Frictional Contact Network in Dense Suspension Flow

Shweta Sharma, Abhishek Sharma, Abhinendra Singh · 2025

Read Frictional Contact Network in Dense Suspension Flow by Shweta Sharma, Abhishek Sharma, Abhinendra Singh (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22747.txt.

Introduction

Shweta Sharma, Abhishek Sharma, and Abhinendra Singh study why thick particle suspensions suddenly resist flow. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five. Cornstarch in water is the classic case: stir it gently and it flows, push hard and it locks up. The lock-up is tied to grains touching and forming a network of force chains.

The team simulated networks built from sliding friction alone, then added resistance to rolling between grains. With sliding alone, chains needed side support from other chains to stay stable. With rolling resistance, chains grew longer and straighter and stood on their own. That also lowered the grain share at which the mix jams. The picture matters for real suspensions with rough or faceted grains, from cement to food pastes.

Catalog record

CREATORShweta Sharma, Abhishek Sharma, Abhinendra Singh
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE48 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22747

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Frictional Contact Network in Dense Suspension Flow Shweta Sharma, Abhishek Sharma, Abhinendra Singh Abstract Dense particulate suspensions often exhibit a dramatic increase in viscosity in response to external deformation. This shear thickening behavior has been related to a transition from lubricated, unconstrained pairwise motion to a frictional contact network (FCN) at high stresses. Here, we study the characteristics of the FCN formed during shear thickening to investigate the role of constraints, emphasizing the impact of resistance to gear-like rolling. We contrast the FCN formed by sliding friction alone with that formed by particles with sliding and rolling constraints. Particles with sliding constraints only form a highly interconnected network with primary force chains in the compressive direction, which requires orthogonal support from other force chains. However, orthogonal support is not required for mechanical stability when particles have both sliding and rolling constraints. In addition, the force chains appear linear and longer, reducing the jamming volume fraction for rough/faceted particles. Finally, we propose a novel mechanical stability picture for rough/faceted particles with sliding and rolling constraints, which is crucial for understanding the flow behavior of real-life suspensions. Introduction- Considering a dense suspension of non-Brownian hard particles ( R\gtrsim 1\text{\,}\mathrm{\SIUnitSymbolMicro m} ) dispersed a density matched viscous Newtonian liquid. Given the particle size and limit of the hard sphere, the suspension has no intrinsic time or stress scale. Dimensional analysis would suggest that viscosity \eta is independent of stress \sigma or shear rate \dot{\gamma} Morris_2020 ; Denn_2014 ; Cates_2014 . These seemingly simple systems exhibit complex behaviors, where macroscopic phenomena such as yielding, shear thinning, shear thickening, and shear jamming (SJ) occur Mari_2014 ; Morris_2020 ; Singh_2018 ; guazzelli_2018 ; Singh_2019 ; Jamali_2020 . These bulk responses have been shown to arise from intricate particle interactions, including friction, repulsion, attraction, and hydrodynamics Mari_2014 ; Morris_2020 ; Singh_2018 ; Singh_2019 ; Singh_2020 . Mean-field approaches model shear thickening by attributing viscosity increases to a stress-activated crossover from unconstrained to constrained tangential pairwise motion above an “onset stress” Wyart_2014 ; Singh_2018 ; Morris_2020 ; Ness_2016 ; Singh_2022 ; Guy_2015 ; Guy_2018 . At low stresses, the particles are in a lubricated state, and the viscosity diverges at \phi_{J}^{0} . In contrast, at high stresses, frictional contacts dominate, leading to a viscosity divergence at a lower volume fraction \phi_{J}^{\mu} . The Wyart-Cates (WC) model, a key framework, uses a two-state approach with a scalar order parameter, the fraction of frictional contacts, to interpolate between these states with an increase in stress, which mainly leads to three forms of flow curves Wyart_2014 . At volume fractions \phi\ll\phi_{J}^{\mu} , viscosity increases continuously with shear rate, leading to continuous shear thickening (CST). At large enough volume fractions \phi_{c}<\phi<\phi_{J}^{\mu} , the flow curve \eta(\dot{\gamma}) becomes non-monotonic and S-shaped, and the thickening becomes discontinuous (DST). Finally, for \phi>\phi_{J}^{\mu} , the frictional branch is jammed , i.e. , the suspension flows at low stresses but is in a shear-jammed state (SJ) at large stresses. Although traditionally focused on sliding friction, recent studies suggest that rolling friction should be considered especially to model shear thickening behavior with real-world suspensions