Time-like Entanglement Entropy: a top-down approach
Carlos Nunez, Dibakar Roychowdhury · 2025
Read Time-like Entanglement Entropy: a top-down approach by Carlos Nunez, Dibakar Roychowdhury (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-20388.txt.
Introduction
Carlos Nunez and Dibakar Roychowdhury studied time-like entanglement entropy in twenty twenty-five through holography. Entanglement entropy in most work links a region of space to its twin. The time-like form swaps in a stretch of time. It is a newer and trickier thing to gauge. Past work used steps that bend a realm to get it. Those steps left doubt.
The pair give a top-down rule that works in the true time-like realm. It is for field theories in higher dimensions, both conformal and confining. They derive good analytic approximations for slab-shaped regions. They state a clear stability rule for the bulk surfaces used. The new gauge proves sharp to pull out central charges of conformal theories. It makes past results stronger. In confining cases it shows odd new traits. Phase shifts are one of them.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Carlos Nunez, Dibakar Roychowdhury |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-20388
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Time-like Entanglement Entropy: a top-down approach Carlos Nunez, Dibakar Roychowdhury Abstract We investigate the concept of time-like entanglement entropy (tEE) within the framework of holography. We introduce a robust top-down prescription for computing tEE using the holographic duals to higher-dimensional QFTs—both conformal and confining—eliminating the ambiguities typically associated with analytic continuation from Euclidean to Lorentzian signatures. We present accurate analytic approximations for tEE and time-like separations in slab geometries. We establish a clear stability criterion for bulk embeddings and demonstrate that tEE serves as a powerful tool for computing CFT central charges, extending and strengthening previous results. Finally, we apply our framework to holographic confining backgrounds, revealing distinctive behaviors like phase transitions. I Introduction and General Idea Maldacena’s conjecture [ 1 ] , along with its refinements [ 2 , 3 ] , introduced the idea that space can emerge from the strongly coupled dynamics of a Quantum Field Theory (QFT). One compelling approach to understanding this emergence of space is through Entanglement Entropy (EE), computed holographically as proposed by Ryu and Takayanagi in [ 4 , 5 ] ; see also [ 6 ] . In particular, the works [ 7 , 8 ] clearly suggest how space-like coordinates may emerge from a QFT. This naturally raises the question of whether a time-like coordinate could also emerge from strong dynamics. With this motivation (among others), the concept of time-like entanglement entropy (tEE) was introduced in [ 9 , 10 ] . From the holographic point of view, the notion of tEE was originally introduced in order to understand the emergence of time from quantum entanglement in time-like subsystems in QFTs [ 9 , 10 ] , much similar in spirit to the original Ryu and Takayanagi prescription [ 4 , 5 ] where space emerges from quantum entanglement among space-like subsystems. Unlike the usual EE for space-like separated intervals, the analogue of the reduced density matrix (also known as the transition matrix) for time-like separated events is non-Hermitian. Although the computation of tEE in higher dimensional CFTs is a nontrivial task, for 2d CFT this has been obtained following a Wick rotation of the subregion ( A ) associated with the Hilbert space ( \mathcal{H}_{A} ) [ 10 ] . The topic has since become an active area of research, especially within the holographic context. Among the works most influential to our study are [ 11 , 12 , 13 , 14 , 15 , 16 , 17 , 18 , 19 , 20 , 21 ] . In the original studies and subsequent developments, the holographic computation of time-like entanglement entropy involves extremizing a surface in the Euclidean regime (where it coincides with the standard RT-EE), followed by analytic continuation to Lorentzian time. However, this analytic continuation remains conceptually challenging for higher-dimensional QFT d ( d\geq 3 ), particularly in slab or spherical regions. One of the goals of the present work is to address this challenge and offer an alternative prescription for computing time-like entanglement entropy using the holographic prescription for duals to higher-dimensional QFTs—whether conformal or not. Our approach provides a natural transition from Euclidean to Lorentzian (or time-like) entanglement entropy and establishes a framework for mapping QFT features in a real-time formalism. Another achievement of this work is the derivation of analytic expressions that approximate the time-like EE and time-like separation for slab regions, while also offering a criterion for stability and a computable method for predicting potential phase