Probing supermassive black hole scalarization with Pulsar Timing Arrays

Clemente Smarra, Lodovico Capuano, Adrien Kuntz · 2025

Read Probing supermassive black hole scalarization with Pulsar Timing Arrays by Clemente Smarra, Lodovico Capuano, Adrien Kuntz (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-20402.txt.

Introduction

Smarra, Capuano, and Kuntz asked in twenty twenty-five whether pulsar timing arrays could detect scalarized supermassive black holes. In some gravity theories, black holes grow a scalar field coat, breaking the classic no-hair picture. A coupling length sets where deviations from Einstein's theory appear.

Collider-scale tests force that length to be small, seemingly ruling out coats on the biggest black holes. Recent work, though, finds a narrow mass window where supermassive holes could still scalarize. The authors compute how this would change the gravitational wave hum from orbiting black hole pairs, recently heard by pulsar timing arrays. Current data mildly favor a nonzero coupling. They warn that eccentric orbits or gas effects could fake the same signal, so longer observation is needed.

Catalog record

CREATORClemente Smarra, Lodovico Capuano, Adrien Kuntz
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE67 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-20402

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Probing supermassive black hole scalarization with Pulsar Timing Arrays Clemente Smarra, Lodovico Capuano, Adrien Kuntz Abstract Scalar-tensor theories with a scalar field coupled to the Gauss-Bonnet invariant can evade no-hair theorems and allow for non-trivial scalar profiles around black holes. This coupling is characterized by a length scale λ \lambda , which, in an effective field theory perspective, sets the threshold below which deviations from General Relativity become significant. LIGO/VIRGO constraints indicate λ \lambda is small, implying supermassive black holes should not scalarize. However, recent work suggests that scalarization can occur within a narrow window of masses, allowing supermassive black holes to scalarize, while leaving LIGO/VIRGO sources unaffected. We explore the impact of this scenario on the stochastic gravitational wave background recently observed by Pulsar Timing Arrays. We find that scalarization can alter the characteristic strain produced by circularly inspiralling supermassive black hole binaries and that current data shows a marginal preference for a non-zero λ \lambda . However, similar signatures could arise from astrophysical effects such as orbital eccentricity or environmental interactions, emphasizing the need for improved modeling and longer observations to discriminate among the different scenarios. I Introduction Despite the great success of General Relativity (GR) in describing gravitational phenomena [ 1 , 2 ] , there are both theoretical and phenomenological motivations to extend it into a more general framework. Among the several possible modifications of GR, scalar-tensor (ST) theories have been studied in greater detail, due to their conceptual simplicity and relevant phenomenology. All ST theories are characterized by the inclusion of at least one fundamental scalar degree of freedom (DOF) in the gravitational sector. Theories within this class provide an appealing explanation to phenomena related to the universe dynamics like dark energy or inflation [ 3 , 4 , 5 , 6 , 7 , 8 ] . On the other hand, it has been shown that most of the interaction terms admitted in (ghost-free) ST gravity do not affect black hole (BH) solutions at the background level. In other words, BHs in most ST theories are exactly the same as in GR, meaning that they are fully determined by mass, spin and, in principle, electric charge, while the additional scalar DOF provides no further “charge” to the BH. This fact is related to the well-known no-hair conjecture and has been rigorously formalized in some specific cases through no-hair theorems [ 9 , 10 , 11 , 12 , 13 ] . Nevertheless, such theorems rely on a set of crucial assumptions that cannot always be taken for granted. In particular, it has been shown that a specific interaction term, among all those leading to second-order equations of motion (EOM), can violate all known no-hair theorems, allowing for BH solutions with a non-trivial scalar profile [ 14 , 15 ] . This term is given by \lambda^{2}F(\varphi)\mathcal{G} , where \lambda is a coupling constant with dimension of a length, \varphi is the scalar field, F is an analytic function, and \mathcal{G} is the Gauss-Bonnet (GB) invariant \mathcal{G}=R_{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}R^{\mu\nu\rho\sigma}-4R_{\mu\nu}R^{\mu\nu}+R^{2}\,. (1) The interesting properties of this model include BH solutions coupled to the scalar field via the so-called scalar charge [ 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 ] , which has been used to constrain the coupling parameter \lambda using Gravitational Waves (GWs) observations from the LIGO/Virgo collaboration [ 2 ] . An interesting feature of this model is that the best constraints on \lambda actually come from the smaller BHs from which we observe the GWs. This is tied to the dimensionful nature of the coupling: the smaller the BH scale, the better the constraint on \lambda . In fact, one can view interaction terms coming with a dimensionful coupling constant \lambda , such as the scalar-GB coupling, as irrelevant operators in an effective field theory (EFT) perspective [ 19 ] . This implies that the contribution of this operator is suppressed at scales that are much larger than \lambda , whereas deviations from GR are expected to become increasingly significant at smaller scales. For this reason, it is usually assumed that supermassive BHs (SMBHs) are the same as in GR, even in presence of the scalar-GB coupling. The EFT interpretation of ST theories can also be made more concrete, as it can be shown that some specific operators arise as the low-energy limit of quantum gravity theories. This is the case for some scalar-GB couplings, that emerge in the low-energy limit of string theories [ 20 ] . However, in principle, one can suppose that high-energy effects, at a given scale, lead BHs back to the GR configuration, providing a well-delimited range of scales in which deviations from GR can occur. This happens, for instance, in a recently proposed model [ 18 ] , in which SMBHs can possess a scalar charge while lower mass BHs are the same as in GR. It is therefore reasonable to envision departures from GR in the signals that we receive from SMBHs, which, when coupled in binary systems, are considered the most likely source of the recently observed stochastic GW background (SGWB). Indeed, in recent years, Pulsar Timing Array (PTA) collaborations reported evidence for a temporally-correlated stochastic process leaving its imprint on the times of arrival (TOAs) of radio beams coming from a network of monitored millisecond pulsars in our Galaxy [ 21 , 22 , 23 , 24 , 25 ] . Furthermore, the correlations observed among different pulsars were found to be consistent with the Hellings-Downs (HD) pattern [ 26 ] , as expected for a SGWB. Although the observed data can also be explained with Early Universe processes (see e.g. Refs. [ 27 , 28 ] ), the most likely interpretation consists in the incoherent superposition of GWs emitted by a population of inspiralling SMBH binaries (SMBHBs). Assuming circular orbits — which we restrict to in the following — the characteristic strain spectrum associated with GW-driven orbital decay is expected to follow a power-law scaling as f^{-n} , with the spectral index n=2/3 , where f denotes the emitted GW frequency [ 29 , 30 ] . Eccentric orbits as well as the presence of any additional non-GW energy loss channel - such as dynamical friction or, in our case, scalar radiation- would accordingly modify the spectral index n [ 31 , 32 , 33 , 34 , 35 , 36 , 37 ] . On the other hand, the predicted angular correlation pattern is a property of the polarization of GWs at the Earth location, and will essentially coincide with the HD curve whenever - as we consider in the following - the scalar field is not coupled to matter. In this article, we hence study the modification of the SGWB predicted by an assembly of circular SMBHBs evolving under the ST theory of gravity studied in Ref. [ 18 ] . In Sec. II , we summarize the framework of black hole scalarization and lay the foundations for the analysis developed throughout the paper. In Sec. III , we review how to construct the SGWB from an astrophysical population of SMBHBs, and we compare the resulting characteristic strain in GR with that predicted by the ST theory described in Sec. II

Read the complete text