Articulatory strategy in vowel production as a basis for speaker discrimination

Justin J. H, Patrycja, Sam · 2025

Read Articulatory strategy in vowel production as a basis for speaker discrimination by Justin J. H, Patrycja, Sam (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-20995.txt.

Introduction

Justin Lo, Patrycja Strycharczuk, and Sam Kirkham test whether tongue habits can identify speakers in a paper from two thousand twenty-five. People move their tongues in personal ways, though anatomy limits the range. The team asked if those personal patterns are strong enough for speaker discrimination.

Tongue shape data came from forty English speakers in the North West of England. Shape features were weighed in a likelihood-ratio frame used in forensic work. Tongue size alone carried the most speaker signal. Front-of-tongue shape beat back-of-tongue shape. Combined shape-only features could rival size-plus-shape, as long as the features did not rise and fall together within speakers.

Catalog record

CREATORJustin J. H, Patrycja, Sam
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE23 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-20995

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Articulatory strategy in vowel production as a basis for speaker discrimination Justin J. H, Patrycja, Sam Abstract The way speakers articulate is well known to be variable across individuals while at the same time subject to anatomical and biomechanical constraints. In this study, we ask whether articulatory strategy in vowel production can be sufficiently speaker-specific to form the basis for speaker discrimination. We conducted Generalised Procrustes Analyses of tongue shape data from 40 English speakers from the North West of England, and assessed the speaker-discriminatory potential of orthogonal tongue shape features within the framework of likelihood ratios. Tongue size emerged as the individual dimension with the strongest discriminatory power, while tongue shape variation in the more anterior part of the tongue generally outperformed tongue shape variation in the posterior part. When considered in combination, shape-only information may offer comparable levels of speaker specificity to size-and-shape information, but only when features do not exhibit speaker-level co-variation. Lo Strycharczuk Kirkham Lancaster UniversityUnited Kingdom University of ManchesterUnited Kingdom keywords tongue shape, vowels, ultrasound, articulation, individuality, speaker discrimination † † email: {j.h.lo—s.kirkham}@lancaster.ac.uk, [email protected] 1 Introduction Articulatory strategy is characterised by individual variation, such that different speakers may perform different articulatory movements to achieve similar acoustic outputs [ 1 , 2 ] . Such variation arises as a result of an interplay between speaker anatomy and speaker choice. Differences in the exact shape of every individual’s vocal tract might produce acoustic differences in and of themselves, and may also influence the speaker to produce a specific articulatory behaviour in order to achieve a specific acoustic output [ 3 ] . For example, palate morphology can systematically affect the articulatory strategy for the production of both vocalic and consonantal phonemes [ 4 , 5 , 6 ] . Anatomical factors, however, are not deterministic, as evidenced, for instance, by articulatory differences between monozygotic twins [ 7 ] . Speakers may choose one strategy over another as a result of their individual language experience, which is an additional source of articulatory variation. Furthermore, reliance on a particular strategy is potentially systematic within speaker, due to the influence of a wider articulatory setting [ 8 ] , and manifesting as reliance on particular motor routines in speech production that is characteristic of an individual. At the same time, variation in articulatory strategy is constrained by the broad similarities in the shape of the human vocal tract, by articulation–acoustics relationships, and by biomechanical constraints on articulatory movement, such that key aspects of articulation can be captured using a limited number of parameters [ 1 , 9 , 10 , 11 ] . Furthermore, articulatory setting may attain higher-level regularity through social processes, such that members of the same groups converge on a similar set of articulatory behaviours [ 12 , 13 ] . The tension between multiple sources of individuality in articulatory strategy and the regularising factors raises the question of whether articulatory strategy is in fact speaker-specific. Can individual speakers be discriminated based on the characteristics of the vocal tract postures they employ to produce contrasts in speech? Establishing the individuality of such differences could contribute to the explanations of the phonetic sources of individuality in human speech. To this end, we investigate whether tongue shape features in vowel production can be the basis of successful speaker discrimination. Vowels have long been of considerable interest to forensic phoneticians for their potential as speaker discriminants [ 14 ] , with long-term distributions of formants (LTFDs) in particular offering the capacity to reflect both individual physiology and articulatory habit [ 15 ] . We take a similar approach to examine articulation of the whole vowel space, with the aim of inquiring into variability and individuality in broad articulatory tendencies. In a larger perspective, acoustic models of vowels going back to [ 16 ] and [ 17 ] provide a framework for linking individuality in production with individuality in acoustics. Due to the nature of our data, which come from ultrasound tongue imaging, we focus on the tongue. Ultrasound does not capture direct information about jaw and lip displacement and, as such, this approach offers only a partial view of articulation, yet it provides detailed information on tongue movement, which is a crucial component in vowel production. Our study aims to address the following research questions: 1. Do tongue shape features used in vowel production contain speaker-specific information? 2. Which tongue shape features are the most informative for speaker discrimination and can therefore be considered individual? We apply the framework of likelihood ratios (LRs) to assess speaker specificity. A modern standard in forensic voice comparison, LRs are used to evaluate the strength of voice evidence under competing same- and different-speaker hypotheses. Similarities of features between voice samples are thus considered in the light of their typicality within the relevant population. While articulatory information is not directly accessible in forensic casework, LR-based testing provides a common framework for the speaker-discriminatory potential of articulatory features to be compared with their acoustic counterparts. 2 Tongue size & shape features 2.1 Ultrasound tongue imaging data Our study includes data from 40 speakers of English from the North West of England (Greater Manchester and Lancashire). Midsagittal ultrasound tongue imaging data were collected from these speakers while they produced a full set of stressed vowel phonemes in a fixed segmental environment (/bV/ and /bVd/, e.g., bee, bead, bar, bard ). Note that Northern English is typically non-rhotic and has no \textipa /U/– \textipa /2/ split. The data were collected using the EchoB system (10 speakers) and the Telemed Micro ultrasound speech system (30 speakers) from Articulate Instruments Ltd. The sampling rate of the ultrasound system ranged between 59.5 and 101 frames per second (median = 81.3 fps). Headset stabilisation was used to minimise probe movement. Typically 4–6 repetitions of the test stimuli were obtained from each speaker. The speakers read the items from a screen, embedded within a carrier phrase, and were instructed to speak as naturally as possible. The study received ethical approval from The University of Manchester and Lancaster University. The ultrasound data were processed using DeepLabCut [ 18 ] , as implemented within Articulate Assistant Advanced, version 2.20 [ 19 ] . DeepLabCut uses the pre-trained unidirectional MobileNet1.0 model, version 1.1.0, to automatically label 11 points corresponding to key anatomical landmarks on the midsagittal tongue contour, which were exported as Cartesian coordinates (in \unit \milli \metre ) and rotated on the occlusal plane. For the purpose of the current paper, we focus on the data corresponding to the acoustic midpoint of the vowel. To remove erroneous landmark identification by DeepLabCut, we calculated the median coordinates of each landmark for every speaker, then excluded trials with any landmarks over 3.5 median absolute deviations away by Euclidean distance from the speaker’s median landmarks. 4.5% of trials were removed as a result, leaving 10,407 trials remaining for analysis. 2.2 Shape analysis While landmark coordinates hold information about the configuration of the tongue, they are susceptible to translational and rotational effects introduced by variation in probe placement and standardisation with reference to each speaker’s own occlusal plane. Such methodological influences have to be factored out from the data, in order to isolate lingual anatomy and articulatory behaviour as

Read the complete text