transitions. We further present formulas using tEE to compute central charges of CFTs, following the approach of Liu and Mezei [ 22 , 23 ] . In addition, we explore two holographic duals of confining QFTs and analyse the tEE and its associated phase transitions in these models. In the remainder of this section, we recall well-established formulas for the strip time-like entanglement entropy, closely following those derived for Wilson loops (see, for instance, [ 24 ] ). We also provide analytic expressions that approximate the time-like EE and the time-like separation, and we formulate a criterion for the stability of the entangling surface in the bulk. Consider a string background (the extension to eleven dimensions is immediate), holographically dual to a QFT in d space-time dimensions. The string frame metric and dilaton read (there are Ramond and Neveu-Schwarz fields that we do not quote), \displaystyle ds_{st}^{2}=f(u,\vec{y})\Bigg[\lambda dt^{2}+d\vec{x}_{d-2}^{2}+dv^{2}+g(u)du^{2}\Bigg] \displaystyle~~~~~~~~~~~~~+g_{ij,(9-d)}(u,\vec{y})dy^{i}dy^{j},~~\Phi(u,\vec{y}). (1) We introduced the parameter \lambda=\pm 1 to indicate Euclidean metrics, with isometry SO(d) or Lorentzian ones, with isometry SO(1,d-1) . This assumption can be relaxed and is discussed in the confining models studied below. We embed an eight-surface \Sigma_{8} parameterised by the coordinates [\vec{x}_{d-2},\vec{y}_{9-d},u] , with v=\text{constant} and t=t(u) . The induced metric of the eight-manifold is, \displaystyle ds_{\Sigma_{8}}^{2}=f(u,\vec{y})\Bigg[d\vec{x}_{d-2}^{2}+(g(u)+\lambda t^{\prime 2})du^{2}\Bigg] \displaystyle~~~~~~~~~~+~g_{ij,(9-d)}dy^{i}dy^{j}. \displaystyle\det[g_{\Sigma_{8}}]=f(u,\vec{y})^{d-1}\det[g_{9-d}](g(u)+\lambda t^{\prime 2}).\ (2) We calculate the time-like entanglement entropy for a strip (or slab) region as, \displaystyle S_{tEE}=\frac{1}{4G_{N}}\int d^{9-d}yd^{d-2}x~du\sqrt{e^{-4\Phi}\det g_{\Sigma_{8}}}. (3) \displaystyle S_{tEE}=\frac{\int d^{d-2}x}{4G_{N}}\int du\times \displaystyle\int d^{9-d}y\sqrt{e^{-4\Phi(u,\vec{y})}f(u,\vec{y})^{d-1}\det[g_{9-d}](g(u)+\lambda t^{\prime 2}).} The evaluation of the integral over the (d-2) coordinates represented by \vec{x} is immediate (as they are isometric coordinates). Less trivial could be the evaluation over the (9-d) coordinates represented by \vec{y} . It usually occurs that the expression e^{-4\Phi(u,\vec{y})}f(u,\vec{y})^{d-1}\det[g_{9-d}] factorises into a function of \vec{y} times a function of the radial coordinate u . This is the case in the examples discussed below and in those studied in the forthcoming work [ 25 ] . After evaluating the integrals over the seven coordinates (\vec{y},\vec{x}) we arrive at a generic expression for the time-like entropy on slab-regions, \displaystyle S_{tEE}=\frac{{\cal N}}{4G_{10}}\int_{u_{0}}^{\infty}du\sqrt{G^{2}+F^{2}t^{\prime 2}(u)}, (4) Here \cal N is a constant, F,G are functions of the radial coordinate u . One can define a function {\cal V} in terms of which the separation between the two regions is expressed. The function and the time-like separation in the case of a strip are \displaystyle{\cal V}=\frac{F(u)}{G(u)F(u_{0})}\sqrt{F^{2}(u)-F^{2}(u_{0})}, (5) \displaystyle T=2\int_{u_{0}}^{\infty}\frac{du}{\cal V}. Using a first integral of the equations of motion derived from eq.( 4 ), the time-like entanglement entropy reads, \displaystyle\frac{4G_{10}}{\cal N}S_{tEE}=F(u_{0})T+ \displaystyle 2\int_{u_{0}}^{\infty}du\frac{G(u)}{F(u)}\sqrt{F^{2}(u)-F^{2}(u_{0})}-2\int_{u_{*}}^{\infty}G(u)du \displaystyle=2\int_{u_{0}}^{\infty}\!\!du\frac{F(u)G(u)}{\sqrt{F^{2}(u)-F^{2}(u_{0})}}-2\int_{u_{*}}^{\infty}\!\!G(u)du. (6) Usually, analytically evaluating the integrals in eqs.( 5 )-( 6 ) is not possible. There are approximate expressions that are very useful. For the time separation T in the case of the strip the expression proposed in [ 26 ] reads, T_{app}=\frac{\pi G(u)}{F^{\prime}(u)}\Bigg|_{u=u_{0}}. (7) A useful quantity indicating whether the embedding is stable under fluctuations was proposed in [ 27 ] . This quantity is Z(u_{0})=\frac{d}{du}\left(\frac{\pi G(u)}{F^{\prime}(u)}\right)\Big|_{u=u_{0}}. (8) In fact, stability of the embedding is implied by Z(u_{0})<0 , on the other hand for positive Z(u_{0}) the embedding is unstable [ 27 ] . This criterium for stability can be proven using the formal similarity between the action for a generic Wilson loop and that of the time-like EE in eq.( 4 ). The proof is presented in [ 25 ] . Intuitively, it can be understood as follows: if the time-separation is not monotonically increasing towards smaller values of u_{0} , there is a value of u_{0} for which there are two possible time-separations. Characteristically, this leads to a competition between embeddings and a phase transition. This is encoded by the derivative of the time separation turning positive Z(u_{0})>0 . We discuss examples of this phase transition in the confining models discussed below.