PatentMind: A Multi-Aspect Reasoning Graph for Patent Similarity Evaluation
Yongmin Yoo, Qiongkai Xu, Longbing Cao · 2025
Read PatentMind: A Multi-Aspect Reasoning Graph for Patent Similarity Evaluation by Yongmin Yoo, Qiongkai Xu, Longbing Cao (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-19347.txt.
Introduction
Yongmin Yoo, Qiongkai Xu, and Longbing Cao build PatentMind, a frame that judges how alike two patents are, by a graph of thought across many sides. Their paper is from two thousand twenty-five.
Patent likeness is key to work on who owns what. Past ways miss the rich build of a patent, which joins tech traits, legal bounds, and use fields. PatentMind splits each patent into those three sides and scores each side on its graph. The scores are then weighed by a step that reads the case's cues, in the way an expert would. The team built a test set of five hundred pairs, marked by people. Their scores tracked expert marks with high accord.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Yongmin Yoo, Qiongkai Xu, Longbing Cao |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 55 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-19347
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
PatentMind: A Multi-Aspect Reasoning Graph for Patent Similarity Evaluation Yongmin Yoo, Qiongkai Xu, Longbing Cao Abstract Patent similarity evaluation plays a critical role in intellectual property analysis. However, existing methods often overlook the intricate structure of patent documents, which integrate technical specifications, legal boundaries, and application contexts. We introduce PatentMind, a novel framework for patent similarity assessment based on a Multi-Aspect Reasoning Graph (MARG). PatentMind decomposes patents into three core dimensions: technical feature, application domain, and claim scope, to compute dimension-specific similarity scores. These scores are dynamically weighted through a four-stage reasoning process which integrates contextual signals to emulate expert-level judgment. To support evaluation, we construct PatentSimBench, a human-annotated benchmark comprising 500 patent pairs. Experimental results demonstrate that PatentMind achieves a strong correlation ( r = 0.938 r=0.938 ) with expert annotations, significantly outperforming embedding-based models and advanced prompt engineering methods.These results highlight the effectiveness of modular reasoning frameworks in overcoming key limitations of embedding-based methods for analyzing patent similarity. 1 Introduction Patent documents pose significant challenges for NLP-based similarity evaluation due to specialized domain knowledge, intricate legal language, and complex structural formats ( Aslanyan and Wetherbee 2022 ; Kanade and Fox 2007 ; Casola and Lavelli 2021 ; Lupu and Hanbury 2011 ) . Accurate evaluation of patent similarity is crucial for identifying prior art, assessing infringement risks, and determining the novelty of innovations ( Feng 2020 ; Helmers et al. 2019 ; Arts et al. 2018 ; Wang et al. 2023 ) . Given that inaccuracies can lead to overlooked prior art, invalid patent grants, or undetected infringements, robust and interpretable evaluation methods are essential. Moreover, the rapidly growing volume of patent applications across diverse technological fields further intensifies the need for reliable similarity evaluation techniques ( Jiang and Goetz 2024 ) . Given the increasing reliance on patent analytics for R&D strategy, legal risk assessment, and competitive intelligence, developing accurate and interpretable similarity models has become critically important in both industry and academia ( Hain et al. 2022 ; Lu et al. 2020 ; Yoo et al. 2023 ) . Figure 1: The comparison between multi-aspect reasoning and embedding-based similarity methods. Early keyword-based methods, such as bag-of-words models, often fail to capture nuanced semantics and technical specificity of patent documents, resulting in ineffective representations ( D’hondt et al. 2013 ) . To overcome these semantic limitations, recent approaches predominantly rely on embedding-based methods, including static word embeddings and transformer-based contextual embeddings ( Lee and Hsiang 2020 ; Reimers and Gurevych 2019 ) . However, embedding-based methods compress patent texts into dense vectors, which can obscure critical distinctions and lack interpretability. In contrast, our approach explicitly models similarity through structured reasoning across technical, legal, and application-specific dimensions, closely reflecting how human experts evaluate patent proximity. Such interpretability and precision are particularly critical in legal or technical decision-making contexts ( Miric et al. 2023 ; Bekamiri et al. 2022 ) . Recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated considerable promise in reasoning-based tasks, offering a compelling alternative to traditional embedding-based approaches. Unlike fixed embedding methods, LLMs support dynamic reasoning and nuanced semantic comprehension, facilitating more sophisticated similarity assessments. However, directly applying general-purpose