The fraction of polar aligned circumbinary disks
Ted M. Johnson, Rebecca G. Martin, Stephen Lepp, Stephen H. Lubow · 2025
Read The fraction of polar aligned circumbinary disks by Ted M. Johnson, Rebecca G. Martin, Stephen Lepp, Stephen H. Lubow (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22728.txt.
Introduction
Ted Johnson and three co-authors count how many double-star systems should host sideways disks in a 2025 paper. Gas disks around a pair of stars start tilted and settle one of two ways: flat with the stars' orbit, or polar, standing at a right angle to it. Which ending wins depends on how the disk's tilt wobbles.
Earlier estimates assumed weightless disks. The new work includes disks with real mass. For light disks, the polar share swings strongly with how stretched the stars' orbit is, rising as the orbit stretches. For heavy disks, the share settles near thirty-seven percent whatever the orbit shape. Populations born with small tilts show fewer polar disks either way. Real disks also live briefly and spread over distance, which can freeze them mid-journey. The formulas let astronomers predict polar disk rates for any known star population.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ted M. Johnson, Rebecca G. Martin, Stephen Lepp, Stephen H. Lubow |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 48 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22728
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
The fraction of polar aligned circumbinary disks Ted M. Johnson, Rebecca G. Martin, Stephen Lepp, Stephen H. Lubow Abstract Circumbinary gas disks that are misaligned to the binary orbital plane evolve toward either a coplanar or a polar-aligned configuration with respect to the binary host. The preferred alignment depends on the dynamics of the disk: whether it undergoes librating or circulating nodal precession, with librating disks evolving to polar inclinations and circulating disks evolving to coplanar. We quantify the fraction of binary star systems whose disks are expected to have polar orbits f polar f_{\text{polar}} , extending previous work to include disks with non-zero mass. Our results suggest that, for low mass disks, the polar fraction is highly sensitive to the distribution of binary eccentricity with a higher fraction expected for higher binary eccentricities, f polar ∼ e b f_{\rm polar}\sim e_{\rm b} . However, for massive discs, the fraction is independent of the binary eccentricity and f polar ≈ 0.37 f_{\rm polar}\approx 0.37 . The value of f polar f_{\text{polar}} is always reduced in a population with a greater preference for low initial mutual inclination. We also explore the consequences of the finite lifetime and non-zero radial extent of a real disk, both of which affect a disk’s ability to complete its evolution to a stationary configuration. Our findings can be used to make predictions given populations with well-understood distributions of binary eccentricity, initial mutual inclination, and disk angular momentum. I Introduction Observed circumbinary planets – those orbiting two stars – have mostly been found to orbit in the same plane as their hosts ( Doyle et al. 2011 ; Orosz et al. 2012 ; Welsh et al. 2012 ) . While this preference is the result of target selection effects ( Martin & Triaud 2014 , see also Martin & Triaud 2015 , Martin 2017 ), it is also representative of the fact that, for the disk progenitors of these planets ( Childs & Martin 2021 , from which the planets inherit orbital parameters, see) , a coplanar alignment is one of two possible stable orientations ( Bate et al. 2000 ; Lubow & Ogilvie 2000 ) . The other configuration – a polar disk – is characterized by being inclined 90^{\circ} relative to the binary orbital plane ( Aly et al. 2015 ; Martin & Lubow 2017 ) . Only a handful of confirmed polar disks have ever been discovered. These include a polar debris disk in the 99 Her system ( Kennedy et al. 2012 , which likely evolved from a polar gas disk, see Smallwood et al. 2020 ) and polar gas disks in the HD 98800 ( Kennedy et al. 2019 ) and V773 Tau ( Kenworthy et al. 2022 ) systems. Recently, strong evidence for the first polar planet has been presented by Baycroft et al. 2025 . They use radial velocity measurements of an eclipsing binary to infer retrograde apsidal precession which can be best explained by a planetary mass companion in a polar orbit. The only previous evidence for a polar circumbinary planet comes from AC Her, a post-AGB star system that hosts an unusually-truncated circumbinary disk, with a planet located interior to the disk’s inner edge being the most likely cause ( Hillen et al. 2015 ; Anugu et al. 2023 ; Martin et al. 2023 ) . Through surveys of recent literature in circumbinary disk characterization ( Czekala et al. 2019 ; Zurlo et al. 2023 ) , Ceppi et al. 2024 estimate that the fraction of circumbinary disks which are polar ( f_{\text{polar}} ) is 0.17\pm 0.08 , though they acknowledge that the sample size is small ( \sim 15 disks) and that the mutual inclination is hard to measure. They place this result in the context of a theoretical framework for a massless disk ( Farago & Laskar 2010 ; Lubow & Martin 2018 ; Zanazzi & Lai 2018 ) to conclude that observations are not telling the whole story. In this work, we use the results of Martin & Lubow 2019 to extend this theoretical framework to massive disks. Disks which are slightly misaligned from coplanar (or retrograde coplanar) undergo circulating nodal precession about the binary angular momentum vector ( Papaloizou & Terquem 1995 ) . Bate et al. 2000 and Lubow & Ogilvie 2000 show that this kind of motion leads to coplanar alignment (or retrograde coplanar alignment) on a timescale that scales as h^{2}/\alpha , where h and \alpha are the disk aspect ratio and viscosity parameter, respectively. Note that we use the terms prograde and retrograde to describe the direction of the orbit of the third body relative to the binary orbit, rather than the direction of the nodal precession. When the mutual inclination is \sim\pi/2 (near polar), the disk can librate about the eccentricity vector of the binary ( Verrier & Evans 2009 ; Farago & Laskar 2010 ; Doolin & Blundell 2011 , e.g.,) . In addition, for sufficiently massive disks, a third kind of motion arises at high inclinations. Crescent orbits take over at inclinations between libration and retrograde circulation, named because of the shape they form on a phase diagram ( Chen et al. 2019 , see also Zanazzi & Lai 2018 ). Abod et al. 2022 showed that both librating and crescent orbiting disks decay to the stationary polar inclination ( Martin & Lubow 2019 , see) on an evolutionary timescale similar to that of coplanar alignment. Thus, when the disk lifetime is longer than the alignment timescale, it is appropriate to map the secular dynamics (which we call the dynamical state, e.g. nodal precession, libration or crescent orbits) to an end state of the disk (coplanar or polar, respectively). More challenging is mapping the parameters of the disk-binary system (e.g., binary eccentricity, initial inclination, disk mass, etc.) to a dynamical state. In general, this can be done using expensive 3D disk simulations (e.g., those shown in Aly et al. 2015 , Cuello & Giuppone 2019 Martin & Lubow 2019 , Smallwood et al. 2019 , Abod et al. 2022 , Young et al. 2023 & Ceppi et al. 2023 ). It is not feasible to perform such simulations over a large parameter space, so we instead approximate a disk as a geometrically narrow ring with angular momentum equivalent to that of the extended disk it represents. The literature provides a robust theoretical framework for the dynamics of such a ring, with analytical solutions ( Farago & Laskar 2010 ; Zanazzi & Lai 2018 ; Martin & Lubow 2019 ) as well as numerical n -body simulations ( Abod et al. 2022 ; Lepp et al. 2022 ) used to translate initial conditions into the ring’s dynamical state. For simplicity, we assume that the narrow ring model approximates an extended disk sufficiently well. This is justified if warps and breaks are not important to the disk’s evolution, though we discuss these effects in the context of our model. In this study we use three methods, varying from purely analytic to n -body and statistical, to calculate f_{\text{polar}} for a given population. In Section II we extend the analytic work to massive rings. Section III describes the numerical integration