Strong coupling and instabilities in singularity-free inflation from an infinite sum of curvature corrections
Shinji Tsujikawa · 2025
Read Strong coupling and instabilities in singularity-free inflation from an infinite sum of curvature corrections by Shinji Tsujikawa (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-20586.txt.
Introduction
Shinji Tsujikawa, writing alone, offers a 2025 paper testing a theory of cosmic inflation that avoids the Big Bang singularity. The theory sums an endless tower of curvature corrections and rescales the metric, which lands it inside a known family of scalar-field theories. It allows an inflation phase where expansion tracks the scalar field's motion exactly.
Tsujikawa shows that this neat solution hides a flaw: the kinetic term for small ripples vanishes at all times. With that term gone, larger ripples cannot be controlled, from the start of inflation onward. Ripples in space itself also tend to grow unstable during the phase. The flaws persist under nearby starting conditions, which weakens the theory's promise.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Shinji Tsujikawa |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 64 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-20586
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Strong coupling and instabilities in singularity-free inflation from an infinite sum of curvature corrections Preprint: WUCG-25-06 Shinji Tsujikawa Abstract Four-dimensional gravitational theories derived from an infinite sum of Lovelock curvature invariants, combined with a conformal rescaling of the metric, are equivalent to a subclass of shift-symmetric Horndeski theories that possess a single scalar degree of freedom. Under the assumption of a homogeneous and isotropic cosmological background, the theory admits an inflationary solution that replaces the Big Bang singularity. This can be achieved by a solution where the Hubble expansion rate H H is equal to the time derivative of the scalar field ϕ ˙ \dot{\phi} . We show that the solution H = ϕ ˙ H=\dot{\phi} suffers from a strong coupling problem, characterized by the vanishing kinetic term of linear scalar perturbations at all times. Consequently, nonlinear scalar perturbations remain uncontrolled from the onset of inflation throughout the subsequent cosmological evolution. Moreover, tensor perturbations are generally subject to Laplacian instabilities during inflation. This instability in the tensor sector also persists under background initial conditions where H ≠ ϕ ˙ H\neq\dot{\phi} . In the latter case, both the coefficient of the kinetic term for scalar perturbations and the scalar sound speed diverge at the onset of inflation. Thus, the dominance of inhomogeneities in this theory renders the homogeneous background solution illegitimate. I Introduction Under several physically reasonable assumptions about spacetime and matter, the appearance of singularities at the centers of black holes (BHs) or at the onset of the Big Bang is a natural consequence of General Relativity (GR) Penrose 1965 ; Hawking and Penrose 1970 . However, at very high energies, GR may be supplanted by a more fundamental theory that incorporates the quantum nature of spacetime. Since a complete theory of quantum gravity has not yet been established, another approach to addressing the singularity problem is to modify either the matter content or the gravitational sector at the classical level. Several approaches have been proposed to construct nonsingular BHs without curvature singularities at their centers by introducing specific matter sources in four-dimensional spacetime. In GR, nonlinear electrodynamics can give rise to regular BH solutions on a spherically symmetric and static background by choosing appropriate forms of the Lagrangian, {\cal L}(F) , where F is the electromagnetic field strength Ayon-Beato and Garcia 1998 ; Ayon-Beato and Garcia 2000 ; Bronnikov 2001 ; Dymnikova 2004 . However, it was recently shown that such nonsingular BHs are inevitably subject to Laplacian instabilities in the angular direction near a de Sitter center De Felice and Tsujikawa 2025a . Even in more general theories where a scalar field \phi with kinetic term X is introduced in a Lagrangian of the form {\cal L}(\phi,X,F) , no linearly stable regular BH solutions have been found if the gravitational sector is described by the Einstein-Hilbert action De Felice and Tsujikawa 2025b . In cosmology, early attempts to resolve the initial Big Bang singularity include the