Viability of general relativity and modified gravity cosmologies using high-redshift cosmic probes
Fernanda Oliveira, Bruno Ribeiro, Wiliam S. Hipólito-Ricaldi, Felipe Avila, Armando Bernui · 2025
Read Viability of general relativity and modified gravity cosmologies using high-redshift cosmic probes by Fernanda Oliveira, Bruno Ribeiro, Wiliam S. Hipólito-Ricaldi, Felipe Avila, Armando Bernui (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-19960.txt.
Introduction
Fernanda Oliveira and co-authors test rival theories of cosmic gravity against the deepest data available. Einstein's relativity and several modified rivals all mimic the standard model closely. High-redshift probes, looking far back in time, may finally separate them.
The team confronts the models with expansion rates, distance measures, and the growth of structure. Both fitted and model-free methods are used. Background data alone barely split the rivals. Adding growth data exposed small but real deviations. Three alternatives, a non-flat standard model, a dark-energy variant, and an F(Q) model, stayed well supported. The universe's far past remains a sharp testing ground. More growth data will sharpen the verdict.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Fernanda Oliveira, Bruno Ribeiro, Wiliam S. Hipólito-Ricaldi, Felipe Avila, Armando Bernui |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 39 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-19960
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Viability of general relativity and modified gravity cosmologies using high-redshift cosmic probes Fernanda Oliveira, Bruno Ribeiro, Wiliam S. Hipólito-Ricaldi, Felipe Avila, Armando Bernui Abstract Several models based on General Relativity and Modified Gravity aim to reproduce the observed universe with precision comparable to the standard flat- Λ \Lambda CDM model. In this study, we investigate the consistency of some of these models with current high-redshift cosmic data, assessing their ability to simultaneously describe both the background expansion and matter clustering, using measurements of the Hubble parameter H ( z ) H(z) , the luminosity distance D L ( z ) D_{L}(z) , and the growth rate of structures [ f σ 8 ] ( z ) [f\sigma_{8}](z) through parametric and non-parametric methods. Our results indicate that background observables alone offer limited capacity to distinguish between models, while the inclusion of growth of structures data proves useful in revealing deviations, even if small. An F ( Q ) F(Q) model, the non-flat Λ \Lambda CDM and the ω \omega CDM emerge as alternatives well supported by data, closely matching the growth data and showing performance comparable to Λ \Lambda CDM, as revealed by the Akaike Information Criterion. In contrast, F ( R ) F(R) models are strongly disfavored compared to Λ \Lambda CDM and F ( Q ) F(Q) . These analyses illustrate the usefulness of both parametric and non-parametric approaches to explore the observational viability of alternative cosmological models. I Introduction The flat- \Lambda CDM, often termed the cosmological concordance model, successfully reproduces the features observed in diverse cosmological observables across different epochs of the universe’s evolution; from primordial times, through the growth of matter clustering at large-scales, to the recent phase of accelerated expansion Frieman et al. 2008 ; Basilakos et al. 2009 ; Weinberg et al. 2013 . However, the flat- \Lambda CDM model 1 1 1 In what follows we call this model simply \Lambda CDM. is not the final model. There are still several issues to be elucidated, such as the physical nature of dark matter and dark energy, or the cosmological tensions, for instance Di Valentino et al. 2021a ; Perivolaropoulos and Skara 2022 ; Di Valentino et al. 2021b ; Adil et al. 2024 ; Di Valentino et al. 2025 . In recent years, several cosmological models have been proposed with the aim of addressing these problems. On the one hand, these proposals include extensions of the \Lambda CDM model, as well as dynamical dark energy models based on General Relativity (GR). In fact, recent results suggest that GR-based models with an evolving equation of state constitute competitive alternatives to the \Lambda CDM model ( Abdul-Karim et al. 2025 ) . On the other hand, there are modified gravity (MG) theories, such as F(R) ( Clifton et al. 2012 ) and