Diverse reddening distributions in sight lines to type Ia supernovae

Lucas Hallgren, Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth, Charles L. Steinhardt · 2025

Read Diverse reddening distributions in sight lines to type Ia supernovae by Lucas Hallgren, Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth, Charles L. Steinhardt (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-22216.txt.

Introduction

Lucas Hallgren, Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth, and Charles Steinhardt wrote this 2025 study on the dust that dims and reddens type Ia supernovae in their host galaxies. Exact measures of the universe from these blasts need exact dust fixes. The field has long used one falling curve as the shared guess for how much reddening to expect in any host.

The team simulated dust and blast sites in spiral and oval galaxies to test that guess. The two host types gave unlike reddening spreads, driven by how much dust each holds for its stars. Spiral hosts matched the seen values well, while oval hosts sat far lower. Both showed more clear sight lines than the shared curve allows. The authors warn that one shared guess bends the dust traits read from the data and may skew distance calls.

Catalog record

CREATORLucas Hallgren, Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth, Charles L. Steinhardt
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE56 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-22216

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Diverse reddening distributions in sight lines to type Ia supernovae Lucas Hallgren, Radosław Wojtak, Jens Hjorth, Charles L. Steinhardt Abstract Context. Precise cosmological constraints from type Ia supernovae require adequately accurate corrections for host-galaxy extinction. Modelling these corrections is challenged by the problem of disentangling supernova intrinsic colours from host-galaxy interstellar reddening. The latter is commonly modelled in a probabilistic way assuming an exponential distribution exp ( − E ( B − V ) / τ ) \exp(-E(B-V)/\tau) as a universal prior which is applied across all types of supernova host galaxies. Aims. We test the robustness of the exponential model of host-galaxy reddening and its universality against predictions based on simulating dust and type Ia supernova distributions in host galaxies of different morphological types. Methods. Our simulations incorporate up-to-date observational constraints on dust masses across host-galaxy morphological types, scaling relations between the dust and stellar disc parameters and the supernova distribution. Results. We find substantial differences between predicted interstellar reddening in late- and early-type host galaxies, primarily driven by the stellar-to-dust mass ratios. The mean simulated reddening in late-type galaxies matches well those derived from type Ia supernova observations, but it is significantly lower for early-type host galaxies. The obtained reddening distributions exhibit an excess of sight lines with vanishing reddening with respect to the commonly used exponential model, although the difference is quite mild for late-type galaxies. On the other hand, the distribution may peak at E ⁡ ( B − V ) > 0 E(B-V)>0 when considering a population of young type Ia supernovae originating from lower heights within the dust disc of spiral galaxies. Conclusions. The reddening distribution strongly depends on the supernova host-galaxy morphological type. Assuming a universal reddening prior distribution for modeling peak magnitude-colour relation, which is currently a common practice, gives rise to a spurious scatter in the derived extinction properties. It may also bias relative distances between supernovae originating from different host-galaxy populations. The discrepancy between the simulated reddening in average early-type host galaxies and the observed occurrence of reddened supernovae in these galaxies suggests that reddening does not originate from interstellar dust expected in these hosts. 