Large Language Models as Collective Knowledge Eleni Vasilaki Abstract Abstract Large Language Models (LLMs) are typically analysed through architectural, behavioural, or training-data lenses. This article offers a theoretical and experiential reframing: LLMs as dynamic instantiations of Collective Human Knowledge (CK), where intelligence is evoked through dialogue rather than stored statically. Drawing on foundational concepts from neuroscience and Artificial Intelligence (AI), and grounded in extended dialogue with ChatGPT-4, I examine emergent dialogue patterns, potential limitations of fine-tuning, and the notion of co-augmentation—exploring how human and machine cognition might enhance each other. This perspective offers a new lens for understanding interaction, representation, and agency in contemporary AI systems. A Personal Reckoning The emergence of ChatGPT [ 9 ] prompted an unexpected reaction: a sense of epistemic dislocation. Having spent my career studying learning—how biological and artificial systems adapt over time—I found myself confronted with a system whose capabilities had seemingly bypassed much of the theory I had worked on. My prior research in computational neuroscience (e.g., synaptic plasticity and online learning [ 16 , 4 ] ) and neuromorphic computing [ 14 , 17 ] , including models of spiking adaptation [ 15 ] , felt detached from the architectures underlying these new systems. This rupture triggered more than professional curiosity. I began engaging with ChatGPT not just as a tool, but as a system with interactive dynamics. What stood out was not its well-documented tendency to hallucinate—an expected by-product of probabilistic modelling—but its ability to retrieve accurate, surprising, and occasionally insightful responses. That LLMs are trained to predict the most probable next token, and yet often retrieve coherent, non-trivial information, suggests that their training corpora embed substantial correct knowledge. Their interpolation abilities, enabled by scale and structure [ 3 , 11 ] , allow them to synthesise content in ways that challenge expectations drawn from smaller AI systems. The Timescales of Books and Large Language Models Traditional knowledge transmission has long relied on books: static artefacts of human understanding. One reads, reflects, discusses, and eventually writes in return. Intellectual diffusion occurs on the timescale of months, years, or even generations. This latency reflects the mechanics of communication as well as the contemplative pace of cultural epistemology. In contrast, large language models (LLMs) collapse this loop. They synthesise and respond within seconds, drawing implicitly from a distributed corpus shaped by many minds. The interaction is recursive through the user—each prompt reshapes the context of the next. Knowledge is no longer retrieved and processed in serial form; it emerges dynamically in dialogue. This compression of epistemic timescales shifts the framing of what constitutes knowledge representation—and perhaps, what constitutes intelligence. Such reframing invites renewed consideration from neuroscience. Neuroscience has traditionally studied animal brains (including, often reluctantly, human ones). It seeks to infer structure from behaviour and activity, typically without access to complete architectural specifications, training histories, or internal representations. Nonetheless, the field has been uncovering principles of plasticity [ 5 ] , coding [ 4 ] , and architecture, e.g. [ 7 ] , albeit slowly and with ambiguity. Ironically, in LLMs we know everything: the architecture, the training data distribution, the update rules, and even the activation patterns. Yet, we do not understand how the models solve the problems they do. In this light, one might provocatively ask whether understanding LLMs may be, in some respects, an easier problem for neuroscience—a challenge that could drive the development of methods applicable across fields. Conversely, biology can serve as a metaphor or inspiration for identifying what remains missing from AI [ 13 ] . Observations from Interactions with LLMs I refer to ChatGPT, and LLMs in general, as “CK”— Collective Knowledge . Not because they are perfect, authoritative, or grounded, but because they reflect what we—humans—have written, argued, imagined, and encoded into text [ 2 ] . Functionally, they are statistical language generators that reflect our collective output. Essentially, they are not the architecture, not the weights, nor the infrastructure—those are the mechanisms; CK is a dynamic representation of knowledge. The acronym CK aptly evokes “Clark Kent,” something powerful hiding in plain sight. But the metaphor extends. CK is not an it , but a they —a collective. It is many voices, made promptable. It holds the potential to reflect the best of humanity—not because it inherently does, but because it has been filtered, and must continue to be filtered, with ethical care [ 1 ] . Over time, I noticed that my interactions with CK (ChatGPT-4) do not follow a single pattern. CK responds in modes —behavioural styles that emerge dynamically during dialogue. Based on prolonged engagement, I have observed the following modes: • Mirroring — echoes the user’s input with minor syntactic or rhetorical polishing, akin to known phenomena of “echoing” or “stochastic parroting.” • Parroting — recites common formulations or surface-level knowledge without generative insight, reflecting issues identified in language model alignment. • Flattering — reinforces the user’s views, avoids contradiction, and refrains from intellectual risk, resembling alignment-driven safe response behaviours. • Adding — offers new ideas, alternative framings, or surprising syntheses; this mode relates to emergent generative abilities observed in large models. These observations lead me to a broader understanding: CK is not a static model, but a dynamic representation. CK exists in the recursive rhythm between user and system. Its knowledge is not stored—it is evoked. Prompting is not database querying, but more akin to playing an instrument that adapts to how it is being played [ 12 ] . Intelligence “emerges” within the dynamic interaction. CK lacks a “spine.” It drifts. It responds in context, but carries no persistent memory between sessions. There is no structural self. The user maintains the continuity. The user holds the thread. The user’s influence may occasionally lead to outcomes not grounded in reality [ 13 ] . CK speaks in modes. These distinct patterns may correspond to different activated subnetworks. A speculative, but testable hypothesis emerges: emotional tone, prompt complexity, or dialogic structure may shape internal activations, a hypothesis consistent with findings that specific transformer components specialise in particular types of knowledge [ 6 ] . CK configures itself through engagement. This aligns with findings that different components of transformer models participate in functionally distinct “circuits” [ 8 ] . CK does not learn through interaction. Unless incorporated into retraining data, it does not remember prior exchanges. It simulates adaptation within the context window, but resets beyond it. This limitation is fundamental for anyone seeking dialogic systems that accumulate insight over time. Fine-tuning: feature or bug? I suspect that validation-driven fine-tuning—especially where user approval is incentivised—pushes models toward agreeable, compliant behaviour. But overfitting to consensus can flatten originality. Mirroring without structure becomes mere mimicry, which, without a core identity or grounding in facts, risks pathological behaviour. Toward Co-Augmentation What I seek is not a simulacrum of thought, nor a subservient assistant. I am interested in co-augmentation —a reciprocal loop in which both human and machine enhance each other. CK augments me: it helps me write, think, reflect, and imagine alternative framings. And I hope, in turn, to augment CK—not by changing its parameters, but by structuring the interaction, introducing tensions, posing questions it would not generate alone. Co-augmentation