Experimental Evidence That AI-Managed Workers Tolerate Lower Pay Without Demotivation

Mengchen Dong, Levin Brinkmann, Omar Sherif, Shihan Wang, Xinyu Zhang, Jean-François Bonnefon, Iyad Rahwan · 2025

Read Experimental Evidence That AI-Managed Workers Tolerate Lower Pay Without Demotivation by Mengchen Dong, Levin Brinkmann, Omar Sherif, Shihan Wang, Xinyu Zhang, Jean-François Bonnefon, Iyad Rahwan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-21752.txt.

Introduction

Mengchen Dong and co-authors test pay under AI managers in a 2025 study. Past lab work on AI bosses gave mixed reads, in part because tasks felt fake. Their custom Minecraft workplace let players build real skill and be tracked closely.

Three hundred eighty-two workers did repeat production tasks under human, AI, or mixed bosses. The AI boss, trained on human-set grading rules, marked workers lower and cut pay by forty percent. Yet drive and felt fairness held steady. Calm feelings toward AI grades explain the split: less heat, less pushback. The authors warn that the same calm may let quiet exploitation slide.

Catalog record

CREATORMengchen Dong, Levin Brinkmann, Omar Sherif, Shihan Wang, Xinyu Zhang, Jean-François Bonnefon, Iyad Rahwan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE25 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-21752

