Tests of General Relativity with GW230529: a neutron star merging with a lower mass-gap compact object

Elise M. Sänger · 2025

Read Tests of General Relativity with GW230529: a neutron star merging with a lower mass-gap compact object by Elise M. Sänger (2025) in the Tower of Babel, a free online library of public-domain works preserved in clean, searchable text. No sign-up. The full text is served as a plain-text file at a predictable URL, where text is present: https://antarctic-labs.com/tower-of-babel/arxiv-2505-18667.txt.

Introduction

Elise Sanger, writing alone in 2025, tests Einstein's theory of gravity with a gravitational wave signal from a merging pair. One object was most likely a neutron star, and the other a compact object in the lower mass gap.

Sanger ran tests in two frameworks that let the signal drift from what the theory predicts at each stage of the spiral inward. The signal matched the theory for every drift measure. Limits on dipole radiation, an extra form of energy loss some rival theories allow, were very tight. She notes traps in the analysis, such as a clash between drift measures and tide effects. A test of one rival theory gave its best limits to date.

Catalog record

CREATORElise M. Sänger
YEAR2025
COLLECTIONPAPERS
FORMATTXT
FILE SIZE11 KB
VERSION1.0
LICENSEhttp://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/
RIGHTSCC BY
SOURCEarXiv

Source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2505-18667

Browse the full library · About the Tower of Babel

Full text

The opening of the work, from the library's hosted text:

Tests of General Relativity with GW230529: a neutron star merging with a lower mass-gap compact object Elise M. Sänger Abstract We performed tests of General Relativity on gravitational wave signal GW230529_181500, which comes from what is most likely a neutrons star merging with a black hole in the lower mass gap. We used two different frameworks to perform parameterized inspiral tests. We find that the signal is consistent with General Relativity for all deviation parameters and we obtain particularly tight constraints on dipole radiation. We discuss some challenges that arise when analyzing this signal, namely biases due to correlations with tidal effects and the degeneracy between the deviation parameter at Newtonian order and the chirp mass. We also performed a theory-specific test for Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet gravity where we obtain the best constraints on this theory to date. 1 Introduction On 29 May 2023, the LIGO Livingston observatory [ 1 , 2 ] detected the gravitational-wave (GW) signal GW230529_181500 (hereafter GW230529 for briefty) from the merger of what is most likely a neutron star with a black hole in the lower mass-gap [ 3 ] . This signal had a signal-to-noise ratio of 11.6 and a false-alarm rate of less than 1 in 1000 years. Follow-up analyses estimated the source component masses to be 3.6_{-1.1}^{+0.8}\penalty\ \rm{M}_{\odot} and 1.4_{-0.2}^{+0.6}\penalty\ \rm{M}_{\odot} (90% credible interval), which puts the primary squarely in the lower mass gap of \sim 2\textup{ -- }5\penalty\ \rm{M}_{\odot} . GW230529, with the compact object within the hypothesized mass gap, provides an opportunity to test General Relativity (GR) in a region of parameter space previously unexplored by strong-field tests of GR [ 4 , 5 ] . Because of its long inspiral signal, it is especially of interest for tests of GR looking for deviations in the inspiral regime. We therefore performed theory agnostic, parameterized inspiral tests of GR using two different frameworks: the Flexible Theory Independent (FTI) method [ 6 ] and the Test Infrastructure for General Relativity (TIGER) [ 7 ] . To demonstrate the importance of this signal for testing GR, we also performed a theory specific test for Einstein-scalar-Gauss-Bonnet, an alternative theory of gravity. 2 Parameterized inspiral tests of GR The post-Newtonian (PN) formalism can be used to approximate the GW signal from the early inspiral of a compact binary [ 8 ] . The PN approximation expands the waveform in powers of the velocity v , where \mathcal{O}(v^{2n}) relative to leading order is refered to as the n PN order. In GR, the frequency domain phase is then given by \Psi_{\ell m}^{\text{GR}}(f)=2\pi ft_{c}-\phi_{c}-\frac{\pi}{4}+\frac{3}{128\eta v^{5}}\frac{m}{2}\sum_{n=0}^{7}\left(\psi_{n}^{\text{GR}}+\psi_{n(l)}^{\text{GR}}\log v\right)v^{n}, (1) where f is the GW frequency, t_{c},\phi_{c} are the time and phase at coalescence, v=(2\pi fM/m)^{1/3} , M=m_{1}+m_{2} is the detector frame total mass, and \eta=m_{1}m_{2}/M^{2} is the symmetric mass ratio. The (n/2) PN coefficients in GR \psi_{n}^{\text{GR}} and \psi_{n(l)}^{\text{GR}} depend only on the intrinsic parameters of the binary. The GW signal can be descomposed into spherical harmonics and the subscript \ell m denotes the (\ell,m) -mode in the mode decomposition. In beyond-GR theories, these PN coefficients can be different from the ones in GR. We can test for deviations from GR during the inspiral by introducing deviation parameters \delta\hat{\varphi}_{n} and \delta\hat{\varphi}_{n(l)} that are fractional deviations of the corresponding PN coefficients in GR. We introduce absolute deviations instead when the (n/2) PN coefficient vanishes in GR (i.e. for n=-2,1 ). This gives a correction to the frequency domain phase of the form \delta\Psi_{\ell m}(f)=\frac{3}{128\eta v^{5}}\frac{m}{2}\left(\sum_{n=-2}^{7}\delta\hat{\varphi}_{n}\psi_{n}^{\mathrm{GR}}v^{n}+\sum_{n=5}^{6}\delta\hat{\varphi}_{n(l)}\psi_{n(l)}^{\mathrm{GR}}v^{n}\log v\right). (2) GR is recovered in the limit \delta\hat{\varphi}_{n},\delta\hat{\varphi}_{n(l)}\rightarrow 0 . The corrections are only applied to the inspiral portion of the signal and the merger-ringdown is left the same as in GR. We use two different frameworks that can perform this type of test of GR: FTI [ 6 ] and TIGER [ 7 ] . These two differ in their exact implementation of the inspiral test and in the GR waveform models used as a baseline. FTI is only available for aligned spin waveforms so we use the SEOBNRv4 waveform family, while TIGER is specific to the IMRPhenomX waveform family and can use precessing spin waveforms. The main difference in the implementation occurs at the transition from a non-GR inspiral to the GR merger ringdown. These parameterized inspiral tests are typically performed allowing only one deviation parameter to vary at a time. This means the analysis is repeated for each deviation parameter. 3 Results Figure 1: The posterior distributions for the different deviation parameters \delta\hat{\varphi}_{n},\delta\hat{\varphi}_{n(l)} for GW230529. The blue histograms are obtained with TIGER using the IMRPhenomX waveform family. The orange posteriors are results from FTI using the SEOBNRv4 waveform family. The filled violins are for binary black hole waveform models, while the dashed lines are binary neutron star models which include tidal effects for both compact objects, and the red solid line is a neutron star–black hole model with tides only on the secondary. GR is recovered at \delta\hat{\varphi}_{i}=0 , which is indicated by the horizontal gray line. The posteriors for the different deviation parameters are shown in Fig. 1 . Comparing the results of both tests, we see that they are consistent with each other and that all results are consistent with GR except for the 0PN results. We will discuss the 0PN results in more detail below. The bounds obtained for the -1PN, 0.5PN, and 1PN deviation parameters are some of the best to date. The bound obtained for GW230529 on dipole radiation (-1PN) of |\delta\hat{\varphi}_{-2}|\lesssim 8\times 10^{-5} is an order of magnitude tighter than the combined bounds from GWTC-3 [ 5 ] . The only tighter bound obtained with GWs is for the binary neutron star GW170817. Figure 2: The 2D posteriors between the tidal deformabilities \Lambda_{i} and deviation parameters \delta\hat{\varphi}_{7} (dark blue) obtained using a binary neutron star model. The green shaded regions are more realistic ranges for the tides, which, when restricting the posterior to those regions, give the green histogram for the deviation parameter. The light blue histogram is the posterior obtained with a binary black hole model. We see that there is a correlation between the tides and the deviation parameter, which leads to a shift away from GR. When restricting the tides to more reasonable values, this shift disappears. Tidal effects The source of GW230529 is most likely contains a neutron star, so we also performed analyses with waveforms that include tidal effects. The deviation-parameter posteriors obtained with these waveforms are broader and shifted away from GR compared to the results obtained with binary black hole models. In Fig. 2 , we see that this is due to correlations between the deviation parameters and tidal deformabilities \Lambda_{i} . For GW230529, the tidal effects are not well constrained and even allow for unrealistically high values [ 3 ] , leading to the broad and shifted posteriors for \delta\hat{\varphi}_{i} . By constraining the tides to the more realistic values of \Lambda_{1}<300 and \Lambda_{2}<1000 , the shift and broadening (mostly) disappear (see green histogram in Fig. 2 ). We therefore use the results from the BBH waveform models as representative. Figure 3: The posteriors for the chirp mass \mathcal{M}_{c} and 0PN deviation parameter \delta\hat{\varphi}_{0} for zero-noise injections of the maximum likelihood waveform from the corresponding GR run (green), compared

Read the complete text