Do multifrequency polarimetric observations of BL Lac exclude a hadronic origin of its X-ray emission?
F. Tavecchio, F. Bolis, E. Sobacchi, S. Boula, A. Sciaccaluga · 2025
Read Do multifrequency polarimetric observations of BL Lac exclude a hadronic origin of its X-ray emission? by F. Tavecchio, F. Bolis, E. Sobacchi, S. Boula, A. Sciaccaluga (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-19784.txt.
Introduction
Tavecchio and co-authors (2025) revisit a claim about the blazar BL Lac, the prototype of its class. Recent multi-frequency observations found its light strongly polarized in the optical band, averaging 25 percent and reaching 45 percent, but weakly polarized in X-rays, below 7 percent. That contrast was read as proof X-rays come from electrons scattering light, and as ruling out proton models.
They offer a different reading. In their framework, all the radiation is synchrotron light: electrons make the radio-to-optical part, and protons make the X-rays and gamma rays. They take the jet's field from a model of magnetically dominated, steady outflows. In that setup, proton-made X-rays come out less polarized than electron-made optical light. The observations, they conclude, do not exclude a hadronic origin; the polarization pattern depends on the field structure, not just on which particle radiates.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | F. Tavecchio, F. Bolis, E. Sobacchi, S. Boula, A. Sciaccaluga |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 30 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-19784
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
Do multifrequency polarimetric observations of BL Lac exclude a hadronic origin of its X-ray emission? F. Tavecchio, F. Bolis, E. Sobacchi, S. Boula, A. Sciaccaluga Abstract Recent multifrequency polarimetric observations of the eponymous blazar BL Lac reveal an extremely large degree of polarization in the optical band (average of 25 % 25\% , reaching 45 % 45\% ), together with a small ( ≲ 7 % \lesssim 7\% ) degree of polarization in the X-ray band. This has been interpreted as evidence that the X-rays are produced through inverse Compton emission by relativistic electrons, thus ruling out alternative models based on hadronic processes. Here we revisit the observational evidence, interpreting it in a framework where the observed radiation is entirely produced through synchrotron emission. Electrons produce the radio-to-optical component and protons produce the X-rays and the gamma-rays. We determine the jet magnetic fields from an MHD model of magnetically dominated stationary axisymmetric outflows, and show that the X-ray emission from the protons is naturally less polarized than the optical emission from the electrons. The model parameters required to reproduce the multifrequency polarimetric observations are fully compatible with blazar jets. 1 Introduction Relativistic jets produced by active galactic nuclei (AGN) represent ideal laboratories for addressing several topics related to black hole physics, particle acceleration, and high-energy (and possible multimessenger) emission ( Blandford et al. 2019 , e.g.,) . Jets are best studied in blazars, where favorable geometrical alignment leads to relativistic amplification of the non-thermal radiation produced in the jet by relativistic particles ( Romero et al. 2017 ) . Blazars are characterized by a double-humped spectral energy distribution (SED), with the first hump peaking in the IR-soft-X-ray band and the high-energy hump with maximum at gamma-ray energies (e.g. Fossati et al. 1998 ). There is general consensus that the first hump is produced by leptons (electrons or pairs) through synchrotron emission. According to the standard framework ( Sikora et al. 1994 ; Ghisellini et al. 1998 , e.g.,) the same particles upscatter soft radiation, forming the high-energy hump through the inverse Compton (IC) mechanism. A competing scenario assumes instead that the high-energy hump is produced by relativistic hadrons, either through direct proton-synchrotron emission or through synchrotron emission by the by-products of hadronic reactions (see Sol & Zech 2022 for a review). The hadronic scenario is supported by the potential association of some blazars with high-energy neutrinos ( Böttcher 2019 , e.g.,) . The launch of the Imaging X-ray Polarimetry Explorer ( IXPE ) satellite ( Weisskopf et al. 2022 ) allows one to perform multifrequency polarimetric observations of blazars that, in principle, can offer unique clues on the physical processes acting in these sources. In particular, it has been anticipated