Nonlinear Diffusion and Decay of an Expanding Turbulent Blob

Takumi Matsuzawa, Minhui Zhu, Nigel Goldenfeld, William T.M. Irvine · 2025

Read Nonlinear Diffusion and Decay of an Expanding Turbulent Blob by Takumi Matsuzawa, Minhui Zhu, Nigel Goldenfeld, William T.M. Irvine (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22737.txt.

Introduction

Takumi Matsuzawa and co-authors watch a blob of turbulent water spread and decay in a tank, in a 2025 paper. Unforced turbulence dies away while invading calm fluid around it. The process is common but hard to capture in a simple frame, since test chambers add wall and flow effects.

They make a local blob with eight vortex makers aimed at the tank center. Imaging tracks its spread over decades of time. The blob first expands and decays, then, after reaching the walls, shifts to a more uniform decay. A nonlinear diffusion model explains the pattern. The setup isolates the basic physics of relaxation to calm.

Catalog record

CREATORTakumi Matsuzawa, Minhui Zhu, Nigel Goldenfeld, William T.M. Irvine
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE44 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22737

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Nonlinear Diffusion and Decay of an Expanding Turbulent Blob Takumi Matsuzawa, Minhui Zhu, Nigel Goldenfeld, William T.M. Irvine Abstract Turbulence, left unforced, decays and invades the surrounding quiescent fluid. Though ubiquitous, this simple phenomenon has proven hard to capture within a simple and general framework. Experiments in conventional turbulent flow chambers are inevitably complicated by proximity to boundaries and mean flow, obscuring the fundamental aspects of the relaxation to the quiescent fluid state. Here, we circumvent these issues by creating a spatially-localized blob of turbulent fluid using eight converging vortex generators focused towards the center of a tank of water, and observe its decay and spread over decades in time, using particle image velocimetry with a logarithmic sampling rate. The blob initially expands and decays until it reaches the walls of the tank and eventually transitions to a second regime of approximately spatially uniform decay. We interpret these dynamics within the framework of a nonlinear diffusion equation, which predicts that the ideal quiescent-turbulent fluid boundary is sharp and propagates non-diffusively, driven by turbulent eddies while decaying with characteristic scaling laws. We find direct evidence for this model within the expansion phase of our turbulent blob and use it to account for the detailed behavior we observe, in contrast to earlier studies. Our work provides a detailed spatially-resolved narrative for the behavior of turbulence once the forcing is removed, and demonstrates unexpectedly that the turbulent cascade leaves an indelible footprint far into the decay process. The energy cascade is arguably the most distinctive feature of three dimensional (3D) steady state turbulence, setting it apart from other forms of random dynamics such as chaos. In the turbulent cascade, energy is transferred from the largest scale \ell at which the flow is forced, via a Hamiltonian process to viscous scales, where it is ultimately dissipated. Typically the turbulent cascade is generated from an imposed mean flow, as in a pipe or wind-tunnel, but many other flow geometries have been explored, with the consensus that regardless of the large scale generation, the small-scale behavior is universal, even at intermediate levels of turbulence Schumacher et al. 2014 ; Cerbus et al. 2020 , and characterized by a suite of scaling laws for the distribution of energy across scales that have been the focus of theoretical efforts to understand the statistical properties of turbulence Kolmogorov 1941a ; Kolmogorov 1941b ; Kolmogorov 1962 ; Pope 2000 ; Sreenivasan and Schumacher 2025 . Turbulence has also been extensively explored in quantum systems (for an introductory review, see Tsubota et al. 2013 ; Barenghi et al. 2014 ; Barenghi et al. 2023 ), including experimentally in the regime where normal and superfluid components are coupled Zhang et al. 2023 , thus emulating classical turbulence in both decay Smith et al. 1993 ; Skrbek et al. 2000 and spectral properties Zhao et al. 2025 . If the forcing stops, this cascade is starved, and turbulence decays, ultimately entering the laminar regime. Although