Intermittency in Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections Observed by Parker Solar Probe and Solar Orbiter

Julia Ruohotie, Simon Good, Christian Möstl, Emilia Kilpua · 2025

Read Intermittency in Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections Observed by Parker Solar Probe and Solar Orbiter by Julia Ruohotie, Simon Good, Christian Möstl, Emilia Kilpua (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22283.txt.

Introduction

Julia Ruohotie and three co-authors study spiky signals inside giant outbursts of solar plasma as they sweep past probes in space. These outbursts are known for smooth, rope-like form at large scales. At small scales, though, they carry a range of waves and jolts. The team used data from two probes, one close to the Sun and one farther out, covering forty-nine outbursts at varied ranges.

They measured a statistic that captures how spiky the signal is. Inside the outbursts, the spikiness matched the pattern seen in plain turbulent flows, and it stayed the same with range from the Sun. That steadiness suggests the outbursts are settled, mature turbulent systems. In the squeezed sheath zones ahead of outbursts, spikiness grew with range, showing turbulence still forming there. The comparison helps separate true turbulence from other structures in the solar wind.

Catalog record

CREATORJulia Ruohotie, Simon Good, Christian Möstl, Emilia Kilpua
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE38 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22283

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Intermittency in Interplanetary Coronal Mass Ejections Observed by Parker Solar Probe and Solar Orbiter Julia Ruohotie, Simon Good, Christian Möstl, Emilia Kilpua Abstract Intermittency has been studied extensively in the fast and slow solar winds but to a far lesser extent in interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICMEs). While ICMEs are often characterized by their relatively smooth, large-scale magnetic flux rope structures, a spectrum of fluctuations is nonetheless present at smaller scales. We have examined kurtosis and its scaling exponents at magnetohydrodynamic inertial scales in 49 ICMEs observed between 0.25 and 1 au by Parker Solar Probe and Solar Orbiter, and compared the results to those obtained for the ICME sheath regions and ambient solar wind intervals. Kurtosis behaves similarly in all intervals studied and presents a universal behavior typical of intermittent time series. The ICMEs displayed a radially invariant level of intermittency, suggesting that they are relatively static, well-developed turbulent environments. In the sheath regions, the level of intermittency increased with distance, indicating that the turbulence is not yet fully developed at small heliocentric distances. In addition to intermittent fluctuations related to turbulence, the sheath regions may possess a population of non-turbulent structures that increase the absolute value of kurtosis. Journal: ApJL I Introduction The solar wind structure is modified by magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence which results in the generation of fluctuations at various scales [ 5 , e.g.] . In Alfvén wave turbulence models, the turbulence is due to nonlinear interactions between counterpropagating Alfvén waves which give rise to a transfer of energy across different scales. This energy transfer is evident from the power spectral density (PSD) of the magnetic field fluctuations, which takes the form of a power law with spectral index values usually at around -5/3 or -3/2 in the inertial range [ 10 , 57 , e.g.] . Nonlinear dynamics in the plasma result in nonlinear energy transfer, giving rise to intermittency, an uneven distribution of energy in the system [ 15 , 50 , 29 , e.g.] . Intermittency increases towards smaller scales leading to nonlinear scaling laws and non-Gaussian statistics which are seen as wider tails in probability density functions (PDFs) of increments. The slow solar wind has been observed to be more intermittent than the fast wind but the radial evolution of intermittency, which shows an increasing trend, has only been observed in the fast wind in the ecliptic plane [ 4 , 58 , e.g.] . Interplanetary coronal mass ejections [ 23 , ICMEs; e.g.] offer a distinct plasma environment compared to the solar wind. They are often associated with large-scale flux ropes with strong fields, low plasma \beta , and rotation over a