that the polarimetric properties of the X-ray emission of blazars can be used to determine the emission mechanism responsible for the high-energy hump ( Zhang 2017 ; Peirson et al. 2022 , e.g.,) . This can be done in low- and intermediate-synchrotron-peaked (LSP and ISP, Abdo et al. 2010 ) blazars, where the X-rays trace the raising portion of the high-energy hump. The general idea is that hadronic processes lead to high polarization of the radiation in this band, because X-rays are produced through synchrotron emission, either by high-energy protons or by the by-products of hadronic reactions ( Zhang & Böttcher 2013 ) . On the other hand, leptonic models lead to a smaller polarization because the X-rays are produced through IC emission. IC radiation would be unpolarized when the seed photons are thermal and isotropic, such as photons produced in the central regions of the AGN ( Bonometto & Saggion 1973 ) , and would have a low degree of polarization ( \lesssim 50\% of the degree of polarization of the seed photons) when it is produced through the synchrotron self-Compton (SSC) mechanism ( Poutanen 1994 ; Krawczynski 2012 ) . The comparison between the polarization in the optical band (produced through synchrotron radiation by high-energy electrons) and in the X-ray band would therefore be a powerful diagnostic of the emission mechanism at work. Recently, Agudo et al. 2025 reported multifrequency polarimetric observations of BL Lac, a well studied blazar of the LSP/ISP type. The optical emission, which belongs to the soft tail of the low-energy SED component, showed an exceptionally high (and variable) degree of polarization (average of 25\% , reaching 45%). IXPE obtained a quite constraining upper limit of \sim 7\% for the degree of polarization in the X-ray band, which tracks the raising part of the high-energy SED peak. Agudo et al. 2025 concluded that these measurements strongly support the leptonic scenario, in which the X-rays are produced through IC scattering by the same electrons that produce the radio-to-optical component through synchrotron emission. This result strengthens previous similar results by IXPE for BL Lac ( Middei et al. 2023 ; Peirson et al. 2023 ) and other sources of the LSP class ( Marshall et al. 2024 ) . A follow-up modeling of the source by Liodakis et al. 2025 concludes that, regardless of the jet composition and the assumed emission model, IC scattering from relativistic electrons dominates the X-ray regime. Their study considers four scenarios for the high-energy spectral component: a pure SSC model, a SSC + EC (external Compton) leptonic model, a hybrid model involving SSC and hadronic processes, and a purely hadronic model. Given the relevance of the topic, it is important to investigate more thoroughly the hadronic scenarios, which are disfavored by the studies of Agudo et al. 2025 and Liodakis et al. 2025 . Here we discuss a scenario where the high-energy component is produced by high-energy hadrons (protons in the following) through synchrotron emission ( Aharonian 2000 ; Zech et al. 2017 ; Liodakis & Petropoulou 2020 , e.g.,) . We determine the jet magnetic fields from an MHD model of magnetically dominated stationary axisymmetric outflows ( Vlahakis 2004 ; Lyubarsky 2009 , e.g.,) . The degree of polarization of synchrotron radiation depends on the shape of the jet, the size of the emission region, and the slope of the energy distribution of the emitting particles ( Bolis et al. 2024a ) . We emphasize that the dependence on the slope of the particle distribution is stronger than in the textbook case of a uniform field. The low degree of polarization in the X-ray band is naturally produced by the joint effect of (i) the hard slope of the underlying proton energy distribution and (ii) the larger region encompassed by the slow-cooling protons with respect to the fast-cooling electrons responsible for the optical emission. The paper is organized as follows. In Sect. 2 we present the model and the calculation of the polarization, and in Sect. 3 we discuss the results. Throughout the paper, the following cosmological parameters are assumed: H_{0}=70{\rm\;km\;s}^{-1}{\rm\;Mpc}^{-1} , \Omega_{\rm M}=0.3 , \Omega_{\Lambda}=0.7 . 2 The model 2.1 Model set-up Our aim is to show that multifrequency polarization observations of BL Lac can be explained by a model where the X-rays are produced through the proton-synchrotron mechanism. Our model follows the work of Bolis et al. 2024a , which discusses the polarization of synchrotron radiation from magnetically dominated jets. The main result of that work is the