Science for Peace and the need for Civil Clauses at universities and civilian research institutions
J. Altmann, U. Amaldi , M. Barone , A. Bassalat , M. Bona , J. Beullens, H. Brand , S. Brentjes , D. Britzger , J. Ellis , S. Franchoo , A. Giammanco , A. Glazov , C. Heck , H. Jung , S. Kraml , L. Lönnblad , M. Mangano , M. Renneberg, Th. Riebe, A. Sabio-Vera , R. Sanders, J. Scheffran , M. Schmell · 2025
Read Science for Peace and the need for Civil Clauses at universities and civilian research institutions by J. Altmann, U. Amaldi , M. Barone , A. Bassalat , M. Bona , J. Beullens, H. Brand , S. Brentjes , D. Britzger , J. Ellis , S. Franchoo , A. Giammanco , A. Glazov , C. Heck , H. Jung , S. Kraml , L. Lönnblad , M. Mangano , M. Renneberg, Th. Riebe, A. Sabio-Vera , R. Sanders, J. Scheffran , M. Schmell (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22476.txt.
Introduction
Altmann and co-authors present a 2025 paper arguing for Civil Clauses that keep university science peaceful. After the Second World War, many institutes wrote such pledges into their charters. Fresh government and European reports now question their reach, blurring the line between civilian and military work. A panel of the Science4Peace Forum supplied the reflections gathered here.
Clause adoptions across countries are reviewed one by one. Challenges already pressing on the clauses get documented. Arguments for holding the civilian line close the case. Dozens of signatories from the physics community back the statement. The paper speaks to rectors and funders weighing dual-use drift in public research.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | J. Altmann, U. Amaldi , M. Barone , A. Bassalat , M. Bona , J. Beullens, H. Brand , S. Brentjes , D. Britzger , J. Ellis , S. Franchoo , A. Giammanco , A. Glazov , C. Heck , H. Jung , S. Kraml , L. Lönnblad , M. Mangano , M. Renneberg, Th. Riebe, A. Sabio-Vera , R. Sanders, J. Scheffran , M. Schmell |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 76 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22476
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Science for Peace and the need for Civil Clauses at universities and civilian research institutions J. Altmann, U. Amaldi , M. Barone , A. Bassalat , M. Bona , J. Beullens, H. Brand , S. Brentjes , D. Britzger , J. Ellis , S. Franchoo , A. Giammanco , A. Glazov , C. Heck , H. Jung , S. Kraml , L. Lönnblad , M. Mangano , M. Renneberg, Th. Riebe, A. Sabio-Vera , R. Sanders, J. Scheffran , M. Schmelling , T. Schucker , T. Suzuki , A. Tanasijczuk , I. Tsakov, D. Valls-Gabaud, M. Walker Abstract After the end of World War II, the commitment to confine scientific activities in universities and research institutions to peaceful and civilian purposes has entered, in the form of Civil Clauses , the charters of many research institutions and universities. In the wake of recent world events, the relevance and scope of such Civil Clauses has been questioned in reports issued by some governments and by the EU Commission, a development that opens the door to a possible blurring of the distinction between peaceful and military research. This paper documents the reflections stimulated by a panel discussion on this issue recently organized by the Science4Peace Forum. We review the adoptions of Civil Clauses in research organizations and institutions in various countries, present evidence of the challenges that are emerging to such Civil Clauses, and collect arguments in favour of maintaining the purely civilian and peaceful focus of public (non-military) research. August 24, 2026 The Science4Peace Forum 2 2 2 Where authors are specified, they take responsibility for their respective sections. Their opinions are not meant to represent the position of the institution to which they are affiliated. When affiliations are mentioned, this is simply to illustrate the scientific contexts in which the authors work. 1 Preface The Convention of the international organization CERN in Geneva states that “the Organization shall have no concern with work for military requirements". Likewise, the international organization JINR in Dubna declares that its research results “can be used only for peaceful purposes for the benefit of the whole of mankind". In Germany “Civil Clauses", commitments to work only for civilian and peaceful goals, have been adopted as voluntary declarations by many institutions and universities. However, whilst there has been common agreement on research for peaceful and civil purposes after World War II, recently discussion of the utility and relevance of Civil Clauses has been put on the table by the EU commission as well as by some national governments. This development reflects new, concerning changes in science policy. On