1 Introduction Type Ia supernovae have long been used to measure cosmological distances and place constraints on cosmological parameters. They played a key role in the discovery of cosmic acceleration and in laying the observational foundation for the concordance \Lambda CDM cosmological model ( Riess et al. 1998 ; Perlmutter et al. 1999 ) . Using type Ia supernovae as a cosmological probe was enabled both by the advent of large survey for time-domain astronomy and by developing a range of corrections needed to use them as effective standard candles. The ongoing progress both in terms of observations and standardisation models aims at achieving sufficient accuracy for constraining the dark energy equation of state. However, apparent discrepancies between recent cosmological results obtained from different supernova compilations ( Brout et al. 2022 ; DES Collaboration et al. 2024 ; Rubin et al. 2023 , compare e.g.) suggest that the current measurements are affected by underestimated systematic errors ( Efstathiou 2025 ) . These errors likely originate from insufficient accuracy of the standardisation models. They generate non-negligible biases in current cosmological measurements (see Wojtak & Hjorth 2022 ; Gall et al. 2024 ; Wojtak & Hjorth 2024 , in the context of the local Hubble constant measurement) . The present and future accuracy of measuring cosmological distances with type Ia supernovae relies critically on understanding a range of assumptions employed by the standardisation models. Arguably, the most problematic aspect of it is the so-called colour correction which aims to account for the observed relation between supernova peak absolute luminosity and its apparent colour. The complexity of this relation results from the fact that it is driven by two independent physical effects – supernova intrinsic emission and host-galaxy extinction – for which the relevant variables are a priori unknown. These two effects can be disentangled in a probabilistic way by modelling type Ia supernova samples. This approach was applied to a wide range of supernova data sets, either as a part of light curve analysis ( Mandel et al. 2022 ; Ward et al. 2023 ; Thorp & Mandel 2022 , see e.g.) or as a post-processing analysis of supernova colours derived from light curve fitting ( Mandel et al. 2011 ; Mandel et al. 2017 ; Brout & Scolnic 2021 ; Wojtak et al. 2023 , see e.g.) . The obtained results, however, depend strongly on the adopted assumptions, in particular the prior probability distributions of supernova intrinsic colours and host-galaxy reddening. Virtually all models of type Ia supernova colours (at a fixed phase of light curves) assume a Gaussian prior for intrinsic colours and an exponential distribution for host-galaxy reddening. The former is not motivated by any generic outcome of type Ia supernova simulations, but is rather the easiest choice for a random variable with measurable mean and scatter. The exponential prior for reddening was introduced in early modelling of type Ia supernova data ( Jha et al. 2007 ) as an approximation of supernova host-galaxy reddening distributions obtained from simulating extinction in disc-like galaxies ( Riello & Patat 2005 ; Hatano et al. 1998 ) . However, the exponential model has never been compared quantitatively to the simulated reddening distributions in relation to the assumptions about the spatial density of dust and type Ia supernovae. Furthermore, the model does not take into account the fact that about 30 per cent of type Ia supernovae originate from early-type galaxies ( Hakobyan et al. 2012 ; Pruzhinskaya et al. 2020 ) with very low or negligible interstellar extinction. The combination of the Gaussian prior for supernova intrinsic colours and the exponential prior for host-galaxy reddening seems to be sufficient to model characteristic fat-tailed distributions of supernova apparent colours, well visible in many independent supernova samples ( Ginolin et al. 2025 ; Brout & Scolnic 2021 ) . However, this does not necessarily guarantee that the model is complete. Based on combined modelling of supernova apparent colours and peak magnitudes, many studies find surprisingly low total-to-selective extinction coefficients with R_{\rm V}\lesssim 2 , either for entire supernova samples ( Kessler et al. 2009 ; Burns et al. 2014 ) or for supernova population in massive host galaxies ( Brout & Scolnic 2021 ; Popovic et al. 2021 ) . These estimates are discrepant with independent and mutually consistent measurements of the extinction coefficient for the Milky Way ( Schlafly et al. 2016 ; Fitzpatrick & Massa 2007 ; Legnardi et al. 2023 ) , other late-type galaxies ( Salim et al. 2018 ; Rino-Silvestre et al. 2025 ) and early-type galaxies ( Patil et al. 2007 ; Goudfrooij et al. 1994 ) , all pointing to a rather narrow distribution of R_{\rm V} peaking at R_{\rm V}\approx 3 and decaying fast towards R_{\rm V}\approx 2 . The most recent improvements in supernova light curve modelling or additional constraints from infrared observations seem to partially alleviate but not eliminate this discrepancy ( Thorp et al. 2021 ; Ward et al. 2023 ; Wojtak et al. 2023 ; Thorp et al. 2024 ) . Although one cannot exclude the effect

Read the complete text