The Co-Evolution of Stellar Wind-blown Bubbles and Photoionized Gas II: 3D RMHD Simulations and Tests of Semi-Analytic Models

Lachlan Lancaster, Chang-Goo Kim, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Eve C. Ostriker, Greg L. Bryan · 2025

Read The Co-Evolution of Stellar Wind-blown Bubbles and Photoionized Gas II: 3D RMHD Simulations and Tests of Semi-Analytic Models by Lachlan Lancaster, Chang-Goo Kim, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Eve C. Ostriker, Greg L. Bryan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22733.txt.

Introduction

Lachlan Lancaster and four co-authors simulate bubbles blown by massive stars, in a 2025 paper. Winds and harsh light from such stars carve growing bubbles in star-forming clouds. A companion paper set out a joint model for how the two effects evolve together. This paper tests that model with full three-dimensional simulations.

The runs used values typical of Milky Way star-forming clouds, where both effects matter. The joint model matched the runs within about a quarter on key measures. It beat older, simpler models by a modest margin. Gaps traced to two missing pieces: lumpy gas from turbulence, and swings in wind push over time. Light-heated gas also shrank the bubble surface, cutting cooling there. That raised the bubble's overall push on its surroundings.

Catalog record

CREATORLachlan Lancaster, Chang-Goo Kim, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Eve C. Ostriker, Greg L. Bryan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE125 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22733