F(Q) ( Jiménez et al. 2020 ) , that are currently being tested 2 2 2 Note that other approaches have also been explored, including for example, unified dark sector models, quintessence, dark matter-dark energy interacting models, other alternative formulations of gravity theories, etc. (see, e.g., Wang et al. 2024 ; Zuñiga Vargas et al. 2012 ; Romero Fuño et al. 2016 ; Oks 2021 ; Tsujikawa 2013 ; Cai et al. 2016 ; Bertini et al. 2020 ; Hipólito-Ricaldi et al. 2024 ). . The so-called F(R) theories are extensions of Einstein’s GR theory, obtained by replacing the term R-2\Lambda in the Einstein-Hilbert (EH) Lagrangian with a generic function of the Ricci scalar R , denoted F(R) . In contrast, F(Q) theories are generalizations of the symmetric teleparallel formulation of GR, which is characterized by a connection in which both curvature and torsion vanish, where gravity, instead, is described by a non-metricity scalar Q ( Khyllep et al. 2021 ) . Our aim in this work is to analyze the viability of alternative cosmological models and to search for observational hints that might shed light on the nature of dark energy or reveal a preference for GR or its possible modifications. We consider GR-based models and MG theories such as F(R) and F(Q) , using cosmological data including cosmic chronometers (CC), Type Ia Supernovae (SNIa) at the background level, and [f\sigma_{8}](z) , the normalized growth rate at the perturbative level. Our approach employs two well-known methods for statistical analysis: the Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) and Gaussian Processes (GPs) Seikel et al. 2012 ; Jesus et al. 2020 . We use the cosmological data and MCMC analysis to obtain the best-fit parameter values for a given cosmological model. These results are then compared with model-independent reconstructions from GPs, allowing us to test the consistency and robustness of the MCMC fits without assuming any specific model. In fact, this comparison can reveal discrepancies suggestive of tensions between the model and the data. If the MCMC best-fit model falls to reproduce the GPs reconstructions, it may suggest that the model lacks the flexibility to capture all features in the data, or equivalently, that the data contain information not explained by the model. After gaining some knowledge with this comparison, we use MCMC results and the Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) to contrast different models based on GR and MG theories. The models to be contrasted include the GR-based models: \omega CDM ( Barboza 2010 ) , with a constant equation of state for dark energy; the Chevallier-Polarski-Linder (CPL) parametrization, with a time-varying equation of state, \omega_{0}\omega_{a} CDM ( Chevallier and Polarski 2001 ; Linder 2003 ) ; and an extended \Lambda CDM including spatial curvature, \Omega_{k} -CDM. We also consider F(R) modified gravity models such as Starobinsky ( Starobinsky 2007 ) , Hu-Sawicki ( Hu and Sawicki 2007 ) , and the R^{2} -Corrected Appleby-Battye ( Appleby and Battye 2007 ; Appleby et al. 2010 ) . In addition, we study one F(Q) model, which features background evolution identical to GR ( Barros et al. 2020 ) . All these models are compared to the \Lambda CDM and rely on Friedmann-Lemaître-Robertson-Walker (FLRW) symmetries 3 3 3 Although possible deviations from the cosmological principle have been reported ( Kester et al. 2024 ; Bernui et al. 2014 ) . . This work is organized as follows: In Section II , we briefly present the data and cosmological observables used. The Section III outlines the basics of the MCMC and GPs methodologies. In Section IV , we summarize main properties of the alternative models analyzed in this work. Our results are presented and discussed in Section V , and finally, our conclusions are presented in Section VI . II Cosmological observables and data Throughout this work, we consider three datasets: H(z) measurements from CC ( Niu et al. 2024 ) , luminosity distance (or distance modulus) measurements from SNIa ( Scolnic et al. 2022 ) , and [f\sigma_{8}](z) measurements. Tables containing CC and [f\sigma_{8}](z) data used in this work are provided in Appendix A , and SNIa data can be found in ( Brout et al. 2022 ) . For H(z) , we use 31 measurements obtained using the cosmic chronometers technique (CC), a method that does not assume any cosmological model Stern et al. 2010 . The CC technique