Turbulent separation control with a tilted wavy wall: a promising approach for energy savings in aerodynamic systems

Piotr Kamiński, Artur Tyliszczak, Witold Elsner, Paweł Niegodajew · 2025

Read Turbulent separation control with a tilted wavy wall: a promising approach for energy savings in aerodynamic systems by Piotr Kamiński, Artur Tyliszczak, Witold Elsner, Paweł Niegodajew (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22611.txt.

Introduction

Piotr Kaminski, Artur Tyliszczak, Witold Elsner, and Pawel Niegodajew test in a 2025 paper a tilted wavy wall for holding airflow to a surface. Flow that peels off a wing or blade wastes energy and lift. A plain wavy wall had already delayed that peel at high speeds in past work.

Tilting each wave in the new design clears the stall pockets that form in wave troughs. Large eddy simulations map both instant and average flow over the surface. Against the best plain wave shape, drag drops 14% with the tilt. Peel control improves 70% at the same time in the tests. Pushing peel control even further is possible, though at a drag cost the authors note.

Catalog record

CREATORPiotr Kamiński, Artur Tyliszczak, Witold Elsner, Paweł Niegodajew
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE34 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22611

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Turbulent separation control with a tilted wavy wall: a promising approach for energy savings in aerodynamic systems Piotr Kamiński, Artur Tyliszczak, Witold Elsner, Paweł Niegodajew Abstract Recently, Kamiński et al. kaminski2024numerical demonstrated that a two-dimensional streamwise waviness with carefully selected amplitude and period can be effectively used in postponement of a flow separation at high Reynolds number which is out of reach for other commonly known passive flow control strategies. This paper demonstrates that this approach can be substantially improved by introducing a novel type of surface waviness characterized by tilting the subsequent waves. The research is performed by applying the Large Eddy Simulation (LES) method allowing for a detailed analysis of both instantaneous and time-averaged flow characteristics. It is shown that the tilting eliminates the occurrence of separation zones in waviness troughs, which minimizes the shape drag and maximizes the wall shear stress. In particular, compared to an optimal classical sinusoidal waviness shape the drag coefficient drops 14%. Simultaneously, 70% better performance in separation control is achieved. Moreover, it is also shown that when this issue is a priority, even further improvement can be achieved, though at the expense of greater drag. Keywords : Turbulent boundary layer, adverse pressure gradient, passive flow control, flow separation, wall-shear stress 1 Introduction The energy efficiency of aerodynamic systems, such as an airplane wing, strongly depends on its near-wall flow dynamics. When a flow experiences an adverse pressure gradient (APG), which is present on the suction side of an airfoil, the separation of the turbulent boundary layer (TBL) is likely to occur when the streamwise component of the wall-shear stress \tau_{w}=\mu(dU/dy) (where \mu is the dynamic viscosity and dU/dy is the near-wall velocity gradient) reaches zero locally. Detachment of TBL from a surface is accompanied with a significant increase in total drag, resulting in a substantial energy loss and consequently, increased fuel consumption lin1996low ; tanarro2020effect . Other examples where separation can significantly affect energy efficiency include the flow inside a diffuser azad1996turbulent ; salehi2017computation ; yadegari2020numerical , around a wind turbine blade devinant2002experimental ; cui2020simulations ; abdolahifar2022comprehensive ; xu2017delayed ; wang2018influence or within axial or centrifugal pumps used as turbines shojaeefard2024analyzing ; nguyen2024co . Ricco et al. RICCO2021100713 , in their review paper, suggested that considerable energy savings, particularly in aerodynamic systems, may be obtained by introducing appropriate flow control methods, which can contribute up to 15\% of total drag reduction. Bearing this in mind, the control of separation is critical to minimize energy losses and thus reduce fuel consumption. This scenario has motivated scientists to search for new or to improve already known flow control techniques. In general, there are two types of flow control approaches: active and passive ashill2005review ; ghaemi2020passive ; moghaddam2017active . Active control involves systems, often quite complex, that require an external energy source collis2004issues . Due to the necessity for external input and high cost, these methods are often less appealing from the perspective of energy savings. On the other hand, passive control strategies, which typically involve surface geometry