A concordance coefficient for lattice data: An application to poverty indices in Chile
Ronny Vallejos, Clemente Ferrer, Jorge Mateu · 2025
Read A concordance coefficient for lattice data: An application to poverty indices in Chile by Ronny Vallejos, Clemente Ferrer, Jorge Mateu (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-18935.txt.
Introduction
Ronny Vallejos, Clemente Ferrer, and Jorge Mateu build a new gauge for how well two maps of the same trait agree across a grid of regions. Their case is poverty rates in Chile, where rival methods give rival maps for the same districts. Agreement tools for such grid data had a gap the authors aim to fill.
Their gauge builds on a family version of an older agreement measure, with weights that honor how regions sway each other. A spatial model of that sway, fit the Bayesian way, drives the math. Applied to two Chilean regions, the method yields poverty rates with high-confidence bands. The work should help judge social measures that live on maps.
Catalog record
| CREATOR | Ronny Vallejos, Clemente Ferrer, Jorge Mateu |
|---|---|
| YEAR | 2025 |
| COLLECTION | PAPERS |
| FORMAT | TXT |
| FILE SIZE | 36 KB |
| VERSION | 1.0 |
| LICENSE | http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/ |
| RIGHTS | CC BY |
| SOURCE | arXiv |
Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-18935
Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel
Full text
The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:
A concordance coefficient for lattice data: An application to poverty indices in Chile Ronny Vallejos, Clemente Ferrer, Jorge Mateu Abstract This paper introduces a novel coefficient for measuring agreement between two lattice sequences observed in the same areal units, motivated by the analysis of different methodologies for measuring poverty rates in Chile. Building on the multivariate concordance coefficient framework, our approach accounts for dependencies in the multivariate lattice process using a non-negative definite matrix of weights, assuming a Multivariate Conditionally Autoregressive (GMCAR) process. We adopt a Bayesian perspective for inference, using summaries from Bayesian estimates. The methodology is illustrated through an analysis of poverty rates in the Metropolitan and Valparaíso regions of Chile, with High Posterior Density (HPD) intervals provided for the poverty rates. This work addresses a methodological gap in the understanding of agreement coefficients and enhances the usability of these measures in the context of social variables typically assessed in areal units. K eywords Bayesian inference \cdot GMCAR process \cdot Lattice data \cdot Multivariate CAR process \cdot Poverty rates 1 Introduction Concordance coefficients, or agreement measures, have gained increasing relevance over the past two decades due to their importance in validating consistency between two or more methods. Specifically, when a new assay or instrument is developed, it is important to assess whether the new assay can reproduce the results of a traditional gold-standard method ( Westgard and Hunt,, 1973 ; Bauer and Kennedy,, 1981 ) . It is well established in the literature that classical techniques, such as the Pearson correlation coefficient, paired t-test, least squares analysis of slope and intercept, coefficient of variation, and intraclass correlation coefficient, do not offer new insights in this context. This is because the discrepancy between methods is measured relative to the 45^{\circ} line through the origin. Building on this principle, Lin, (1989) developed the concordance correlation coefficient to quantify the discrepancy between two sets of measurements generated by different mechanisms. Several extensions and generalizations of Lin’s result have been studied. For instance, King et al., (2007) introduced a new repeated measures concordance coefficient, which not only possesses the necessary properties to measure the overall agreement between two n\times 1 vectors of random variables but also offers a more intuitive appeal compared to the methods previously studied by Chinchilli et al., (1996) . Later, Hiriote and Chinchilli, (2011) extended Lin’s concordance coefficient to multivariate observations in the context of repeated measures. Leal et al., (2019) studied Lin’s type coefficient in the context of local influence assessment. Additionally, Leal et al., (2019) explored a Lin-type coefficient in the assessment of local influence. A compendium of various techniques used in statistical agreement analysis can be found in Lin et al., (2012) and Choudhary and Nagaraja, (2017) Another approach to evaluating agreement between two sets of measurements is the probability of agreement (PA), first introduced in a series of papers by Stevens and Anderson-Cook, (2017) , Stevens et al., (2018) , and