Investment Decisions for Perfect and Imperfect Competition in Ireland’s Electricity Market

Davoud Hosseinnezhad \orcidID 0000-0002-4011-776X Mel T. Devine \orcidID 0009-0009-2393-3026 Seán McGarraghy \orcidID 0000-0001-9906-8635 · 2025

Read Investment Decisions for Perfect and Imperfect Competition in Ireland’s Electricity Market by Davoud Hosseinnezhad \orcidID 0000-0002-4011-776X Mel T. Devine \orcidID 0009-0009-2393-3026 Seán McGarraghy \orcidID 0000-0001-9906-8635 (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-20077.txt.

Introduction

Davoud Hosseinnezhad, Mel Devine, and Sean McGarraghy model, in a 2025 paper, how power firms pick builds in Ireland's electricity market under two trade rules. One frame is perfect competition, where no firm can move the price. The other is a Nash-Cournot frame, where each firm weighs how its output moves price. Price in both rests on firm and tech caps, and on a cap for non-synced green power in the grid. That last cap shows the true bounds of wind and sun at scale. Both frames are cast as one-goal sums to solve.

A start-stop cost layer is added to the perfect frame, with on-off calls per plant. Three demand paths, drawn from Ireland's 2023 to 2033 plans, test the pair. Build picks, carbon output, and green share split by frame in clear ways.

Catalog record

CREATORDavoud Hosseinnezhad \orcidID 0000-0002-4011-776X Mel T. Devine \orcidID 0009-0009-2393-3026 Seán McGarraghy \orcidID 0000-0001-9906-8635
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE24 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-20077

