Ensembles in M-theory and Holography
Friðrik Freyr Gautason, Jesse van Muiden · 2025
Read Ensembles in M-theory and Holography by Friðrik Freyr Gautason, Jesse van Muiden (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-21633.txt.
Introduction
Fridrik Freyr Gautason and Jesse van Muiden write on ensembles in M-theory and holography, in a paper from 2025. M-theory is a framework that unifies string theories of gravity and matter. Its counting rules depend on which background fields are held fixed during a calculation. The authors argue that this choice of ensemble is not a mere detail.
They link the fixed fields to couplings on the worldvolume of the M2-brane, a basic object in the theory. One natural choice fixes the value of the three-form field of M-theory. In one holographic setup, that choice matches averages over many field theories, not a single one at fixed rank. In a second setup, it matches a single theory after all. Many brane counts take a simple form under this choice, which hints the results may be exact at one loop.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Friðrik Freyr Gautason, Jesse van Muiden |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 56 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-21633
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Ensembles in M-theory and Holography Friðrik Freyr Gautason, Jesse van Muiden Abstract We discuss that the string/M-theory partition function requires a choice of ensembles, depending on which background fields are held fixed. The background fields correspond to worldvolume couplings in the effective action approach to the superstring, which we extrapolate to the M2-brane. One natural ensemble in this context, which we call the M2-ensemble, corresponds to fixing the value of the M-theory three-form potential. In holographic setups the choice of ensemble is important when comparing to observables in the dual field theory. Indeed, in AdS 4 holography the M2-ensemble does not map gravitational observables directly to field theory observables at a fixed rank N N , but rather to observables in the grand canonical ensemble. We remark that many M2-brane partition functions take a simple form in this ensemble hinting at one-loop exactness. We also discuss how in AdS 7 holography, the M2-ensemble does correspond to the canonical ensemble in the field theory, i.e. the (2,0) theory at fixed rank N N . 1 Introduction and motivation In the mid 1980s Fradkin and Tseytlin [ 1 , 2 , 3 ] proposed a method to determine the generating functional of string scattering amplitudes via the path integral and a genus sum of a fundamental string in an arbitrary background specified by a metric, dilaton, and gauge potentials. In this formulation, the target space fields are viewed as sources to which the worldsheet sigma model couples and which can be used to take derivatives to obtain observables. The result is an object \mathcal{Z}_{\text{string}}[g,B,\Phi,C] that can be used to generate not only the beta functions of the string (which must vanish on-shell) but also scattering amplitudes. This generating functional is notoriously difficult to evaluate in full generality and Fradkin and Tseytlin resorted to using a derivative expansion around a genus 0 pointlike string. Focusing on the critical type II superstring, the pointlike string has vanishing on-shell action and ten bosonic zero-modes corresponding to the center-of-mass location of the string in target space. Since translation invariance is broken by the sources, the zero-mode integral is non-trivial. Furthermore, the generating functional has to be carefully regularized to obtain a sensible result [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Assuming that this procedure is well-defined, target-space {\cal N}=2 supersymmetry fixes the form of the answer to leading order to be proportional to one of the two ten-dimensional type II supergravity actions \mathcal{Z}_{\text{string}}[g,B,\Phi,C]=-S_{\text{sugra}}[g,B,\Phi,C]+\cdots\,. (1) Here the ellipses denote perturbative corrections in \ell_{s} and g_{s} which so far have not been determined. Beyond perturbative corrections to this formula, we also expect non-perturbative corrections arising from string saddles with finite classical action. Including these ‘worldsheet instanton’ corrections, the string partition function can be written as [ 7 ] \mathcal{Z}_{\text{string}}\approx-S_{\text{sugra}}+\sum\limits_{\text{instantons}}\mathrm{e}^{-S_{\text{cl}}}Z_{\text{1-loop}}\,, (2) where we have truncated all expansions at one loop (or two derivatives). In holography, these results gain new life as its fundamental principle identifies the string generating functional to the QFT generating functional. Since, as we have summarized, the generating