Stevens and Lu, (2020) . de Castro and Galea, (2021) developed Bayesian PA methods to compare measurement systems with either homoscedastic or heteroscedastic errors. It is worth noting that the literature on PA is extensive, with numerous applications across various scenarios having been published. Extensions of agreement coefficients for the analysis of spatial data have been the focus of recent investigations. Vallejos et al., (2020) proposed an approach for assessing the agreement between two continuous responses when observations of both variables are georeferenced in space. For an increasing domain sampling scheme, they established the asymptotic normality of the sample spatial concordance coefficient for a bivariate Gaussian process with a Wendland covariance function. An image analysis example was used to illustrate both the strengths and limitations of the method. A generalization of the probability of agreement for geostatistical data was recently explored in Acosta et al., (2024) . Additionally, concordance indices for measuring the correspondence between images have been applied in neuroimaging studies for comparing brain maps ( Alexander-Bloch et al.,, 2018 ; Markello and Misic,, 2021 ) . The extension of agreement indices to lattice data, where observations are associated with areal units rather than point locations, remains an open problem. This paper introduces a coefficient for measuring agreement between two lattice sequences observed in the same areal units. The motivation for this extension arises from the analysis of two different methodologies used to measure poverty rates in Chile. Our coefficient is a modified version of the multivariate coefficient studied by King et al., (2007) , where the dependency of the multivariate lattice process is accounted for using a non-negative definite matrix of weights. To achieve this, we assume that the bivariate process follows a Multivariate Conditionally Autoregressive (GMCAR) process ( Jin et al.,, 2005 ) . Due to the hierarchical structure, the inference is approached from a Bayesian perspective. Since the proposed agreement index is a function of the model parameters, inference is conducted using summaries from the Bayesian estimates. The methodology is illustrated through an analysis of poverty rates in Chile, with HPD intervals provided for the poverty rates in the Metropolitan and Valparaíso regions, the two largest regions in Chile. We believe this work addresses a methodological gap in the understanding of agreement coefficients. The poverty rates enhance the applicability of the coefficient because numerous social variables are commonly measured in areal units, impacting the resources each areal unit (county) receives from the government. The paper is structured as follows. In Section 2, we introduce the poverty dataset and the corresponding poverty rates. Section 3 presents the methodological aspects for constructing the concordance coefficient for lattice data. In Section 4, we briefly outline the Bayesian estimation method for the GMCAR process. Section 5 revisits the analysis of poverty rates and provides a statistical solution for the agreement problem between the Horvitz-Thompson (HT) and Small Area Estimation (SAE) coefficients, which have been calculated for every county in Chile. Finally, Section 6 outlines concluding comments, discussions, and future research directions. 2 The poverty dataset 2.1 Poverty in Chile The eradication of poverty has been a central focus of public policies in Chile, guiding various efforts in this area. Estimates from nationwide surveys indicate, in the recent past ( de Desarrollo Social,, 2012 ) , that the poverty rate has declined since the early 1990s, suggesting some progress towards this goal. However, erratic time series patterns have emerged in small counties, the smallest territorial units in Chile. For extremely small counties, poverty rate estimates are unavailable for certain periods due to the survey design, which traditionally prioritizes accurate estimates for larger regions. To effectively monitor trends, identify key factors, develop impactful public policies, and eliminate poverty at the county level, new methodologies have been introduced since 2011. Chile’s primary source of poverty statistics is the National Socioeconomic Characterization Survey (CASEN), conducted by the Ministry of Social Development every 2 to 3 years since 1987. This survey collects samples from most counties. Socioeconomic data at the county level is crucial for formulating and evaluating public policies, particularly since municipalities serve as the first point of contact for Chileans with their local government. Starting in 2007, regulations were introduced concerning the design of surveys and algorithms. In 2010, an expert committee was formed to provide