LLMs to patent similarity tasks remains challenging due to specialized terminology and complex features inherent in patent texts ( Ikoma and Mitamura 2025 ; Ascione and Sterzi 2024 ) . Moreover, these models often lack domain-specific legal and technical expertise necessary for accurate analysis. Although recent prompting methods for LLMs have partially mitigated the limitations of static embeddings by enabling dynamic contextual analysis, they continue to struggle with domain-specific terminology and processing key patent sections such as titles, abstracts, and claims. In this work, we propose PatentMind, a novel patent similarity evaluation framework structured as a Multi-Aspect Reasoning Graph (MARG). By leveraging LLM-based multi-step reasoning, PatentMind performs dimension-aware similarity assessments, closely emulating the analytical processes of patent attorneys. Specifically, MARG decomposes patent documents into three essential dimensions: technical features, application domains, and claim scopes. Each dimension is independently analyzed to generate similarity scores, which are then integrated using a context-aware dynamic weighting module consisting of four reasoning stages: Domain Relationship Analysis, Information Distribution, Dimension Relevance, and Cross-Validation. This multidimensional approach mirrors real-world patent examination practices, which evaluate technical details, application contexts, and legal claims in accordance with established standards for prior art analysis ( USPTO 2023 ) . Consequently, PatentMind effectively captures subtle distinctions across the diverse attributes of patents. Our empirical evaluations demonstrate that PatentMind, implemented with GPT-4o-mini as the underlying LLM, achieves a Pearson correlation of 0.938 with expert evaluations, significantly surpassing embedding and LLM-based prompting baselines. To facilitate rigorous evaluation, we introduce PatentSimBench as the first expert-annotated patent similarity benchmark that reflects real-world criteria employed by patent examiners and attorneys. By explicitly modeling technical, legal, and contextual aspects through interpretable reasoning, PatentSimBench and PatentMind collectively address key limitations of prior approaches. The key contributions in our research PatentMind are summarized as follows: • Multi-Aspect Reasoning Graph (MARG) : We propose a structured LLM framework that performs modular similarity evaluation across three core dimensions of patent documents and integrates them through interpretable, multi-step reasoning. • Context-Aware Reasoning : We introduce a dynamic weighting mechanism built on multi-step contextual analysis, incorporating domain relationship, score distribution, dimension relevance, and robustness validation. • PatentSimBench Dataset : We release the first publicly available expert-annotated benchmark for patent similarity evaluation, comprising 500 high-quality patent pairs. In contrast to existing datasets lacking expert annotations, PatentSimBench provides rigorously annotated pairs with explicit expert rationales, ensuring robust evaluation and reproducibility. 2 Related Work 2.1 Patent Similarity Evaluation Early approaches to patent similarity evaluation, such as keyword matching and TF-IDF, treated patents as generic texts and often failed to capture their domain-specific structure and terminology ( Tseng et al. 2007 ; Ascione and Sterzi 2024 ) . To address these limitations, vector-based models like Word2Vec and Doc2Vec were introduced to encode semantic relationships within patent corpora ( Jeon et al. 2022 ) . However, these models struggled with challenges such as polysemy and limited domain adaptation. To improve semantic representation, contextualized language models like SciBERT ( Beltagy et al. 2019 ) and PatentBERT ( Lee and Hsiang 2020 ) were developed, offering embeddings tailored for scientific and patent texts. While these models produce more accurate representations, their black-box nature and lack of interpretability hinder their practical application in legal and technical decision-making contexts ( Miric et al. 2023 ; Ascione and Sterzi 2024 ) . To overcome these challenges, we propose PatentMind, a structured and interpretable framework that mimics expert reasoning via modular, dimension-based analysis. By decomposing patents into multiple perspectives and reasoning over each dimension, PatentMind provides transparent, multi-dimensional similarity scores aligned with human judgment criteria, addressing the limitations of opaque, single-vector embeddings. 2.2 Prompt Engineering Prompt engineering has emerged as a key strategy for enabling complex reasoning in LLMs. Chain-of-Thought prompting ( Wei et al. 2022 ) improves sequential reasoning by guiding models through intermediate steps. However, its linear structure limits effectiveness in tasks requiring divergent reasoning. To overcome this, Yao et al. ( Yao et al. 2023 ) proposed the Tree-of-Thoughts framework, which enables exploration of multiple reasoning paths in parallel, enhancing performance on tasks requiring structured deliberation. Additional