large angle [ 9 , e.g.] . They are additionally observed to be environments with low cross helicity [ 17 , 16 ] , a parameter that describes the balance of power between Alfvénic fluctuations parallel and anti-parallel to the mean magnetic field. A subset of ICMEs with smooth rotation, low plasma temperature, and relatively small fluctuation amplitudes are called magnetic clouds [ 8 , MCs; e.g.] . If an ICME propagates fast enough, a sheath region will form ahead of it [ 23 , e.g.] . These structures consist of the preceding solar wind that has been piled up between the shock and the leading edge of the ICME and they are often characterized by their ’turbulent’ nature, i.e. containing large-amplitude fluctuations [ 25 , e.g.] . ICME sheaths show a range of dynamic turbulent behavior at 1 au [ 33 , 43 , 47 , e.g.] . The large-scale dynamics of ICMEs are fairly well known, but the same is not true of their small-scale characteristics. In addition to smoothly varying MCs with relatively simple structures, ICMEs with complex structures and fluctuations at various scales are observed [ 20 , 54 , e.g.] . The observed magnetic structure of ICMEs is affected by large-scale dynamics like the expansion of the ICME and interactions with the surrounding solar wind. Small-scale dynamics giving rise to fluctuations include, for example, the turbulence which has been studied both observationally [ 18 , 44 ] and through simulations [ 40 ] . Intermittency has been widely researched in the solar wind and lately also in ICME sheaths [ 41 , 26 , 24 ] . On the other hand, in ICMEs, intermittency and other mesoscale structures and dynamics have generally gathered less attention, though this has changed in recent years [ 39 , e.g.] . Intermittency in ICMEs has previously been studied by Sorriso-Valvo et al. [51] and Márquez Rodríguez et al. [34] but to our knowledge no dedicated statistical study has been carried out. The presence of intermittency in ICMEs raises questions about the origin of intermittent fluctuations, how their presence fits with the traditional picture of a smooth flux rope structure, and what effects intermittency may have on the dynamics of the ICMEs. In this paper, we present a statistical study of magnetic field intermittency in ICMEs observed by Parker Solar Probe [ 14 , PSP;] and Solar Orbiter [ 37 , SolO;] at various heliocentric distances. Intermittency is studied using structure functions, with scale-dependent kurtosis used as the main intermittency measure. The results are compared to those obtained by similar analysis of the preceding and trailing solar wind and in the ICME sheath regions. Additionally, we study the connection between kurtosis and heliocentric distance, speed, spectral index, residual energy, cross helicity, and proton \beta . II Data and methods In this study, 49 ICMEs observed by PSP and SolO at distances between 0.25 and 1 au are studied. Events are collected from the HELIO4CAST ICMECAT database [ 35 , 36 ] . Events are required to have good coverage of both magnetic field and plasma data without major data gaps. Recalling that ICMEs are characterized by low \beta , only events with average proton \beta of less than 0.5 are included. The minimum duration of ICMEs is set at 3 hours in order to sample most of the inertial range in frequency space [ 27 , e.g.] . For one event, the trailing end boundary of the ICME given in the ICMECAT database has been altered via visual inspection due to the possible presence of another structure immediately after the ICME. See the Appendix for the full list of ICMEs used. In addition to the ICME intervals, three other interval types are examined: ICME sheaths, and upstream and downstream solar wind periods. The minimum duration of sheaths is set to 3 hours, similar to the ICMEs. The durations of the upstream and downstream intervals equal the mean duration of the analyzed ICMEs, namely \sim 11.7 hours. For upstream and downstream intervals to be included in the study, the ICME cannot be preceded or followed by another large-scale structure (e.g. another ICME or crossings of the heliospheric current sheet) unless the separation is at least 23.4 hours (i.e. twice the mean ICME duration). The magnetic field data from the PSP/FIELDS [ 1 ] and the SolO/MAG [ 19 ] instruments are used with time resolutions of 0.218 s and \sim 0.125 s, respectively. The ion moments are from the PSP/SWEAP-SPC [ 21 ] and the SolO/SWA [ 38 ] instruments,

Read the complete text