modifications or introducing roughness, do not require external energy input and are generally more cost-effective, which makes them significantly more attractive for practical applications. A number of passive approaches have so far been developed and the following ones are the most commonly employed in practice: dimples tay2018drag ; tay2015mechanics ; gattere2022dimples ; aoki2012mechanism ; tay2019drag ; azlan2023passive ; vortex generators koike2004research ; aider2010drag , which are employed in various types of systems, i.e., airfoil surfaces, helicopter rotors gibertini2015helicopter , wind turbine blades zhu2019dynamic ; wang2017flow , and car bodies islam2013drag . Also a considerable attention is paid to investigating some more unconventional control methods, such as modifying the airfoil surface shape by introducing slots belamadi2016aerodynamic ; coder2020design , slats zaki2022effects ; wang2019effects , Gurney flaps ye2023numerical ; ni2021impacts , or placing microcylinders near a blade leading edge WANG2018101 ; mostafa2022quantitative ; wang2023wake ; zhong2023dynamic . Quite often, nature itself suggests solutions that are optimal for the given flow scenario and inspires researchers and engineers to employ them in practice. Good examples of such solutions are wingtip devices known as winglets, which are inspired by bird wings guerrero2012biomimetic ; wu2018experimental ; guerrero2020variable ; zhang2023comparative ; jeong2022efficient ; khaled2019investigation ; riblets lowrey1991preliminary or adaptive flaps hao2020performance reflecting the shapes of bird feathers chen2013biomimetic ; yossri2023evaluation ; and various types of microstructures borrowed from the skin of aquatic animals schlieter2016mechanical ; lang2017separation ; wu2018experimental . Unfortunately, as suggested in Refs. lissaman1983low ; xie2022investigation , the effectiveness of the outlined passive approaches is limited to flows experiencing laminar or transitional conditions. For high Reynolds numbers, when the flow becomes fully turbulent, employment of, in particular, an artificial roughness is not recommended as it may lead to increased total drag and even to earlier separation mcmasters1979low ; Wu_Piomelli_2018 . In light of these facts, it appears that the use of active methods is the most reasonable choice to prevent TBL separation at high Re . In the experimental study by Dróżdż et al. drozdz2021effective devoted to air flow exposed to APG conditions, the authors showed that by precisely adjusting the amplitude A and the period length \lambda of a two-dimensional (2D) streamwise waviness on a wall surface, it is possible to significantly increase \tau_{w} , thereby delaying TBL separation. They suggested that the amplitude of the waviness should be scaled to the size of the inner layer, meaning A should increase proportionally to the TBL thickness \delta found, in the same area, for a configuration with a flat wall. Simultaneously, the corrugation crests should not penetrate the outer region of TBL. Notably, the increase in \tau_{w} , which ensures a delay of turbulent separation, was achieved in a fully turbulent flow regime, where most passive flow control methods are ineffective. Worth noting is that the streamwise waviness has found so far some other applications such as reducing the leading-edge interaction noise of an airfoil casalino2019aeroacoustic ; teruna2022numerical or enhancement of heat transfer process bhardwaj2015influence ; abbaspour2024numerical . Recently, Kamiński et al. kaminski2024numerical performed Large Eddy Simulation (LES) studies of a flow over 2D streamwise wavy wall (WW) under APG and ZPG conditions at the friction Reynolds number equal to Re_{\tau}=\frac{u_{\tau}\delta}{\nu}=2500 (where u_{\tau} is the friction velocity, \delta is the boundary layer thickness and \nu is the kinematic viscosity). In agreement with the experimental research of Dróżdż et al. drozdz2021effective it has been proven that by using a WW shape one can increase \tau_{w} locally, thereby postponing the point of TBL separation. Interestingly, enhancement of \tau_{w} was reported only under APG conditions. The authors also demonstrated that the benefit of augmented \tau_{w} comes at the cost of increased total drag in the area occupied by the waviness. The studies of Kamiński et al. kaminski2024numerical and Dróżdż et al. drozdz2021effective , though demonstrated a large potential of WW in the control of \tau_{w} , were limited only to a sinusoidal type of the waviness in which the adjustable parameter was the amplitude A of the sine wave. In the present study, we maintain a constant A/\delta ratio as in kaminski2024numerical ; drozdz2021effective and additionally modify the waviness by introducing streamwise and counter-streamwise tilting to its sinusoidal shape. The research is performed by applying the

Read the complete text