Breaking coexistence: zealotry vs. nonlinear social impact
Christopher R. Kitching, Lucía S. Ramirez, Maxi San Miguel, Tobias Galla · 2025
Read Breaking coexistence: zealotry vs. nonlinear social impact by Christopher R. Kitching, Lucía S. Ramirez, Maxi San Miguel, Tobias Galla (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-21407.txt.
Introduction
Christopher Kitching and co-authors study in 2025 how stubborn zealots and nonlinear group influence shape whether opinions reach consensus. In three classic models, finite groups always end at consensus, while endless populations can settle into lasting coexistence. They ask when a fixed bloc that never changes its mind can force full agreement on everyone else.
Strong enough zealotry drives consensus in all three models for endless populations. One model is the exception for some settings: when small groups punch above their weight, minorities resist and coexistence survives. The slope of the influence curve near zero decides local stability. Finite-group timing is also analyzed.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Christopher R. Kitching, Lucía S. Ramirez, Maxi San Miguel, Tobias Galla |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 109 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-21407
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Breaking coexistence: zealotry vs. nonlinear social impact Christopher R. Kitching, Lucía S. Ramirez, Maxi San Miguel, Tobias Galla Abstract We study how zealotry and nonlinear social impact affect consensus formation in the nonlinear voter model, evolutionary games, and the partisan voter model. In all three models, consensus is an absorbing state in finite populations, while coexistence is a possible outcome of the deterministic dynamics. We show that sufficiently strong zealotry, i.e. the presence of agents who never change state, can drive infinite populations to consensus in all three models. However, while evolutionary games and the partisan voter model permit zealotry-induced consensus for all values of their model parameters, the nonlinear voter model does not. Central to this difference is the shape of the social impact function, which quantifies how the influence of a group scales with size, and is therefore a measure of majority and minority effects. We derive general conditions relating the slope of this function at small group sizes to the local stability of consensus. Sublinear impact favours minorities and can override zealotry to prevent consensus, whereas superlinear impact promotes majorities and therefore facilitates consensus. We extend the analysis to finite populations, exploring the time-to-consensus, and the shape of quasi-stationary distributions. Preprint: AIP/123-QED We consider several individual-based models of opinion dynamics and simple two-player games. These models share the property of either allowing indefinite coexistence of opinions (or strategies) or converging to a consensus state. Zealotry, that is, the presence of agents who never change their state, is known to promote consensus, whereas certain types of nonlinear interactions tend to favour coexistence. In this paper, we study the balance between these two opposing effects, focusing on nonlinear social impact: how the influence of a group of agents depends on the group’s size. We find that sublinear social impact can override the effects of zealotry and prevent consensus formation. This result is particularly relevant, as sublinear impact has been observed in experiments with human participants. I Introduction A system is considered ‘complex’ when it consists of many interacting entities which give rise to system-wide emergent behaviour that cannot be understood by examining its constituents in isolation. Examples span physics, biology, and other sciences Anderson (1972) ; May (1972) ; Simon (1962) ; Mitchell (2009) ; Strogatz (2001) ; Barabási and Albert (1999) , and statistical physics has played a key role in understanding these phenomena Bak and Paczuski (1995) ; Castellano, Fortunato, and Loreto (2009) ; Mezard and Montanari (2009) ; Sornette (2006) . Complex dynamics arise in opinion formation in social (or socio-technical) systems and population evolution in game theory Nowak (2006) ; Hofbauer and Sigmund (2003) ; Castellano, Fortunato, and Loreto (2009) . Individual-based stochastic models commonly used in these two areas to describe finite populations are closely related to one another. For example, the celebrated voter model Clifford and Sudbury (1973) ; Liggett (1994) ; Redner (2019) can be seen as the limit of neutral selection of certain evolutionary processes Fotouhi et al. (2019) ; Allen et al. (2012) ; Shakarian, Roos, and Johnson (2012) . The phenomena studied in both fields also mirror each other. In opinion dynamics, one focus is on the emergence of consensus, i.e. situations in which all agents share the same opinion. In evolutionary models, the analogue is a ‘monomorphic’ state, where all individuals are of the same type or species, or in which all involved players use the same strategy. Hence, the distinction between consensus and diversity in opinion dynamics parallels fixation and coexistence in evolutionary systems. Zealots, i.e. agents who do not change state, are known to affect outcomes in both domains Galam (1997) ; Galam and Jacobs (2007) ; Mobilia (2015) ; Masuda (2012) ; Nakajima and Masuda (2015) ; Khalil, San Miguel, and Toral (2018) . In the standard voter model without zealots, the two opinion states are symmetric, and consensus on either is equally likely. A single zealot breaks this symmetry, ensuring consensus in finite populations at the state represented by the zealot. Zealots can also influence infinite populations Mobilia (2003) , and similar effects are observed in network co-ordination games with extremists Kearns et al. (2009) , and in the two-opinion naming game with committed minorities Xie et al. (2011) . Generally, one-sided zealotry breaks symmetry, while mixed zealotry promotes coexistence Mobilia, Petersen, and Redner (2007) ; Yildiz et al. (2013) ; Acemoğlu et al. (2012) . For a further review of zealotry in opinion dynamics, see Sec. 2.1 of Ref. Cao et al. (2024) . In this paper, we ask if and when zealotry can bring about consensus in different models of opinion dynamics and evolutionary games. We consider three settings: the nonlinear voter model Castellano, Muñoz, and Pastor-Satorras (2009) ; Ramirez et al. (2024) ; Schweitzer and Behera (2009) ; Min and San Miguel (2017) , two-player two-strategy evolutionary games Nowak (2006) ; Traulsen and Hauert (2009) , and the so-called partisan voter model Masuda, Gibert, and Redner (2010) ; Masuda and Redner (2011) ; Llabrés, San Miguel, and Toral (2023) . In all three models, agents can be in one of two discrete states, and in the absence of zealots consensus states are absorbing; that is, once such a state is reached, no further dynamics can occur. Our focus is on conditions under which zealotry and nonlinear interactions shift a system from coexistence to consensus by breaking the symmetry between states. We approach this through deterministic rate equations for infinite populations and also by investigating finite-size effects: time-to-consensus (or fixation) and the shape of quasi-stationary distribution that describes the system at long times but before absorption. For each of these we establish the similarities and differences across the three models. A key finding is that the local stability of consensus states in the deterministic rate equations is, among other things, determined by ‘social impact’ Latané (1981) . This describes the influence a group of agents has on other agents. The strength of this influence can be a nonlinear function of the size of the group of influencers. We quantify this using a ‘social impact function’, showing that sublinear impact destabilises consensus, while superlinear impact can stabilise it. Our paper is organised as follows: In Sec. II we describe the general framework of populations with susceptible agents and zealots. Section III defines the models: the (linear and nonlinear) voter models, simple evolutionary games, and the partisan voter model, along with their corresponding rate equations. In Sec. IV , we determine the fixed points of these rate equations in the presence of zealots and analyse their stability. This provides a comprehensive study of the effects of zealotry in finite populations. We establish common behaviour across the three models, in particular we show that show that zealotry above a model-dependent critical magnitude can enforce consensus in many circumstances. In Sec. V we explore the interplay of nonlinearity and zealotry in more detail, and we discuss the importance of the social impact function. In particular we derive conditions on this function for the local stability of consensus states, and investigate how sublinear and superlinear impact affect this stability. In Sec. VI , we turn to finite populations, characterising the mean time-to-consensus or fixation in opinion dynamics