one hand, following the invasion of Ukraine by the army of the Russian Federation, co-operation with scientists from Russian and Belorussian institutions was stopped and their scientists were excluded from participating in international civilian research projects. On the other hand, attempts to open for military purposes research institutions that were in the past bastions of civilian research contribute further to sanctioning their science communities and treating them as enemies, abandoning the universal nature of science. Triggered in 2024 by a White Paper of the EU Commission as well as a Position Paper by the German Ministry for Education and Research, the Science4Peace Forum started in September 2024 discussions among a panel of experts on different aspects of Civil Clauses. In Spring 2025, the EU commission has released the ReArm Europe Plan/Readiness 2030. In response to these developments, in this paper we collect arguments for maintaining the purely civilian and peaceful focus of public (non-military) research and argue that scientific progress for the benefit of humanity can only be achieved by the collective efforts of all countries and nations. Limiting the collaboration on research only to those countries that share the same political values will create only anger, mistrust and further conflicts. This will lead to another arms race and will work against finding solutions to the most important problems humanity is facing now: climate change, ecocide, poverty and, most of all, the proliferation of wars. 2 Introduction In January 2024, the EU Commission issued a White Paper [ 1 ] calling for a special effort to promote research with both civil and military objectives (dual-use research). Similarly, the German Ministry of Education and Research (BMBF) released a Position Paper [ 2 ] in March 2024 calling for the deepening of cooperation between civilian and military research institutions and for establishing funding incentives for increased cooperation between civilian and military research . In its annual report for 2024, the German Research and Innovation Expert Commission proposed dissolving the previous separation between civil and military research [ 3 ] . In March 2025 the EU commission has released the ReArm Europe Plan/Readiness 2030 [ 4 ] . This reorientation is in fundamental contradiction to the spirit of civilian research following the experiences of World War II: at the opening of the Technical University of Berlin in 1949 Major-General E.P. Nares said in his opening speech [ 5 ] : The British authorities are well aware that the Technical High School of Berlin made a valuable contribution to your country’s war potential and was one of the props of the technical development of the vast war machine which Hitler built up to oppress other peoples … The four great Allies - Russia, France, the United States and Great Britain - have vowed that such a war machine shall never be allowed to rise again…. and he continued by saying Science and technology can be and must be devoted to advancing the peace and civilisation of man and this can only be so if they are used with responsibility. The Science Council of Japan vowed in 1950 to never become engaged in scientific research for war purposes [ 6 ] . At the international organization CERN, where the Higgs Boson was found in 2012, the Convention of 1954 [ 7 ] demands explicitly that it shall have no concern with work for military requirements , and the guiding principles of the Helmholtz Research Center DESY in Germany [ 8 ] stipulate that its research pursues goals that are peaceful and serve civil society . Moreover, many universities and institutions in Germany have adopted Civil Clauses [ 9 ] that voluntarily focus their research and teaching for purely civilian and peaceful purposes. The discussion of opening civilian research institutions to military research threatens international scientific cooperation, and research funds that are allocated to civilian research might be withdrawn and could be dedicated to dual-use and military research, as criticized in a statement [ 10 ] of the German University Rectors’ Conference (HRK). However, in the ReArm Europe Plan/Readiness 2030 White Paper of the EU Commission [ 4 ] it is explicitly stated that the European Innovation Council and the planned TechEU Scale-up Fund will invest in dual-use technologies . At DESY the directorate initiated a discussion in June 2024 [ 11 ] on whether the restriction of research to civilian and peaceful purposes is still appropriate, or whether military research should be allowed at the laboratory. This initiative triggered many discussions and protests at DESY, where shortly after this announcement a petition in opposition to this move [ 12 ] was launched. This