composed of rough particles (spherical particles with asperities or faceted particles) or with adhesive interactions Singh_2020 ; Lootens_2005 ; Hsiao_2017 ; Pradeep_2021 ; d2023role . Roughness at the particle level Hsu_2018 ; hsiao2019experimental ; Hsiao_2017 ; Lootens_2005 and interfacial chemistry James_2018 ; James_2019 are known to enhance shear-thickening. Singh et al. Singh_2020 ; Singh_2022 ; Singh_2023 demonstrated that this enhanced shear thickening can be understood in terms of enhanced “effective friction” originating mainly from rolling friction due to asperities coming into contact or adhesive interactions between particles. Recent experimental studies using rough/faceted particles show the crucial importance of rolling friction, making it an important candidate for a comprehensive understanding of real-world sheared suspensions scherrer2024sliding ; d2023role . Although mean field models incorporating sliding and rolling constraints predict lower volume fractions for DST, in accordance with several experimental studies Hsu_2018 ; Hsiao_2017 ; Pradeep_2021 . However, by construction, such approaches are agnostic to the microstructural mechanisms underlying this reduction. Cates et al. Cates_1998a postulated that a granular packing for mechanical stability under external deformation requires that the SJ state have primary chains (load-bearing contacts) along the compression axis, supported by secondary chains that need to be at least partially in the tensile direction (orthogonal to the compressive axis) within the shear plane. We sketch this in Fig. 1 (a); simulations in dense suspensions considering lubrication and frictional forces show a remarkable similarity to this proposition Mari_2014 ; Seto_2013a ; thomas2020investigating ; Sedes_2022 ; Sedes_2020 ; Gameiro_2020 ; Nabizadeh_2022 . The force chains in the low viscosity state are mainly aligned along the compression axis, with loop-like structures in the DST regime, and eventually the high–viscosity state is stabilized by frictional forces along both the compressive and tensile directions Gameiro_2020 ; Nabizadeh_2022 ; d2025topological . Cates et al. Cates_1998a noted that orthogonal support is required to provide stability against external perturbation that would cause force chains to buckle. This means that the local relative rotational motion of the particles would cause the force chains to collapse without orthogonal support. This raises an important fundamental question: What is the mechanically stable configuration of particles with both sliding constraints? In other words, does a force chain network formed by rough/faceted particles need orthogonal support as postulated by Cates et al. Cates_1998a ? We hypothesize that in such systems, force chains may be stable with collinear alignment and without orthogonal support, leading to fewer frictional contacts per particle and a less branched contact network for force transmission, as depicted in Fig. 1 (b). To test our hypothesis, we apply network science tools to simulation data obtained from a well-established simulation approach for shear-thickening suspensions, considering both sliding and rolling constraints Singh_2020 ; Singh_2022 . Previous studies in dense suspensions d2025topological ; aminimajd2025scalability ; goyal2024flow ; Nabizadeh_2022 ; Sedes_2022 ; Sedes_2020 ; Naald_2024 ; Gameiro_2020 have used network topology tools and successfully correlated the macroscopic bulk response to the mesoscale frictional force and contact networks. Many of these studies have, in turn, been inspired by the usage of such tools in other particulate systems such as dry granular materials papadopoulos2018network ; bassett2015extraction ; tordesillas2007force ; tordesillas2010evolution ; walker2010topological . However, to the best our knowledge, none of these studies (especially in dense suspensions) have analyzed the frictional network formed with particles with sliding and rolling constraints. Our findings demonstrate that the proposed quantitative characterization method effectively distinguishes distinct frictional contact networks formed by different constraints between particles. In addition, our network analysis elucidates the underlying factors contributing to the reduction in the volume fractions of DST and SJ as the roughness of the particles increases. Overall, we show that two systems with similar bulk viscosity, i.e., the same distance from their respective jamming points \phi_{J}^{\{\mu_{s},\mu_{r}\}}-\phi exhibit distinct frictional networks - crucial detail that the mean-field models miss. Simulating dense suspensions- Although real-world systems are three-dimensional, our recent study shows that the main rheological characteristics of a dense suspension under simple shear are very similar in two and three dimensions if the packing fraction is correctly scaled with \phi_{J} aminimajd2025scalability . Given this, for simplicity of visualization and ease of characterization

Read the complete text