The Co-Evolution of Stellar Wind-blown Bubbles and Photoionized Gas I: Physical Principles and a Semi-Analytic Model
Lachlan Lancaster, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Greg L. Bryan, Shyam H. Menon, Eve C. Ostriker, Chang-Goo Kim · 2025
Read The Co-Evolution of Stellar Wind-blown Bubbles and Photoionized Gas I: Physical Principles and a Semi-Analytic Model by Lachlan Lancaster, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Greg L. Bryan, Shyam H. Menon, Eve C. Ostriker, Chang-Goo Kim (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22730.txt.
Introduction
Lachlan Lancaster and five co-authors build a model of feedback from massive stars in a 2025 paper. A young star blows a bubble with its wind while its light also charges gas around it. Both forces push on the gas, and past models often treated them in a crude joint way.
The authors track where each force acts and how each part reacts to the other. They define a ratio that shows which force rules in a given cloud. For many real clouds both forces matter, and their joint model shifts the total push by a clear margin. A companion paper will test the model against full simulations.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Lachlan Lancaster, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Greg L. Bryan, Shyam H. Menon, Eve C. Ostriker, Chang-Goo Kim |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 134 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22730
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The Co-Evolution of Stellar Wind-blown Bubbles and Photoionized Gas I: Physical Principles and a Semi-Analytic Model Lachlan Lancaster, Jeong-Gyu Kim, Greg L. Bryan, Shyam H. Menon, Eve C. Ostriker, Chang-Goo Kim Abstract We propose a new framework for the simultaneous feedback of stellar winds and photo-ionizing radiation from massive stars, distinguishing the locations where forces are applied, and consequences for internal spatio-temporal evolution of the whole feedback bubble (FB). We quantify the relative dynamical importance of wind-blown bubbles (WBB) versus the photoionized region (PIR) by the ratio of the radius at which the WBB is in pressure equilibrium with the PIR, R eq R_{\rm eq} , to the Strömgren radius, R St R_{\rm St} . ζ ≡ R eq / R St \zeta\equiv R_{\rm eq}/R_{\rm St} quantifies the dynamical dominance of WBBs ( ζ > 1 \zeta>1 ) or the PIR ( ζ < 1 \zeta<1 ). We calculate ζ \zeta and find that, for momentum-driven winds, 0.1 ≲ ζ ≲ 1 0.1\lesssim\zeta\lesssim 1 for the star-forming regions in (i) typical Milky Way-like giant molecular clouds (GMCs), (ii) the most massive of individual OB stars, and (iii) dense, low-metallicity environments, relevant in the early universe. In this regime, both WBBs and the PIR are dynamically important to the expansion of the FB. We develop a semi-analytic Co-Evolution Model (CEM) that takes into account the spatial distribution of forces and the back reactions of both the WBB and PIR. In the ζ < 1 \zeta<1 regime where the CEM is most relevant, the model differs in the total FB momentum by up to 25% compared to naive predictions. In the weak-wind limit of ζ ≪ 1 \zeta\ll 1 , applicable to individual OB stars or low-mass clusters, the CEM has factors ≳ 2 \gtrsim 2 differences in WBB properties. In a companion paper we compare these models to three-dimensional, turbulent hydro-dynamical simulations. Journal: ApJ scipy [ 102 ] , numpy [ 34 ] , matplotlib [ 36 ] , adstex ( https://github.com/yymao/adstex ) I Introduction As stars are fundamental building blocks of galaxies, and critical to how we observe (and therefore make physical inferences about) the Universe, it is crucial to have a detailed model of their formation. Unfortunately, there is much we still do not understand about the processes controlling star formation. We do know that these processes take place across many scales: involving the collapse of halo gas into galaxies [ 13 , 77 , 78 , 107 , 106 ] , the regulation of gas being maintained within that galaxy [ 20 , 38 , 75 , 76 , 74 , 19 , 46 ] , and the formation and dispersal of dense molecular clouds in which stars are born [ 49 , 48 , 45 , 9 , 40 , 41 , 52 , 30 , 67 , 92 ] . At each scale, injection of energy and momentum back into the interstellar (ISM) and circum- and inter-galactic media from stars plays a critical role in regulating the collapse of gas to the densities needed to form a star. It is these ‘feedback’ processes, in their various forms, that are perhaps