pre-Big Bang and Ekpyrotic scenarios Veneziano 1991 ; Gasperini and Veneziano 1993 ; Khoury et al. 2001 , in which a period of cosmological contraction is followed by an expanding phase. Both scenarios can be described within an effective four-dimensional framework of scalar-tensor theories, where the scalar degree of freedom corresponds to a dilaton field or the position of D-branes. By taking into account higher-order corrections to the tree-level action, it is possible to realize regular bouncing solutions without curvature singularities Gasperini et al. 1997 ; Brustein and Madden 1998 ; Foffa et al. 1999 ; Cartier et al. 2000 ; Tsujikawa et al. 2002 . In the effective four-dimensional description, these nonsingular models fall within subclasses of Horndeski theories–the most general scalar-tensor theories with second-order field equations of motion Horndeski 1974 ; Deffayet et al. 2011 ; Kobayashi et al. 2011 ; Charmousis et al. 2012 . Numerous other examples of bouncing Qiu et al. 2011 ; Easson et al. 2011 ; Cai et al. 2012 ; Osipov and Rubakov 2013 ; Qiu et al. 2013 ; Koehn et al. 2014 ; Ijjas and Steinhardt 2016 or genesis Creminelli et al. 2010 ; Creminelli et al. 2013 ; Hinterbichler et al. 2012 ; Nishi and Kobayashi 2015 ; Kobayashi et al. 2015 cosmological solutions have been constructed within the framework of Horndeski theories. These solutions are typically plagued by the emergence of either singularities or ghost/Laplacian instabilities at early or late stages of cosmological evolution. In Horndeski theories, there is a no-go theorem stating that, if a background solution is nonsingular during the entire cosmological evolution, the linear stability conditions for scalar and/or tensor perturbations are violated during some time interval Libanov et al. 2016 ; Kobayashi 2016 . This no-go theorem can be circumvented by considering specific models in which unstable perturbations do not grow significantly within a short timescale–either by lowering the scale of ultraviolet completion Pirtskhalava et al. 2014 or by extending Horndeski theories to more general frameworks Creminelli et al. 2006 ; Pirtskhalava et al. 2014 ; Koehn et al. 2016 ; de Rham and Melville 2017 ; Heisenberg et al. 2018 . An alternative mechanism has been proposed to suppress the coefficients of second-order actions for scalar and/or tensor perturbations in the asymptotic past Ageeva et al. 2020a ; Ageeva et al. 2020b ; Ageeva et al. 2021 . In the latter case, as long as the strong coupling energy scale is much higher than the scale associated with the classical background evolution, it is possible to construct linearly stable bouncing or genesis solutions. Recently, geometric approaches have also been proposed to address BH and Big Bang singularities by incorporating an infinite tower of higher-curvature corrections Colléaux 2020 ; Fernandes 2025a ; Fernandes 2025b ; Bueno et al. 2025a ; Bueno et al. 2025b . If we restrict ourselves to theories that yield second-order field equations of motion to avoid Ostrogradsky instabilities, the Lagrangian should consist of a sum of the n -th order Lovelock curvature invariants {\cal R}^{(n)} Lovelock 1971 ; Lovelock 1972 , which preserve diffeomorphism invariance in d -dimensional spacetime. For 2n\geq d , the n -th order contributions to the field equations vanish identically. In four dimensions ( d=4 ), the only nonvanishing contributions to the Lovelock Lagrangian are the cosmological constant term, {\cal R}^{(0)}=1 , and the Ricci scalar, {\cal R}^{(1)}=R . The Gauss-Bonnet (GB) term, R_{\rm GB}^{2} , corresponds to the second-order curvature invariant {\cal R}^{(2)}=R_{\rm GB}^{2} , which identically vanishes in four dimensions. To extract nontrivial contributions from the GB Lagrangian in four dimensions, one needs to either promote the coupling constant \hat{\alpha} to a function of some dynamical degree of freedom (like a dilaton field) or rescale it in an appropriate manner. By rescaling the coupling constant as \hat{\alpha}\to\alpha/(d-4) , one can extract nontrivial contributions of the higher-dimensional GB term in four dimensions. This theory, originally proposed by Glavan and Lin Glavan and Lin 2020 , is commonly referred to as 4-dimensional Einstein-Gauss-Bonnet (4DEGB) gravity. The original 4DEGB gravity suffers from several problems, including unphysical divergences in the perturbation equations Arrechea et al. 2021 ; Arrechea et al. 2020 and the lack of covariant field equations of a massless graviton Gürses et al. 2020 ; Gurses et al.