Anisotropic electron damping and energy gap in Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O 8+δ
Jiemin Li, Yanhong Gu, Takemi Yamada, Zebin Wu, Genda Gu, Tonica Valla, Ilya Drozdov, Ivan Božović, Mark P. M. Dean, Takami Tohyama, Jonathan Pelliciari, Valentina Bisogni · 2025
Read Anisotropic electron damping and energy gap in Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O 8+δ by Jiemin Li, Yanhong Gu, Takemi Yamada, Zebin Wu, Genda Gu, Tonica Valla, Ilya Drozdov, Ivan Božović, Mark P. M. Dean, Takami Tohyama, Jonathan Pelliciari, Valentina Bisogni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-21687.txt.
Introduction
Jiemin Li and a large team of co-authors report a 2025 study of a copper oxide material that conducts without resistance at low temperature. In such materials, electrons interact so strongly that their bands blur. The blur depends on direction. The team asked whether it leaves a clear mark in a different kind of measurement, based on X-ray scattering.
In the normal state, the spectra showed signals down to near zero energy. In the cold conducting state, signal below a set energy was suppressed, with no boost at higher energies. A model that left out the direction based blurring could not match the data, while one that included it could. The authors say this effect must be included when key values, such as the size of the energy gap, are drawn from such data.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Jiemin Li, Yanhong Gu, Takemi Yamada, Zebin Wu, Genda Gu, Tonica Valla, Ilya Drozdov, Ivan Božović, Mark P. M. Dean, Takami Tohyama, Jonathan Pelliciari, Valentina Bisogni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 26 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-21687
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Anisotropic electron damping and energy gap in Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O 8+δ Jiemin Li, Yanhong Gu, Takemi Yamada, Zebin Wu, Genda Gu, Tonica Valla, Ilya Drozdov, Ivan Božović, Mark P. M. Dean, Takami Tohyama, Jonathan Pelliciari, Valentina Bisogni Abstract The many body electron-electron interaction in cuprates causes the broadening of the electronic bands in k -space, leading to a deviation from the standard Fermi liquid. While a k -dependent anisotropic electronic scattering ( k -DAES) has been assessed by photoemission, its fingerprint in Q -space has been scarcely considered. Here, we explore the Q -dependent electron dynamics in optimally doped Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O 8+δ through the evolution of low-energy charge excitations as measured by resonant inelastic x–ray scattering (RIXS). In the normal state, the RIXS spectra display a continuum of excitations down to 0 meV, while the superconducting state features a spectral weight suppression below 80 meV without any enhancement at higher energies. To interpret the energy and Q -evolution of our data, we introduce a phenomenological expression of the charge susceptibility by including the k -DAES. We show that only the charge susceptibility with k -DAES captures the RIXS data, highlighting the importance of k -DAES when describing the Q -dependence of charge excitations from 0 to few eV scale. Furthermore, we also find that the inclusion of k -DAES is essential when quantitative parameters such as the electronic energy gap are extracted from RIXS data. Introduction. —In Bardeen–Cooper–Schrieffer theory, the electron-phonon coupling generates an effective attractive interaction between two electrons to form the so-called Cooper pairs, whose condensation at low-temperature gives rise to superconductivity Bardeen et al. 1957 . This concept however fails to account for unconventional superconductivity in cuprates Bednorz and Müller 1986 that appears at a higher temperature than what the electron-phonon coupling can support Nagamatsu et al. 2001 . Instead, strong electron-electron ( el-el ) interaction features in these unusual cases and is believed to play a predominant role for the formation of Cooper pairs Keimer et al. 2015 . In addition, it has also been argued that the el-el interaction is at the root of multiple exotic phases of cuprates, such as magnetism, charge/spin density waves, pseudogap, and strange metal behaviors Keimer et al. 2015 . Therefore, the understanding of el-el interaction is crucial to achieve a physical understanding of these phenomena and of unconventional superconductivity. Generally, such strong el-el interaction can significantly alter the electron dynamics in cuprates, leading to the deviation from a Fermi liquid. Indeed, Raman scattering or infrared reflectivity experiments revealed a strong electron damping, i.e. an anomalous scattering rate that displays a linear variation with temperature and electron energy Thomas et al. 1988 ; Collins et al. 1989 ; Božović et al. 1991 ; Cooper et al. 1992 ; Abrahams and Varma 2000 and that is suppressed in the superconducting (SC) state Bonn et al. 1992 ; Rieck et al. 1995 . These unusual behaviors could be partially described by the theory of “marginal Fermi liquids” Varma et al. 1989 , which is however uncapable of explaining the anisotropy of the scattering rate Abdel-Jawad et al. 2006 ; Fang et al. 2022 in k space, as reported by the angle-resolved photo-emission spectroscopy (ARPES) Valla et al. 1999 ; Valla et al. 2000 ; Kaminski et al. 2005 ; Chang et al. 2013 . While the origin of the k -dependent anisotropic electron scattering ( k -DAES) is still the subject of debate, two contributions to the anomalous electron scattering in cuprates seem clear: (1) anisotropic elastic scattering possibly associated with impurity scattering Varma and Abrahams 2001 ; Abrahams and Varma 2000 or the pseudogap Kaminski et al. 2005 ; (2) inelastic part arising from the spin-fluctuation scattering Norman 1990 ; Millis 1992 ; Dahm et al. 2005 . Figure 1: Sketch of particle-hole excitations across the energy gap in k -space and the calculation of charge susceptibility \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) . (a) A particle-hole excitation at Q = k - k {}^{{}^{\prime}} , stemming from electron hopping from the lower band to the upper one along the nodal- (Q,Q) direction. The bottom plane outlines a quadrant of the Brillioun zone of cuprates. The shaded arc on the bottom plane represents a simplified Fermi surface of cuprates, while the width denotes the anisotropy of \Gamma^{\mathrm{SC}}_{\textit{{Q}},\textit{{k}}}(\omega) in the antinodal (Cu-O) region. The black dashed line indicates the nodal (diagonal Cu-Cu) direction. (b) Representation of the anisotropic k -dependence of \Gamma^{\mathrm{SC}}_{\textit{{Q}},\textit{{k}}}(\omega) considered in the calculation of Im \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) in the SC state. Eight Gaussian curves (indicated by red circles) centered at anti-nodal points are used to model the anisotropic momentum dependence. (c, d) Im \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) along nodal and anti-nodal directions in the SC state, without (c) and with (d) the anisotropic k -dependence in \Gamma^{\mathrm{SC}}_{\textit{{Q}},\textit{{k}}}(\omega) . Im \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) in (d) was obtained for \Gamma^{\mathrm{SC}}_{\textit{{Q}},\textit{{k}}}(\omega) derived from A =6 and \sigma =0.45 \pi , see Eq. 1. (e) Im \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) in the normal state. (f) Im \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) at (0.02, 0.02). The teal and blue dashed lines are the spectral difference between the normal and SC states without and with the k -DAES respectively. The black dashed lines in (c, d, e, f) indicate the electronic energy gap size ( \sim 30 meV) of nearly optimally dopped Bi2212. Nonetheless, the impact of k -DAES on the cuprate electron dynamics has been scarcely discussed in Q space Mitrano et al. 2018 ; Husain et al. 2019 . It is however important to experimentally address this point to refine models of the electron response at finite Q . Here, we examine the electron dynamics of optimally doped Bi 2 Sr 2 CaCu 2 O 8+δ (Bi2212) using resonant inelastic x-ray scattering (RIXS), a momentum resolved two-particle probe Ament et al. 2011 ; Mitrano et al. 2024 . We study the low-energy charge excitations across the electronic energy gap of Bi2212 using high-resolution RIXS at the Cu L_{3} -edge, below and above T_{c} . In the normal (N) state, we observe a continuum of excitations down to \sim 0 meV. In the SC state, a spectral suppression emerges up to 80 meV and displays a momentum dependence, consistent with the opening of the electronic energy gap. However, no spectral weight enhancement manifests at higher energies ( \gtrsim 80 meV), contradicting expectations based on spectral weight conservation. To explain our observations, we model the RIXS charge response in the SC state with the charge susceptibility formulated as a function of k -DAES. We found that only charge susceptibility including k -DAES captures the data and their momentum dependence. Our results prove that besides capturing the opening of the electronic energy gap Marra et al. 2013 ; Suzuki et al. 2018 ; Merzoni et al. 2024 , we can extract the electron dynamics including the damping in reciprocal space. This aspect therefore needs to be accounted for when quantifying the magnitude of the electronic energy gap. To start, we need to formulate a calculation of the charge susceptibility \chi_{c}(\textit{{Q}},\omega) . Distinct from single-particle probes, such as ARPES, RIXS is a two-photon process, requiring the consideration of both occupied and unoccupied bands to describe the created particle-hole excitations. Figure 1 (a) depicts a specific particle-hole