Euclidean wormholes stability analysis revisited
Donald Marolf, Bruno Missoni · 2025
Read Euclidean wormholes stability analysis revisited by Donald Marolf, Bruno Missoni (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-21118.txt.
Introduction
Donald Marolf and Bruno Missoni revisit the soundness of a class of space-time tunnels in a 2025 paper. Past checks of flat-space tunnels with a twist field found wild swings in one mode set. Those swings cast doubt on the tunnels' hold under small shakes.
The wild swings prove to be a quirk of one way of solving the bound rules, the team shows. A full fix gives calm values, so the modes join the check. Their action stays on the safe side, which leaves past soundness claims intact, and a lean proof route skips heavy counts.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Donald Marolf, Bruno Missoni |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 58 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-21118
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Euclidean wormholes stability analysis revisited Donald Marolf, Bruno Missoni Abstract Previous studies of linearized stability of asymptotically flat Euclidean axion wormholes found that symmetric modes suffered from divergences. We show that such divergences were an artifact of a particular way of solving the constraints, and that a full treatment leads to finite actions for such modes. The modes must thus be included in a stability analysis. However, since the action for these modes turns out to be positive, this turns out not to affect previous statements about stability of axion wormholes. We also introduce a technique that allows us to show this positivity at a pseudo-analytic level that avoids heavy numerics. Our techniques should be useful to future studies of stabilities of other wormholes as well. 1 Introduction Wormholes have caught the interest of a large number of researchers in theoretical physics ever since the early days of Euclidean semi-classical gravity [ 1 , 2 ] . Axion wormholes represent the model which has been studied in great depth, due to their natural embedding in string theory [ 2 , 3 ] (though see also e.g [ 4 ] for other top-down analyses.). Axions are pseudoscalars which have a shift symmetry, which implies that they can be described in the dual two-form formulation with a three-form field strength. In Euclidean signature this leads to a negative kinetic term in the scalar description, which is required to hold the wormhole throat open. In this simplistic setup, wormholes are supported by the axion-charge flux and they connect two flat spaces. However, more general solutions have also been studied, such as those including dilatons [ 5 , 6 ] (also with dilatons having a mass [ 7 , 8 ] ) and those with non-zero cosmological constant [ 9 , 10 ] . Being a particular example of gravitational instantons, wormholes should affect the vacuum significantly and in fact have many phenomenological applications in particle physics and cosmology (nicely summarized in [ 11 ] ). They also lead to many puzzles, the most prominent one being the factorization puzzle in holography [ 12 , 5 ] . The puzzles can be resolved if the wormholes are declared to be irrelevant saddles in the gravitational path integral. This requires a classification of saddles a la Coleman: the Euclidean path integral is performed in the saddle-point approximation \int\mathcal{D}g\mathcal{D}\phi\ e^{-S_{E}[g,\phi]}\approx\sum_{\text{saddles}}\frac{1}{\sqrt{\det\hat{M}}}e^{-S_{E}[g_{0},\phi_{0}]}, (1.1) where g_{0},\phi_{0} represent the metric and matter fields evaluated at the saddle-point, and \hat{M} is the operator of quadratic fluctuations 1 1 1 See e.g. [ 13 , 14 ] for discussion of ambiguities in the definition of \hat{M} and their possible effects. . Coleman [ 15 , 16 ] argued that the number of negative modes determines the meaning of the instanton. Namely, if there are no negative modes in the spectrum of \hat{M} the instanton is a meaningful contribution to the path integral (e.g. it lifts the vacuum degeneracy as double-well instantons in quantum mechanics [ 16 ] ). If there is a single negative mode, it describes a tunnelling effect 2 2 2 A notable example being the false vacuum decay in QFT [ 17 , 18 ] , with the effects of gravitation included in [ 19 ] . . Multiple negative modes imply that the saddle in question is not an actual minima of the action, it does not represent a physically meaningful contribution to the path integral and it is ”unstable”. While this kind of ”axion wormhole stability analysis” has a long and controversial history [ 20 , 21 , 22 ] , recent works [ 23 , 24 , 25 ] using a variety of approaches 3 3 3 Ref. [ 24 ] used the two-form formulation of axion while [ 23 ] used the pseudoscalar formulation to study axion-dilaton wormholes in the homogeneous sector of dilaton fluctuations. The work of [ 25 ] considered all modes of axion-dilaton wormholes in both formulations of axions. have all found that asymptotically flat axion wormholes have no negative modes. However, [ 24 , 25 ] seem to indicate that even eigenfunctions should be excluded from the spectrum of the quadratic operator \hat{M} . In fact, their final quadratic action takes the following form \delta^{2}S_{E}=\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\textrm{d}r\left[\mathrm{A}\dot{R}^{2}+\mathrm{B}\dot{R}R+\mathrm{C}R^{2}\right], (1.2) where r is the Euclidean time, R is the gauge-invariant variable comprised out of axion and metric fluctuations and \mathrm{A},\mathrm{B} and \mathrm{C} are some functions of the background. It turns out that B and C are singular near r=0 , in fact B\sim 1/r and C\sim 1/r^{2} . However, when they had rewritten the action in terms of the quadratic operator \hat{M} \delta^{2}S_{E}=\frac{1}{2}\int_{-\infty}^{\infty}\textrm{d}rR\hat{M}R+\text{boundary terms}, (1.3) they found that singularities are removed. The authors of the aforementioned papers argued that even eigenfunctions can be found in the spectrum of \hat{M} , but that they give an infinite contribution when inserted back into ( 1.2 ) and thus should be excluded from the spectrum. However, the absence of divergent contributions in ( 1.3 ) suggests that it may be useful to treat the singularities in ( 1.2 ) with more care. This is also suggested by the fact that similar singularities that arise in a closely related approach to studying wormholes turn out to cancel when treated properly [ 26 ] . In this paper we resolve the issue of singularities in two different ways. To explain these resolutions, let us recall that gravitational degrees of freedom will generally lead to constraints. One can then use these constraints to perform the path integral over some degrees of freedom, effectively imposing the constraints. A common method of analyzing the stability of saddles follows [ 27 , 28 , 29 ] in choosing a complex contour of integration that allows this procedure and then integrating the remaining (constrained) degrees of freedom over a real Euclidean contour 4 4 4 See, however, comments in [ 30 ] . . We will show that singularities found in [ 24 , 25 ] were an artifact of the choice of variables used to solve the constraints in [ 24 , 25 ] and, in particular, that making a different choice leads directly to ( 1.3 ) without encountering singularities along the way. Since there are no singularities, there is no reason to exclude even eigenfunctions from the spectrum. When we include the dilaton, our new choice seems to present difficulties for writing the resulting action in a gauge-invariant form. In this way, it seems that the choice made in [ 25 ] and the appearance of singularities may be inevitable. We therefore propose a way of treating these singularities by allowing for excursions in the complex r -plane, using a contour which is partly an infinitesimal semi-circle of infinitesimal radius \epsilon going around the singularity. The contribution of the singularity to the integral is then accounted for as in the spirit of the famous identity in complex analysis [ 31 ] \lim_{\epsilon\rightarrow 0}\frac{1}{r+i\epsilon}=\mathcal{P}\left(\frac{1}{r}\right)-i\pi\delta(r), (1.4) where \mathcal{P} denotes the Cauchy principal value of the integral. We see that the singularities contribute with a \delta -function which has an imaginary coefficient. One could then ask a natural question: what is the physical meaning of the imaginary part introduced by the singularities? To understand this,