there is still not a consensus on a satisfactory theoretical framework for the decay, a variety of experimental set-ups have been applied to study the decay process, often in the context of a superimposed mean flow where the decay in time is transformed to a distance-dependent scaling. Examples include passive grids Hurst and Vassilicos 2007 ; Kistler and Vrebalovich 1966 ; Comte-Bellot and Corrsin 1971 ; Bodenschatz et al. 2014 , active grids Hideharu 1991 ; Mydlarski and Warhaft 1996 , pipes Reynolds 1883 ; Mullin 2011 ; Eckhardt et al. 2007 ; Hof et al. 2003 , and spinning disks de la Torre and Burguete 2007 ; Volk et al. 2011 ; Labbé et al. 1996 , with reported putative power laws for energy decay spread over a large range De Silva and Fernando 1994 ; George 1992 ; Sinhuber et al. 2015 ; Panickacheril John et al. 2022 ; Gorce and Falcon 2024 , often deviating from the necessarily ad hoc theoretical predictions de Karman and Howarth 1938 ; Batchelor and Townsend 1948a ; Batchelor and Townsend 1948b ; Batchelor 1953 ; Saffman 1967 . Even under idealized conditions of spatial homogeneity, theoretical and experimental results for decay rates span a broad spectrum Smith et al. 1993 ; Smith 1994 ; Skrbek and Stalp 2000 ; Sinhuber et al. 2015 ; Panickacheril John et al. 2022 ; Küchler et al. 2023 ; George 1992 ; Davidson 2015 ; Gorce and Falcon 2024 . Explorations of the decay of turbulence are confounded by difficulties such as finite Reynolds number, finite system size, presence of mean flows, and interactions with boundaries. Furthermore, in natural settings, turbulence is rarely homogeneous. Instead, it often exhibits fronts, with turbulent regions interfacing quiescent zones across distinct boundaries characterized by abrupt changes in vorticity and Reynolds stresses da Silva et al. 2011 . In such settings, the free evolution of turbulence inherently involves both decay and propagation into surrounding quiescent regions. No unified body of experiment or theory currently integrates these intertwined processes of turbulent transport and decay in a regime where the laminar-turbulent front dynamics can be systematically probed. Here, we introduce a new experimental platform for probing the decay and propagation of turbulence unconstrained by boundaries or mean flows. We report compelling evidence for the nonlinear diffusion of the laminar-turbulent fronts as a blob of turbulence expands into a laminar region of fluid, and then subsequently transitions into a homogeneous decay regime at long times, all of which are consistent with predictions based upon a phenomenological model for inhomogeneous turbulence Kolmogorov 1942 ; Barenblatt 1983 ; Barenblatt et al. 1987 ; Chen and Goldenfeld 1992 . Our experimental platform for investigating the free evolution of turbulence uses vortex rings to produce an isolated region of turbulence in the middle of a tank Matsuzawa et al. 2023 . By localizing turbulence at the center of the chamber and minimizing mean flow and boundary effects, our setup enables direct observation of the intrinsic behaviors of turbulence as it propagates, mixes with the surrounding fluid, and decays toward thermal equilibrium. Figure 1 a shows our experimental chamber. Pulling the piston upward produces sets of eight vortex rings that travel toward the center of the tank and collide, feeding energy and enstrophy into the turbulent blob at the center. Inside the blob, the flow is dominated by turbulent fluctuations, with fluctuating energy exceeding the energy of the time-averaged mean flow by up to a factor of 1000 Matsuzawa et al. 2023 . Crucially, the tunable properties of injected vortex rings directly determine the intensity and length scales of the resulting isolated blob of turbulence, as well as other inviscid invariants of the turbulent state such as angular impulse and helicity. When the turbulent blob is suddenly starved of incoming vortex rings, it begins to expand and decay. In a typical experiment, the characteristic velocities drop from approximately 150 mm/s just before the forcing stops to 0.4 mm/s at the end of the decay. This significant dynamic range and long decay duration pose a challenge for recording Particle Image Velocimetry (PIV) data, which requires tracer particles to move at least about one diameter between frames for accurate measurements of velocity vectors Raffel et al. 2018 .

Read the complete text