Belief Attribution as Mental Explanation: The Role of Accuracy, Informativity, and Causality

Lance Ying, Almog Hillel, Ryan Truong, Vikash K. Mansinghka, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Tan Zhi-Xuan · 2025

Read Belief Attribution as Mental Explanation: The Role of Accuracy, Informativity, and Causality by Lance Ying, Almog Hillel, Ryan Truong, Vikash K. Mansinghka, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Tan Zhi-Xuan (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-19376.txt.

Introduction

Ying and a team of colleagues studied in twenty twenty-five how people attribute beliefs to others. Explaining someone's actions often means guessing what they believe. Yet people could attribute many possible beliefs, and the team asked which ones they actually pick.

They built a computer model scoring a belief statement on three factors: accuracy, how much it tells, and causal relevance to the action. People watched an agent collect keys hidden in boxes to reach a goal. They then ranked statements about the agent's beliefs. Accuracy and informativeness together predicted the rankings fairly well. Causal relevance alone predicted them best. The results suggest people favor beliefs that actually explain why the agent acted.

Catalog record

CREATORLance Ying, Almog Hillel, Ryan Truong, Vikash K. Mansinghka, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Tan Zhi-Xuan
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE32 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-19376

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Belief Attribution as Mental Explanation: The Role of Accuracy, Informativity, and Causality Lance Ying, Almog Hillel, Ryan Truong, Vikash K. Mansinghka, Joshua B. Tenenbaum, Tan Zhi-Xuan Abstract A key feature of human theory-of-mind is the ability to attribute beliefs to other agents as mentalistic explanations for their behavior. But given the wide variety of beliefs that agents may hold about the world and the rich language we can use to express them, which specific beliefs are people inclined to attribute to others? In this paper, we investigate the hypothesis that people prefer to attribute beliefs that are good explanations for the behavior they observe. We develop a computational model that quantifies the explanatory strength of a (natural language) statement about an agent’s beliefs via three factors: accuracy, informativity, and causal relevance to actions, each of which can be computed from a probabilistic generative model of belief-driven behavior. Using this model, we study the role of each factor in how people selectively attribute beliefs to other agents. We investigate this via an experiment where participants watch an agent collect keys hidden in boxes in order to reach a goal, then rank a set of statements describing the agent’s beliefs about the boxes’ contents. We find that accuracy and informativity perform reasonably well at predicting these rankings when combined, but that causal relevance is the single factor that best explains participants’ responses. Keywords: theory of mind; mental explanation; belief attribution; causal attribution; communication; social inference Introduction Suppose you are watching your friend Sally upend her fruit basket in an effort to find her lost keys, when your mutual friend Anne walks in and asks what in the world Sally is thinking. How would you be inclined to describe Sally’s beliefs? Although there are a great many beliefs that Sally likely holds --- that she owns a fruit basket, that her fruit basket is now upended, and that she has lost her keys --- none of these seem quite as apt as the explanation that she believes she might have lost her keys in her fruit basket. † † Presented as a conference paper at CogSci 2025 This tendency to attribute beliefs that are good explanations for other agents’ behavior is highly intuitive, yet understudied. While a large body of literature has investigated how people infer and attribute beliefs to others by exercising their theory-of-mind ( Wimmer & Perner, (1983) ; Onishi & Baillargeon, (2005) ; Baker et al., (2017) ) , and a similarly large of body of work has studied how people generate and evaluate explanations ( Lombrozo, (2006) ; Lombrozo, (2007) ; Kirfel et al., (2024) ) , prior research on how people choose between mental explanations has focused on agent’s goals, intentions and their responsibility for outcomes ( Lagnado et al., (2013) ; Alicke et al., (2015) ; Chandra et al., (2024) ; S.A. Wu et al., (2023) ) . In contrast, selective belief attribution and its relationship with explanation generation have received limited attention. Figure 1: An example scenario in our belief attribution experiment. An animation on the left shows a player in a treasure game, who is trying to find a blue key to unlock the blue door to retrieve the gold chest. On the right, participants are asked to rank three statements about the player’s beliefs based on their likelihood of attributing each statement. In this paper, we investigate how and whether people attribute beliefs on the basis of their explanatory strength, developing a computational model of selective belief attribution that scores and selects candidate beliefs. We represent candidate belief attributions in natural language, building upon recent extensions of the Bayesian Theory-of-Mind (BToM) framework that provide a grounded compositional semantics for belief statements ( Ying, Zhi-Xuan et al., (2025) ; Ying et al., (2024) ) . Unlike the non-linguistic belief representations in earlier work, ( Baker et al., (2017) ) , this allows us to study how people attribute belief statements that highlight specific aspects of others’ minds. To quantify the explanatory strength of a belief statement, we take inspiration from accounts of explanation as probabilistic inference ( Lombrozo, (2007) ; Wojtowicz & DeDeo, (2020) ) , rational communication ( Chandra et al., (2024) ; Kirfel et al., (2024) ) and causal judgment ( Gerstenberg et al., (2015) ; Gerstenberg & Icard, (2020) ; Quillien & Lucas, (2023) ) , factoring explanatory strength into accuracy, informativity, and causal relevance to an agent’s actions. These factors are computed as probabilistic or causal quantities from a generative model of rational belief-driven action. To evaluate our model, we design an experiment where participants are shown animations of a player character navigating a gridworld puzzle, which requires the player to find keys hidden in boxes that unlock doors to their goal (see Figure 1 ). We recruited participants to watch the player’s actions, and present them with three statements that describe the player’s beliefs about the boxes’ contents. Participants are asked to rank these statements based how likely they would attribute each belief, without any prompting to do so on the basis of explanatory strength. Our model also ranks these statements by each of the explanatory factors, and combinations thereof. By comparing these rankings, we find that accuracy and informativity predict human rankings reasonably well when combined, but that causal relevance is the single factor that best explains how people selectively attribute beliefs. Related Work Computational Models of Belief Attribution Computational accounts of belief attribution include approaches based on epistemic logic ( Shvo et al., (2020) ; Cedegao et al., (2021) ) and Bayesian theory-of-mind (BToM) Baker et al. ((2017)) . Our model builds on the latter framework, which models how observers infer beliefs as Bayesian inference over a generative model of how goals and beliefs guide actions. We leverage a recent extension of this framework that can infer beliefs represented in epistemic language ( Ying et al., (2024) ; Ying, Zhi-Xuan et al., (2025) ) , allowing us to represent a much richer set of belief attributions. While prior work in the BToM paradigm focuses on assessing the probability that an agent holds a specific belief, we study the selective attribution of beliefs, which we model as explanatory choice. To do so, we use the fact that a generative theory-of-mind is also a causal model, allowing us to evaluate the effect of hypothetical interventions on agents’ minds ( Ho et al., (2022) ; Chen et al., (2024) ; S. Wu et al., (2024) ) . We use this to quantify the causal relevance of a belief on an agent’s actions, alongside non-causal quantities. Generating and Evaluating Explanations Our model draws upon several accounts how people evaluate or select between explanations. Bayesian accounts capture how people adjudicate between multiple competing explanations ( Lombrozo, (2007) ; Wojtowicz & DeDeo, (2020) ) . Communicative accounts model whether an explanation is helpful to an (implied) listener ( Chandra et al., (2024) ; Machino et al., (2024) ) , pragmatically trading off between accuracy and informativity ( Scontras et al., (2021) ; Quillien & Lucas, (2022) ) . Causal accounts emphasize the fact good explanations are not just probable, but also causally relevant to the observations explained ( Gerstenberg et al., (2015) ; Gerstenberg

Read the complete text