functional of connected string scattering amplitudes is the partition function itself, the holographic duality involves a \log : \log Z_{\text{QFT}}=\mathcal{Z}_{\text{string}}\,. (3) This equation is meaningless without supplementing it with a dictionary that translates between sources on the QFT side and the string theory side. Another important point is that the right hand side is not well-defined in holographic backgrounds without being regularized by including suitable boundary terms. No string theory path-integral derivation of the boundary terms exists, but instead the robust method of holographic renormalization is used to regulate and renormalize the right-hand-side (see e.g. [ 8 ] ). Without a first principle derivation, we will assume that a similar definition can be made for the M2-brane generating functional \mathcal{Z}_{\text{M2}} by uplifting the corresponding type IIA generating functional. The former is consequently sourced by the background metric and three-form gauge potential A_{3} . Although this assumption of uplifting the type IIA observable seems ad hoc, recently there have been several non-trivial checks supporting it [ 9 , 10 , 11 ] . The target space is now eleven-dimensional and assuming the path-integral formulation is sensible (which is far from obvious), supersymmetry fixes the form of the leading term to be proportional to the eleven-dimensional supergravity action \mathcal{Z}_{\text{M2}}\approx-S_{\text{11D}}+\sum\limits_{\text{instantons}}\mathrm{e}^{-S_{\text{cl}}}(Z_{\text{1-loop}}+\ldots)\,, (4) where S_{\text{11D}} contains the known two-derivative eleven-dimensional action and its corrections. Up to two derivatives the former takes in Euclidean signature explicitly the form S_{\text{11D}}=\frac{-2\pi}{(2\pi\ell_{p})^{9}}\int\Big[\star\Big(R-\frac{1}{2}|G_{4}|^{2}\Big)-\frac{1}{6}A_{3}\wedge G_{4}\wedge G_{4}\Big]\, (5) where boundary terms still have to be added by hand. A point to emphasise is that the M2-brane partition function depends explicitly on the sources g and A_{3} , but importantly not A_{6} . We should therefore view the partition function as defined for fixed A_{3} (and the metric g ) but A_{6} is not fixed. It is then not surprising that the leading perturbative contribution to the partition function in ( 5 ) depends on G_{4} and not its hodge dual, G_{7} . We argue that there is a conjugate ensemble where we quantize M5-branes instead of M2-branes for which A_{6} would be fixed and A_{3} is unfixed. It is not clear to us how to define the M5-partition function from first principles but since M5-branes are charged with respect to A_{6} , it appears that the logical microscopic description of the conjugate ensemble is in terms of M5-branes. In general, we will refer to the ensemble where one fixes the value of A_{3} as the M2-brane ensemble, while the conjugate ensemble will be referred to as the M5-brane ensemble. We will also argue that in many cases one can change ensembles and therefore deduce the M5-brane partition function knowing the M2-brane partition function. Although the formalism described above, computing \mathcal{Z}_{\text{M2}} , is expected to hold for generic smooth backgrounds, we will highlight its implications in holography, i.e. in asymptotically AdS backgrounds. In particular, we will first focus on computing gravitational observables in asymptotically AdS 4 backgrounds and then move on to discuss observables in asymptotically AdS 7 and AdS 5 geometries. Let us be more specific by discussing M-theory on AdS {}_{4}\times S^{7}/\mathbf{Z}_{k} , whose holographic dual field theory is ABJM with gauge group \text{U}(N)_{k}\times\text{U}(N)_{-k} and CS-level k [ 12 ] . The background is specified in terms k and one additional parameter L/\ell_{p} which appears both in the metric and in the three-form potential. We conclude that the M2-brane partition function evaluated on this background only depends on these two parameters. The conjugate variable to L/\ell_{p} , which defines the dual gauge potential A_{6} , is the flux quantum number N . This fact can be seen by rewriting the kinetic-term of A_{3} in the leading perturbative saddle of the partition function; defining \mu\equiv L^{3}/\ell_{p}^{3} for convenience one finds that \frac{2\pi}{(2\pi\ell_{p})^{9}}\int\star|G_{4}|^{2}=\frac{2\pi}{(2\pi\ell_{p})^{9}}\int G_{4}\wedge G_{7}=\mu N\,. (6) While evaluating this integral we replaced \star G_{4} with the field strength G_{7} and used its standard flux quantisation through the seven-sphere, the explicit expression for the four-form (see eq. ( 12 ) below), and the renormalized volume of AdS 4 . Our interpretation is that the M2-brane partition function in this context should not be thought of as being in the ensemble for fixed N but rather for fixed \mu . 1