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Investment Decisions for Perfect and Imperfect Competition in Ireland’s Electricity Market Davoud Hosseinnezhad \orcidID 0000-0002-4011-776X Mel T. Devine \orcidID 0009-0009-2393-3026 Seán McGarraghy \orcidID 0000-0001-9906-8635 Abstract This paper employs a game-theoretic approach to analyze investment decisions in Ireland’s electricity market. It compares optimal electricity investment strategies among energy generators under a perfect competition framework with an imperfect Nash-Cournot competition. The model incorporates market price based on competition among generators while accounting for supply capacity of each firm and each technology, along with the System Non-Synchronous Penetration (SNSP) constraint to reflect operational limitations in the renewable energy contribution to the power system. Both models are formulated as single-objective function optimization problems. Furthermore, unit commitment constraints are introduced to the perfect competition model allowing the model to incorporate binary decision variables to capture energy unit scheduling decisions of online status, startup, and shutdown costs. The proposed models are evaluated under three different demand test cases, using Ireland’s electricity generation projections for 2023-2033. The results highlight key differences in investment decisions, C ​ O 2 CO_{2} emissions, and the contribution of renewable technologies in perfect and imperfect competition structures. The findings provide managerial insights for policy makers and stakeholders, supporting optimal investment decisions and generation capacity planning to achieve Ireland’s long-term energy objectives. Keywords Energy Market, Competition Models, Unit Commitment Constraints 1 Introduction Game theory is widely used in the Operations Research literature on energy markets to analyze strategic interactions among market participants pozo2017bilevel . A primary distinction in this domain lies between perfect competition and imperfect competition , which influence market dynamics, pricing mechanisms, and participant behavior. These classifications determine whether energy suppliers act as price-takers or price-makers, shaping their strategic decision-making and overall market outcomes tomic2024perfect . In a perfectly competitive energy market, all participants are price-takers, meaning they accept the market price as given and have no ability to influence it. This model assumes a large number of suppliers offering homogeneous products, leading to a perfectly elastic demand curve for each supplier rozas2024comparative . Perfect competition models are often used to analyze markets in which individual energy suppliers have small market shares and prices are determined solely by aggregate supply and demand budzinski2024perfect ; devine2024analysing . Perfect competition models can be formulated as cost minimization problems or equivalently social welfare maximization problems egging2020solving . Unlike models based on Nash-Cournot competition or equilibrium concepts, cost minimization does not incorporate strategic competition among firms, as it assumes a centralized approach where demand is determined externally devine2012rolling . This method has been widely applied in various market models sundarajoo2023under ; faranda2007load . Social welfare maximization is also applied to energy market problems to address perfectly competitive market structures egging2020solving ; devine2016rolling ; ramnath2021social . Incorporating integer variables into energy market models allows the representation of key operational constraints, such as unit commitment and generation scheduling kercci2020impact . The perfect competition with unit commitment problem is a critical aspect of power system dispatch, determining which generators should be online at any given time while accounting for operational constraints such as startup and online costs devine2023cournot . Previous studies, such as tuohy2009unit , have explored the integration of renewable generation into unit commitment models, while more recent works (e.g wu2023novel ; ali2024multi ; zhang2023two ) focus on developing efficient solution techniques for these models. See montero2022review for a comprehensive review of unit commitment problems and approaches. Imperfect competition, in contrast, captures market structures where certain participants can influence prices, acting as price-makers. These suppliers strategically adjust production quantities or prices to maximize profits while anticipating competitors’ responses. Imperfect competition is common in oligopolistic markets, where some companies have important market power allowing them to influence market prices through their decisions and are aware of this influence pozo2017bilevel . Imperfect competition models are also used to model capacity restrictions and transmission limits ruiz2011equilibria ; gonzalez2022transmission . These models pose greater challenges in incorporating integer variables. However, some exceptions exist, such as the work by devine2023cournot . Imperfect competition can be categorized into different types based on how participants make decisions. Cournot competition , Bertrand competition , and Supply Function Equilibria (SFE) are three main imperfect competition models discussed in the literature pozo2017bilevel . Cournot competition models formulate firms competing by deciding on energy generation quantities. It is foundational in studying oligopolistic markets, where firms compete based on output rather than price. Each firm selects its generation level to maximize its profit, considering how its decisions influence market prices and the strategies of competitors. Equilibrium is reached when no firm can unilaterally increase its profit by adjusting its production. Unlike perfectly competitive markets, where firms have no market power and take the market-clearing price as given, Cournot competition assumes that firms recognize their influence on prices. Market prices are determined by the inverse demand function, reflecting the aggregate supply decisions of all firms trebicka2014imperfect ; hobbs2002linear . Nash-Cournot games can be solved as a quadratic programming problem, assuming the principles of symmetry are met egging2020solving . While Cournot competition models are preferred when adjusting production quantities is complex, Bertrand models suit markets with flexible pricing gabriel2012complementarity . saukh2020modelling ; cartuyvels2024market applied the Bertrand model in electricity markets. SFE models examine electricity markets where firms submit supply curves based on price and quantity. SFE outcomes resemble Cournot equilibria during peak demand and Bertrand equilibria in off-peak periods pozo2017bilevel . See wei2023supply ; mokhtari2021impact for a review of SFE models for electricity markets. Both perfect competition and imperfect competition models can be formulated and solved using either single-level optimization approaches or bi-level optimization approaches . In bi-level optimization, decisions are made in a hierarchical sequence of leader-follower decisions. This framework, known as Stackelberg equilibrium , is widely applied in power system models, such as strategic bidding lei2023data and generation investment weibelzahl2020optimal . A more complex extension, the multiple-leader-multiple-follower equilibrium, involves interactions between multiple decision-makers at both levels, often modeled using Equilibrium Problem with Equilibrium Constraints (EPEC) luna2023regularized ; devine2023strategic . However, EPEC models are computationally challenging, especially for large-scale systems. The contribution of this work can be expressed by reviewing relevant studies. devine2023cournot consider perfect and imperfect competition, and also unit commitment model, using detailed data on the Irish electricity system. However, their work does not incorporate long-term investment decisions. helisto2019backbone include unit commitment constraints and investment decisions with detailed Irish system data but do not model imperfect competition. devine2024analysing incorporate investment decisions in both perfect competition and imperfect frameworks, but their analysis is limited to toy data and does not compare outcomes with a unit commitment model. Building on these studies, we employ a single-level optimization approach and develop game-theoretic models for Ireland’s electricity market to analyze decisions for both perfect and imperfect competition models. Furthermore, the perfect competition model is extended by incorporating unit commitment constraints, where startup and no-load costs are modeled using binary variables. The key contribution of this study lies in integrating long-term investment decisions within both perfect and imperfect competition models, using detailed Irish market data and benchmarking the outcomes against a unit commitment model. Such an approach has not been seen in the literature to date. The remainder of this paper is structured as follows. Section 2 introduces the Irish energy market problem,

Read the complete text