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

The Co-Evolution of Stellar Wind-blown Bubbles and Photoionized Gas II: 3D RMHD Simulations and Tests of Semi-Analytic Models Lachlan Lancaster, Chang-Goo Kim, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Eve C. Ostriker, Greg L. Bryan Abstract In a companion paper (Paper I) we presented a Co-Evolution Model (CEM) in which to consider the evolution of feedback bubbles driven by massive stars through both stellar winds and ionizing radiation, outlining when either of these effects is dominant and providing a model for how they evolve together. Here we present results from three-dimensional radiation magneto-hydrodynamical (RMHD) simulations of this scenario for parameters typical of massive star-forming clouds in the Milky Way: precisely the regime where we expect both feedback mechanisms to matter. While we find that the CEM agrees with the simulations to within 25% for key parameters and modestly outperforms previous idealized models, disagreements remain. We show that these deviations originate mainly from the CEM’s lack of (i) background inhomogeneity caused by turbulence and (ii) time-variable momentum enhancements in the wind-blown bubble (WBB). Additionally, we find that photoionized gas acts similarly to magnetic fields [ 79 , as in] by decreasing the WBB’s surface area. This causes a decrease in the amount of cooling at the WBB’s interface, resulting in an enhanced WBB dynamical impact. Journal: ApJ scipy [ 140 ] , numpy [ 54 ] , matplotlib [ 58 ] , adstex ( https://github.com/yymao/adstex ) I Introduction Giant molecular clouds (GMCs) are considered to be the fundamental unit of star formation in the universe, in that nearly all observed star formation occurs in these systems [ 93 , 74 ] . While the formation of stars in a given galaxy is governed by processes at many different scales [ 127 , 98 ] including the processes leading to the formation of such GMCs [ 122 , 60 ] , the efficiency at which the gas in these clouds is turned into stars is thought to be governed primarily by the stellar feedback from massive stars [ 91 , 76 , 14 ] . These massive stars affect their natal clouds through many different channels, including stellar wind-blown bubbles [ 13 , 142 , 53 , 118 , 80 ] , pressure from gas heated through photoionization [ 128 , 145 , 57 , 46 , 44 , 68 ] , direct radiation pressure from UV light [ 22 , 113 , 114 , 67 , 68 ] , and indirect or reprocessed radiation pressure [ 75 , 30 , 123 , 95 , 100 ] . The question of how these processes affect their natal clouds is often asked in the literature through the lens of which is dominant in any given environment [ 75 , 30 ] , with this dominant feedback mechanism being usually considered as the sole regulator in theoretical models. In reality, all of these mechanisms are always present and often affect one another in non-linear ways [ 107 , 22 ] . Even if their dynamical importance varies strongly with environment, they each will have an impact on the structure of the gas in star forming clouds and thus on the observable properties of those clouds [ 105 , 106 ] . Given the abundance of recent and upcoming observations of these regions [ 121 , 24 , 72 , 120 ] , which require interpretation, there is a pressing need to improve the theoretical modeling of interacting feedback processes and their observable consequences. To that end, in Paper I we presented a model for the interaction of feedback from both stellar wind-blown bubbles (WBBs) and photoionized regions (PIRs) created by Lyman Continuum (LyC) radiation. In particular, we specified the regimes of parameter space in which winds or LyC radiation should be more dynamically important and developed a semi-analytic model for how the feedback bubble (FB) resulting from both of these mechanisms evolves. Here we present three-dimensional (3D), radiation magneto-hydrodynamical (RMHD) simulations of the joint feedback of both of these mechanisms in the regime where we expect both to be important. We use these simulations for the dual purposes of (i) testing the accuracy and pitfalls of the model developed in Paper I and (ii) understanding the effects of the presence of LyC radiation on cooling at the WBB’s interface, which we have shown in previous work determines the dynamical impact of the WBB [ 80 , 81 , 79 ] . As we will show below, the presence of each of these feedback mechanisms impacts the other in complicated ways. In Section II we review the results of the combined evolution models of Paper I and the classical solutions for the evolution of WBBs and photoionized gas. We provide details on the simulation suite we have run in Section III before analyzing them, through both comparisons to models of Paper I and Lancaster et al. [79] , in Section IV . In Section V we place this work in the context of past numerical works that have investigated the feedback from both WBBs and LyC radiation. In particular, using the model of Paper I we explain why past works, which for the most part have focused on individual stars or low density environments, had concluded that winds are generally subdominant to LyC radiation feedback. Finally, we summarize our conclusions in Section VI . II Review of Theory This section presents a summary of the key ideas relevant to the joint feedback evolution from WBBs and the PIR. This discussion is given in much greater detail in Paper I. II.1 Classical Theories We begin by briefly reviewing the theoretical background of feedback from LyC radiation and stellar winds. This is meant to provide a clear comparison between the semi-analytic models developed in Paper I and the numerical simulations given here. We characterize the former by the rate at which LyC photons are emitted, Q_{0} , and their average energy, h\nu_{i} . We characterize winds by the mass loss rate, \dot{M}_{w} , and wind velocity, {\cal{V}}_{w} , which can be translated into the wind’s mechanical luminosity, \mathcal{L}_{w}=\dot{M}_{w}{\cal{V}}_{w}^{2}/2 , and momentum input rate, \dot{p}_{w}=\dot{M}_{w}{\cal{V}}_{w} . We consider the impacts of the injection of energy in these forms into a uniform background medium with density \bar{\rho} and therefore number density of hydrogen atoms, \overline{n}_{\rm H}=\bar{\rho}/\mu_{\rm H}m_{\rm H} , where m_{\rm H} is the mass of a Hydrogen nucleus and \mu_{\rm H} is the mean molecular weight per H atom (in units of m_{\rm H} ). Stellar winds shock as they expand into the surrounding cloud, heating the wind to 10^{7}-10^{8}\,\mathrm{K} and making it vastly over-pressurized with respect to its surroundings [ 142 , 23 ] . The resulting WBB does mechanical work on its surroundings as it expands and sweeps up the surrounding gas. The effectiveness of this work largely hinges upon the bubble’s ability to retain thermal energy in its interior [ 142 , 90 , 53 , 119 , 80 ] . In the ‘best case scenario’ for wind effectiveness, all energy is retained and the classical “energy-driven” solution of Weaver et al. [142] applies. If we modify this solution to allow for a constant fraction, \theta , of the wind luminosity to be lost to cooling [ 29 ] ,

Read the complete text