the largest open uncertainty in our understanding of star formation physics [ 93 ] . On the scales of giant molecular clouds (GMCs) where stars form, feedback is dominated by young massive stars [ 70 , 50 ] and energy that originates from the strong, high energy radiation emitted from the atmospheres of these stars can affect the surrounding GMC in multiple ways [ 11 , 48 ] . Past theoretical studies of feedback effects focus on a single mechanism [ 94 , 108 ] or combine many feedback channels artificially into a single thin-shell evolution equation [ 47 , 70 , 28 , 86 , 87 ] . This approximation is made in order to simplify calculations but does not have rigorous theoretical foundations. In reality, however, these mechanisms always act in unison in a way that depends the complex way in which they interact with one another. A complete model of feedback should account for these interactions. Two mechanisms that are generally understood as potentially dominant [ 48 , 8 ] in the early feedback evolution of ‘normal’ GMCs as we might observe in our own Milky Way are (i) the photo-ionizing or Lyman Continuum (LyC) radiation from these stars which acts to heat the surrounding cloud [ 94 , 35 , 39 ] and (ii) stellar winds that flow from their atmospheres at thousands of kilometers per second [ 7 , 100 , 101 ] , shock heating and becoming vastly over-pressurized with respect to the surrounding cloud. These mechanisms interact in complex ways, with the photoionized region (PIR) created by the LyC radiation changing the nature of cooling at the interface of the stellar wind-blown bubble (WBB) and compression due to the WBB increasing the recombination rate of the PIR, causing it to contract. In this work we present a framework for considering the co-evolution of feedback from these two mechanisms that provides (i) a simple heuristic for when one will be dominant over another and (ii) a semi-analytic model for evolution under the combined effects of these mechanisms. As the degree to which WBBs retain or lose the mechanical energy they inject (and hence impart momentum to their surroundings), is somewhat uncertain [ 51 ] , we present models for different limiting cases. In Section II we review the classical dynamical theories for the evolution of WBBs and the PIR in star-forming clouds before presenting our model for their co-evolution in Section III . Key details are illustrated in Figure 1 and discussed in Section III.2 - Section III.6 . In Section IV we present a series of sample model calculations and discuss their features, while in Section V we provide an in-depth review of past work on this topic, contrasting with the current work, and outline pathways for future model development. We give a brief summary of our main conclusions in Section VI . Discussion throughout the work is supplemented by appendices, which contain further details. Table 1: Explanation of Model Parameters. Parameters Meaning Definitions and References \bar{\rho} mean mass density in the GMC n number density of all particles n_{\rm H} number density of hydrogen nuclei n_{{\rm H},i} number density of hydrogen nuclei in photo-ionized gas \overline{n}_{\rm H} mean number density of hydrogen nuclei in GMC \mu mean molecular weight \mu\equiv\bar{\rho}/(\overline{n}m_{\rm H}) \mu_{\rm H} mean particle weight per hydrogen nucleus \mu_{\rm H}\equiv\bar{\rho}/(\overline{n}_{\rm H}m_{\rm H}) {\cal{V}}_{w} wind velocity \dot{M}_{w} wind mass loss rate \mathcal{L}_{w} wind mechanical luminosity \mathcal{L}_{w}\equiv\frac{1}{2}\dot{M}_{w}{\cal{V}}_{w}^{2} \dot{p}_{w} wind momentum input rate \dot{p}_{w}\equiv\dot{M}_{w}{\cal{V}}_{w} Q_{0} ionizing photon emission rate \mathcal{R} volume-equivalent radius for volume V \mathcal{R}\equiv\left(3V/4\pi\right)^{1/3} \theta fraction of energy lost to cooling for energy-driven-like (ED-like) solutions \theta\equiv\dot{E}_{\rm cool}/\mathcal{L}_{w} R_{{\rm ED},\theta}(t) bubble radius for ED-like solutions Equation 1 P_{{\rm ED},\theta}(t) bubble pressure for ED-like solutions Equation 2 p_{{\rm ED},\theta}(t) bubble radial momentum for ED-like solutions Equation 3 \alpha_{p} momentum enhancement factor for \alpha_{p}\equiv\dot{p}_{r}/\dot{p}_{w} , Equation 6 , \cdots momentum-driven-like (MD-like) solutions Equation 10 R_{{\rm MD},\alpha}(t) bubble radius for MD-like solutions Equation 5 P_{{\rm MD},\alpha}(t) bubble pressure for MD-like solutions Equation 7 p_{{\rm MD},\alpha}(t) bubble radial momentum for MD-like solutions Equation