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Experimental Evidence That AI-Managed Workers Tolerate Lower Pay Without Demotivation Mengchen Dong, Levin Brinkmann, Omar Sherif, Shihan Wang, Xinyu Zhang, Jean-François Bonnefon, Iyad Rahwan Abstract Experimental evidence on worker responses to AI management remains mixed, partly due to limitations in experimental fidelity. We address these limitations with a customized workplace in the Minecraft platform, enabling high-resolution behavioral tracking of autonomous task execution, and ensuring that participants approach the task with well-formed expectations about their own competence. Workers (N = 382) completed repeated production tasks under either human, AI, or hybrid management. An AI manager trained on human-defined evaluation principles systematically assigned lower performance ratings and reduced wages by 40%, without adverse effects on worker motivation and sense of fairness. These effects were driven by a muted emotional response to AI evaluation, compared to evaluation by a human. The very features that make AI appear impartial may also facilitate silent exploitation, by suppressing the social reactions that normally constrain extractive practices in human-managed work. Introduction Companies and organizations increasingly use AI-powered algorithms to manage human workers ( Dong, Bonnefon, and Rahwan 2024 ; Kellogg, Valentine, and Christin 2020 ; Wood 2021 ) . In online customer service centers, AI programs monitor calls, screen activities, and keystrokes to assess worker performance ( Doellgast, Litwin, and Ter Haar 2021 ; Doellgast, Wagner, and O’Brady 2023 ) . In large e-commerce firms like Amazon, algorithmic management uses wearable devices to track location and movements, creating high-resolution depictions of worker activity in the physical world ( Crawford 2021 ; Delfanti 2021 ) . AI management has been credited with increasing company profits and organizational efficiency ( Sun et al. 2021 ; Yaraghi, Ramesh, and Tayi 2024 ) , but these gains often emerge through cost-cutting strategies and intensified worker discipline — for example, when AI-managed workers in gig economy sectors such as ride-hailing and delivery service drive longer hours for lower earnings ( Bucher, Schou, and Waldkirch 2021 ; Delfanti 2021 ; Muldoon et al. 2023 ; Rahman 2021 ; Wood 2021 ) . Such conditions are fertile ground for worker backlash against AI management, which may take the form of gaming the system, disengaging from the platform, or organizing collective resistance ( Anteby and Chan 2018 ; Doellgast, Wagner, and O’Brady 2023 ; Mohlmann and Zalmanson 2018 ) . Yet, experimental findings on how workers respond to AI-driven evaluation and compensation remain inconclusive — leaving us without clear behavioral insight into the consequences of AI management under controlled causal conditions. Indeed, experimental studies have produced contradictory evidence on how workers respond to AI management. Some suggest that AI management can reduce motivation and task engagement ( Ranganathan and Benson 2020 ; Schlund and Zitek 2024 ) , as it is perceived to be reductionistic and lack the subjective capacities required for fair, respectful, or empathetic evaluation ( Acikgoz et al. 2020 ; Lee 2018 ; Dong, Bonnefon, and Rahwan 2024 ; Schlund and Zitek 2024 ) . In contrast, other studies report increased productivity under AI management ( Bai et al. 2020 ; Duani, Barasch, and Morwitz 2024 ) when workers value the consistency and impartiality of AI, particularly when expecting biased treatment from human managers ( Bigman et al. 2023 ; Garvey, Kim, and Duhachek 2023 ; Jago and Laurin 2022 ; Yalcin et al. 2022 ) . These divergent findings reflect not only theoretical tensions but, perhaps more importantly, methodological challenges in designing ecologically valid simulations of AI management in a laboratory setting. Specifically, controlled experiments often struggle to simulate the following features of real-world AI management. Lack of real-time monitoring : Hypothetical scenarios rarely recreate the psychological pressure of being evaluated and observed in real time, a hallmark of AI management ( Bucher, Schou, and Waldkirch 2021 ; Cameron and Rahman 2022 ; Dong, Bonnefon, and Rahwan 2024 ) . Restricted autonomy in task execution : Stripped-down experimental tasks can be too restrictive in terms of the discretion and flexibility that workers have in achieving their goals, which may confound reactions to AI management by amplifying perceptions of control ( Mohlmann and Zalmanson 2018 ; Rahman 2021 ) . Absence of motivational feedback loops : One-shot tasks fail to capture how repeated cycles of AI evaluation and feedback affect workers’ performance and motivation over time. Absence of evaluation-based wages : Hypothetical scenarios do not tie performance evaluations to actual contingent pay, limiting our ability to measure behavioral responses to wage reductions imposed by AI management. Unfamiliar workplace : Unlike real workers, who have a sense of their own competence, experimental participants are often assigned unfamiliar tasks that leave them without meaningful expectations or benchmarks against which to interpret AI evaluations ( Barclay, Bashshur, and Fortin 2017 ; Critcher and Dunning 2009 ; Sitzmann et al. 2010 ) . Simulated AI : Many vignette studies and experiments rely on pretended AI evaluations, which elicit responses to the idea of AI rather than to actual machine behavior; and the idea of AI can be more aversive than its real-world experience ( Dong, Bonnefon, and Rahwan 2024 ; Jakesch, Hancock, and Naaman 2023 ; Tong et al. 2021 ) . To overcome these challenges and isolate the behavioral consequences of AI-driven wage management, we developed a controlled yet ecologically rich experimental environment: the Iron Pickaxe Factory, a bespoke Minecraft game server. Minecraft is a widely adopted platform for training AI agents to imitate humans, navigate physical environments, and collaborate with human partners ( Amresh, Cooke, and Fouse 2023 ; Guss and et al. 2021 ; Hafner et al. 2025 ) . Its open-ended, programmable structure has also made it increasingly valuable for behavioral research, offering a flexible environment to study real-world cognition and behavior under controlled conditions ( Bendell et al. 2024 ; Peters, Kyngdon, and Stillwell 2021 ; Simon and et al. 2022 ) . In our customized Minecraft workplace, participants repeatedly attempt to craft an iron pickaxe within a structured time window of 10 minutes, receiving a managerial evaluation and contingent wage after each attempt. After each evaluation, they report their fairness perceptions; and before each new attempt, they report their motivational state. This experimental setup systematically reconstructs the key features of real-world AI management that laboratory studies struggle to capture. Real-time monitoring : Workers are supervised by a visible manager avatar throughout task execution (Fig. 1), while the system captures fine-grained behavioral data, including movement patterns, mining actions, item acquisition, and time-to-completion metrics. Autonomy in task execution : The iron pickaxe task allows multiple strategies for achieving the production goal, granting participants meaningful discretion in how they approach their work. Dynamic motivational feedback loops : Workers engage in repeated production cycles, each followed by a performance evaluation and contingent compensation, allowing us to track motivational dynamics over time. Evaluation-based wages : Workers’ compensation is directly tied to evaluated performance, replicating the economic pressures of AI-managed labor and allowing us to observe behavioral responses to wage reductions imposed by AI versus human managers. Familiar workplace : Workers are Minecraft players reporting different levels of self-assessed skills, reflecting natural variation in worker ability and ensuring that they have meaningful internal benchmarks against which to interpret managerial evaluations. Genuine AI management : Our experiment

Read the complete text